I Can Read - Discussion

[heavenarc]

Anyone has kids in ICR Yishun or LC in Kathib? Pls provide some feedback is it good? My ds is 6 now.

Appreciate all valuable feedback.

[Felicia09]

heavenarc:

Anyone has kids in ICR Yishun or LC in Kathib? Pls provide some feedback is it good? My ds is 6 now.

Appreciate all valuable feedback.

My 2 girls currently is at ICR at Chong Pang. So far so good and they love their teacher. My no.1 is with ICR for almost 2 yrs.
My No 1 even joined LC @Khatib for 2 terms, dont see any progress for her and she dont really like to join the class. Later on i found that the reason is because the teacher at LC is an ang moh and she cant understand his slang. My no 1 english is quite poor, so it very much depend on your kid. If your kid is english speaking kid, certain teacher with some slang will be ok for them.

[heavenarc]

Thanks Felicia09,

Which level are your child in ICR? Any idea which teacher is better?
Oh no wonder my ds did not like LC after the assessment, thinking back it could be the strong accent. Instead it’s me the mummy who’s impress with their materials.

[Dino mummy]

Felicia09:

heavenarc:

Anyone has kids in ICR Yishun or LC in Kathib? Pls provide some feedback is it good? My ds is 6 now.

Appreciate all valuable feedback.

My 2 girls currently is at ICR at Chong Pang. So far so good and they love their teacher. My no.1 is with ICR for almost 2 yrs.
My No 1 even joined LC @Khatib for 2 terms, dont see any progress for her and she dont really like to join the class. Later on i found that the reason is because the teacher at LC is an ang moh and she cant understand his slang. My no 1 english is quite poor, so it very much depend on your kid. If your kid is english speaking kid, certain teacher with some slang will be ok for them.

I thot all ICR teachers are native speaking teachers, hence most will have a certain accent? That's why they chareg a higher fee.

[Felicia09]

HI heavenarc,

My eldest is at PRP and 2nd one is at TCS. This TCS teacher is just newly joined ICR, so i cant comment much. But previously, my no 1 when she’s in TCS, she was under Teacher Margaret. She’s a nice lady. She’s quite proactive feedback to me on my girl progress in class when she’s just newly join her class. And she managed to understand my girl’s problem (My girl was very poor in english and too shy to speak at that time) and help my girl to be more open up and speak in English. This is the part i likes about this teacher.

[Felicia09]

Hi Dino mum,

My girl previous level in ICR is a singaporean chinese teacher. But if you did not mentioned i din realised seems like this teacher is the only sporean at that centre.

But i heard from my collegue, her son teacher in ICR at another branch also a singaporean lady.

[heavenarc]

thanks felicia09… Think I go check out over this weekend.


Glad that your kids are enjoying their lessons at ICR.

[Dino mummy]

Felicia09:

Hi Dino mum,

My girl previous level in ICR is a singaporean chinese teacher. But if you did not mentioned i din realised seems like this teacher is the only sporean at that centre.

But i heard from my collegue, her son teacher in ICR at another branch also a singaporean lady.

Hi Felicia
That's strange...Native speaking Teacher is a \"selling point\" for ICR, just like LC. I saw all Native teachers at the branch at CCK which my boy attended. If it is not conducted by native speaking teacher, I will go to other phonics school, cheaper. You may want to check it out at your centres, question them on this..I tink their website oso mentioned the classes are conducted by native speaking teachers.
The only 2 chinese lasdies I saw at CCK were the admin staff.

[Felicia09]

Dino mummy:

Felicia09:

Hi Dino mum,

My girl previous level in ICR is a singaporean chinese teacher. But if you did not mentioned i din realised seems like this teacher is the only sporean at that centre.

But i heard from my collegue, her son teacher in ICR at another branch also a singaporean lady.

Hi Felicia
That's strange...Native speaking Teacher is a \"selling point\" for ICR, just like LC. I saw all Native teachers at the branch at CCK which my boy attended. If it is not conducted by native speaking teacher, I will go to other phonics school, cheaper. You may want to check it out at your centres, question them on this..I tink their website oso mentioned the classes are conducted by native speaking teachers.
The only 2 chinese lasdies I saw at CCK were the admin staff.

Hi Dino Mum,
I din know about this. On the 1st trial, my girl was with that sporean teacher and she's comfortable with her tats why i din question much. She's now with a native teacher. But now i suddenly realised actually is 2 sporean teacher at my girls branch as my youngest teacher is a chinese, which i supposed is sporean as well. This teacher just joined this branch not long ago. Ok, i'll check with them on next class. Thanks for alerting me on this.

[luanluancao]

hi, my girl started ICR when she was 4, that time she knew phonics for single letters, but still not able to read at all. after attending ICR for 1 year, she was in ICR program ( the level with 6 books, and all stories are marked with sound codes). i had to admit that the previous 1 year class, in fact i did not see much improvement. she basically go for the class, play some phonic games, do some oral presentation, and some home work, that’s it. but these series of 6 books are super super amazing. each book only takes 1 month to complete, and she is able to read very well after book 3 on her own. and the spelling words given in the book are very well selected. i just need to read the words, and she can figure out how to spell it herself. at first she still need to refer to the sound code given, after book 2, she can read words on other books without the coding. pretty amazing.


for your case, i guess the ICR program might be too simple for your P1 girl. cuz my girl was promoted to ICR when she was in K1, and now she is completing the 6 books when she is in K2 term 1. she do have classmates who are in P1 right now. but i guess it might work better on your 5yo girl. personally i felt no need to go for any particular teacher, those native speaking teachers are all very good. i felt the system is very good. although i am thinking of stopping my girl now, i don’t want her to go for the next 2 levels cuz she is going to P1 next year, i am thinking to transfer her to British Council for english writing program. still highly recommend ICR if your aim is to get your kids master the reading skill.