Children Suicide Cases
-
winth:
I pity the 3 kids
I pity the children. They are really skinny and small-sized for their age. But there's really nothing I can do to help. This mummy is the aggressive type and you can kinda visualise her getting all jumpy over her son's academic results when he attends primary education in a couple years' time. And let's not talk about all the stress this mummy has created for the young soul.
... Not that I am doing a great job myself, but there are some who you know cant cut it as parents.
-
[Editor's note: Topic selected and edited for http://www.kiasuparents.com/kiasu/content/stress-children-put-themselves-through.]
jedamum:
Rigid education system... yeah. But methinks, not all scholars are \"square\" and \"inside the box\". At least those that I know are not, or perhaps I am super square myself and can't see itRigid local education system --> breeds inside the box Scholars --->
Actually, can the effects of 6+4+2 years of the local system simply be wiped away by a few short years overseas?
--
I observe many parents pushing their kids to get into the IP schools (Study hard! Do well in primary school! Sail through PSLE with flying colours! Get in and you're set for life!!!). But I wonder if they think beyond getting in, and consider what six years of being in an environment full of super-achievers will do to their bright kids. It's not just schools and teachers and parents perpetuating the stress. Quite apart from these external 'culprits', kids are perfectly capable of creating stress for themselves too. Especially if one is an achiever who has been \"conditioned\" for success from all those years of being in elite schools and expects a great deal of oneself.
Just to illustrate. I graduated from a JC where the usual questions before and after A levels were along the line of : [1] Are you applying to Oxbridge? Ivy League? [2] Did you get provisionally accepted? HYP or lower Ivy?? [3] Which scholarships are you applying for? [4] Which scholarships offers did you get? (Oh, the pitying looks when one admits to certain (perceived) \