7 PSLE composition myths that quietly cost marks (from a former marker)
-
In 15 years of marking PSLE English scripts, I saw the same well-meant habits pull good writers down, usually ones picked up from model-essay books. Here are the seven I saw most often, and what to do instead.
-
“Use as many good phrases and idioms as possible.”
Memorised phrases often don’t fit the moment and sound unnatural, and a misused idiom costs Language marks.
Instead: one precise, well-placed description beats five stock phrases. -
“A more exciting plot scores higher.”
Kidnappings, robberies and near-death escapes are rarely believable, and they often drift from the topic.
Instead: choose an ordinary situation with real feelings, such as a broken promise, a lost item or a lie. -
“Long is good.”
Extra scenes dilute the key moment and give more chances for errors.
Instead: spend the words on the climax, not on breakfast and the bus ride. -
“Start with the weather or an alarm clock.”
A generic opening wastes the first impression and delays the problem.
Instead: start close to the problem, with an action, a line of dialogue or a thought. -
“Memorise a few essays and adapt them.”
Adapted essays usually answer a slightly different topic, and relevance is the first thing markers check.
Instead: practise planning for many topics rather than memorising stories. -
“Replace ‘said’ with a fancy verb every time.”
Constant “exclaimed”, “retorted” and “bellowed” is distracting and often used wrongly.
Instead: use “said” most of the time, and let the dialogue and actions carry the emotion. -
“End with a moral like ‘Honesty is the best policy’.”
A tacked-on proverb feels preachy and doesn’t show what the character learned.
Instead: end with the character’s own realisation and what they’ll do differently.
A quick check you can do tonight
Take your child’s last school composition and ask these questions:Which part shows the topic? If they point to one line near the end, that isn’t enough.
What could the main character lose? If nothing, there’s no real problem.
Is the most important moment longer than the walk to school?
How is the character different at the end?Don’t fix anything yet. Just note which question it fails first. That’s your starting point.
Happy to answer questions below.
Disclosure: I now make writing resources. If it’s useful, there’s a free sample of my parent’s guide, with these myths and a printable checklist, here: payhip.com/AntzLearn/collection/free-samples
-
-
A AntzLearn referenced this topic
-
@AntzLearn Thanks for sharing these tips!
I’m from the KiasuParents team (editorial background), and yes, I agree with your list. There’s definitely no need to avoid “said!”
We have some compo tips here too:
https://www.kiasuparents.com/kiasu/article/help-primary-school-child-with-english-compositionWhen my kids were still in primary school, I remember also hearing the advice to avoid heavy topics like death. What’s your take on this?
-
@thebottomsupblog Thank you, and thanks for sharing the article! I especially like the point about aiming for “a clear, interesting story rather than a masterpiece”. It takes a lot of pressure off children (and parents!). And agreed, analysing why a model works is far more useful than memorising it.
On heavy topics like death: in my experience, the topic itself isn’t the problem. Markers don’t take marks off for writing about loss. What usually costs marks is how it’s handled, and that’s where the advice comes from.
Why children are often told to avoid it
- It tempts melodrama. A sudden accident or death thrown in for drama often feels rushed and unbelievable, and believability matters.
- lt can pull the story off the topic. A question about “a time you showed kindness” can turn into a tragedy where the kindness is only a line at the end.
- Real feelings are hard to develop in the time. Grief is complex, and it’s difficult for a 12-year-old to show it convincingly in under an hour.
- It can be upsetting. If a child draws on a real loss, writing about it under exam pressure can be hard emotionally.
When it can work well
A quiet, believable story can be very moving, for example a child visiting a grandparent in hospital and realising how much the small things they shared meant. It works when:- It clearly answers the topic.
- It focuses on one moment, slowed down, with feelings shown through actions and details.
- It ends with the character’s own realisation rather than a dramatic twist.
What I suggest to parents
Default to everyday situations: a broken promise, a lost item, a misunderstanding. They’re easier to write well and give plenty of room for real feelings. But if a child wants to write about loss, there’s no need to forbid it. Just help them keep it grounded, sensitive and tied to the question, and steer clear of violence or killing off a character for shock value.Thanks again for the thoughtful question, and do let me know if the team ever needs a teacher’s perspective for an article.
Elliot
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login8
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects