Raffles Girls' School (Secondary) [*IP]
-
Hi parents of current or ex-Rgs girls, my dd has been offered a place at Rgs through dsa.
But I heard comments that some ip teachers do not teach much and that learning is left ver much to the pupils themselves.
So I would really appreciate it if I could get feedback about rgs’ programmes from parents who have or had girls in the Rgs ip programme. -
moomoo7368:
whatever it is, it is time to train to girls to be more independent in their studies, learn where to get what and howHi parents of current or ex-Rgs girls, my dd has been offered a place at Rgs through dsa.
But I heard comments that some ip teachers do not teach much and that learning is left ver much to the pupils themselves.
So I would really appreciate it if I could get feedback about rgs' programmes from parents who have or had girls in the Rgs ip programme. -
moomoo7368:
My comments are :Hi parents of current or ex-Rgs girls, my dd has been offered a place at Rgs through dsa.
But I heard comments that some ip teachers do not teach much and that learning is left ver much to the pupils themselves.
So I would really appreciate it if I could get feedback about rgs' programmes from parents who have or had girls in the Rgs ip programme.
1) There are some very good teachers who really spoon feed their students with wonderful notes. Unfortunately, these are not the majority.
Some are so lazy that they didn't even bother to give their students the standard notes. The trick is to have many friends and get notes from classes with the good teachers. There was a really good math teacher who left recently. A real lost to the school but I wonder if the principal is aware.
2) Generally by JC1, they forget what is a \"real exam\" after being tested by \"modules\" for the last 4 years. However, being intelligent kids, most of them will recover by JC2.
2) For weaker students who takes time to \"recover\", best to make them do \"O\" level paper on their own because IP can deviate quite substantially from the \"O\" level syllabus. -
Hi atutor2001, thanks for your feedback. It is quite worrying as dd is one of those who need to be 'pushed'. So if she gets one of the 'bochap' teachers, it would be... :roll:
-
verykiasu2010:
I concur.
whatever it is, it is time to train to girls to be more independent in their studies, learn where to get what and howmoomoo7368:
Hi parents of current or ex-Rgs girls, my dd has been offered a place at Rgs through dsa.
But I heard comments that some ip teachers do not teach much and that learning is left ver much to the pupils themselves.
So I would really appreciate it if I could get feedback about rgs' programmes from parents who have or had girls in the Rgs ip programme.
[quote]My comments are :
1) There are some very good teachers who really spoon feed their students with wonderful notes. Unfortunately, these are not the majority.
Some are so lazy that they didn't even bother to give their students the standard notes. The trick is to have many friends and get notes from classes with the good teachers. There was a really good math teacher who left recently. A real lost to the school but I wonder if the principal is aware.
2) Generally by JC1, they forget what is a \"real exam\" after being tested by \"modules\" for the last 4 years. However, being intelligent kids, most of them will recover by JC2.
2) For weaker students who takes time to \"recover\", best to make them do \"O\" level paper on their own because IP can deviate quite substantially from the \"O\" level syllabus.[/quote]Are good teachers the ones who spoon-feed students with notes? Perhaps this is a value judgement but I think good teachers should actually encourage students to think on their own. Though your statement that \"Some are so lazy that they didn't even bother to give their students the standard notes.\" may be true, do not be mistaken; Most teachers in RGS are not like this.
In addition, I do not believe that students will forget what a \"real exam\" is. If your definition of a real exam happens to be one that covers all topics, it is still not true that students will forget. Whatever the subject is, topics covered earlier would serve as a foundation to future topics. Hence, it is not true that students would not remember.
It is precisely because the IP deviates from the O Level syllabus that it is not advised for students to do the O Level paper on their own. The topics taught are more advanced than the O Level topics. However, I do admit that the O Level papers would serve as a good revision for foundation building.
[quote]It is quite worrying as dd is one of those who need to be 'pushed'. So if she gets one of the 'bochap' teachers, it would be...[/quote]Going to RGS would possibly encourage her to study on her own and learn to think critically! -
[quote]
.....Most teachers in RGS are not like this. [/quote]Don't know leh. That is the impression I get after having so many kids going through that school. Maybe my kids are not so lucky. Anyway it is quite common for students with parents, petitioning against teachers. Heard of quite a number of cases. Once, against a physics teacher many years back, who is no longer there and latest I heard is against an old chem teacher.
[quote].... Whatever the subject is, topics covered earlier would serve as a foundation to future topics. Hence, it is not true that students would not remember. [/quote]Not true lah. Let say for physics, the \"Kinematics module\" will not be able to serve as a foundation for subsequent module on \"electricity\". So after being tested in term 1 on kinematics they will not see it again. CT is topic based. But at A level, the exam is on ALL topics. That is where the J1 find it hard to adjust. All my kids did not do that well for J1 but ok by J2.
[quote] It is precisely because the IP deviates from the O Level syllabus that it is not advised for students to do the O Level paper on their own. The topics taught are more advanced than the O Level topics. However, I do admit that the O Level papers would serve as a good revision for foundation building. [/quote]The problem with some of the IP syllabus is that they did not put the horse before the cart. O level syllabus is a tested comprehensive syllabus, developed over so many years, covering the fundamentals needed. So for weaker or lazier students who need more time to grasp the fundamentals, the way some of the IP syllabus are structured can be quite overwhelming. -
I would think that it is hardly possible for it to common for students to petition against teachers, given the calibre of this school. Sure, some teachers may be disliked but this to be expected.
[quote] Not true lah. Let say for physics, the \"Kinematics module\" will not be able to serve as a foundation for subsequent module on \"electricity\". So after being tested in term 1 on kinematics they will not see it again. CT is topic based. [/quote]My statements should be taken into context. Of course, it is not possible to integrate the two at this level but in topics such as dynamics and mechanics, knowledge from previous topics is essential.
The students in J1 now and were from RGS that I know do not find it as hard to adjust as you seem to say. In fact, sometimes the RGS students have an upper hand (e.g. Organic Chemistry) because they have already studied it in RGS.
There are quite a few benefits to the IP too! -
[quote] ... but in topics such as dynamics and mechanics, knowledge from previous topics is essential. [/quote]
Agreed but unfortunately such related topics are usually covered under the same module, taught in the same term. So after CT, mostly forget already.
[quote]The students in J1 now and were from RGS that I know do not find it as hard to adjust as you seem to say. [/quote]With the exception of the really gifted, most of the kids' grades drop in J1 and took about 1 year to regain their grades. For such a highly intelligent group of kids to take such a long time to adjust and accustom to the A-level format, to me, is quite hard.
Actually my real concern is the introduction of IP to too many schools. Recently, my nephew asked me how come KE=1/2 mv^2 . I was surprised to learn later that he has not been taught velocity and yet the school was teaching KE. He is from a school that has just gone IP and the physics booklet he shown me is compiled by the school probably in preparation for their IP. In their zeal to enhance the coverage, the horse was placed behind the cart and the students will throw off balance.
[quote] In fact, sometimes the RGS students have an upper hand (e.g. Organic Chemistry) because they have already studied it in RGS.
There are quite a few benefits to the IP too![/quote]Fully agreed, especially biology. Heard that they cover the A-level syllabus in the IP. However, I am trying to highlight the fact that that IP can also be a disadvantage to students whose good results are through sheer hardwork or students who are lazy/playful. -
moomoo7368:
I think the school wants to stretch the students. There is a lot of project work, working in groups and singly. It's quite different from the classroom lecture style. Maybe parents should guide the child first couple of times as to where to get information (e.g. internet, what keywords to use in internet search). Trains the child to deal with unfamiliar circumstances. Academically, worksheets can be quite challenging. Naturally some students will complain about \"not be taught\" because they are not being spoonfed.But I heard comments that some ip teachers do not teach much and that learning is left ver much to the pupils themselves.
So I would really appreciate it if I could get feedback about rgs' programmes from parents who have or had girls in the Rgs ip programme.
Without O Levels, it makes it possible for trying alternative learning styles. My guess is that it's back to book style in JC. -
67283:
I concur.
whatever it is, it is time to train to girls to be more independent in their studies, learn where to get what and howverykiasu2010:
[quote=\"moomoo7368\"]Hi parents of current or ex-Rgs girls, my dd has been offered a place at Rgs through dsa.
But I heard comments that some ip teachers do not teach much and that learning is left ver much to the pupils themselves.
So I would really appreciate it if I could get feedback about rgs' programmes from parents who have or had girls in the Rgs ip programme.
[quote]My comments are :
1) There are some very good teachers who really spoon feed their students with wonderful notes. Unfortunately, these are not the majority.
Some are so lazy that they didn't even bother to give their students the standard notes. The trick is to have many friends and get notes from classes with the good teachers. There was a really good math teacher who left recently. A real lost to the school but I wonder if the principal is aware.
2) Generally by JC1, they forget what is a \"real exam\" after being tested by \"modules\" for the last 4 years. However, being intelligent kids, most of them will recover by JC2.
2) For weaker students who takes time to \"recover\", best to make them do \"O\" level paper on their own because IP can deviate quite substantially from the \"O\" level syllabus.[/quote]Are good teachers the ones who spoon-feed students with notes? Perhaps this is a value judgement but I think good teachers should actually encourage students to think on their own. Though your statement that \"Some are so lazy that they didn't even bother to give their students the standard notes.\" may be true, do not be mistaken; Most teachers in RGS are not like this.
In addition, I do not believe that students will forget what a \"real exam\" is. If your definition of a real exam happens to be one that covers all topics, it is still not true that students will forget. Whatever the subject is, topics covered earlier would serve as a foundation to future topics. Hence, it is not true that students would not remember.
It is precisely because the IP deviates from the O Level syllabus that it is not advised for students to do the O Level paper on their own. The topics taught are more advanced than the O Level topics. However, I do admit that the O Level papers would serve as a good revision for foundation building.
[quote]It is quite worrying as dd is one of those who need to be 'pushed'. So if she gets one of the 'bochap' teachers, it would be...[/quote]Going to RGS would possibly encourage her to study on her own and learn to think critically![/quote]Yes, there are some very good teachers who take the time to explain and teach well (not necessarily equals to spoonfeeding) and inspire the girls to enjoy the subjects. Just like in any school, there are also those who in the girls' words \"cant teach\", \"spending a lot of time on unimportant stuff and running out of time for the rest\" and one who will throw terms around and when asked to explain, told that in University, you would be expected to find out yourselves. There is the expectation that the students are more independant learners and can study/learn on their own and at the same time juggle their load of ccas, projects, many mini tests, assignments... They do survive through it. Lke atutor2001 said, they'll figure it out and get the notes from their friends and seniors with the \"better\" teachers.
The girls also do take tuition outside - math, chinese, sciences. There must be a substantial demand for it cos I hear that tuition centres such as Aspen Learning, offer IP classes specifically for RGS girls (RI, NYGH and DH too).
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login123
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects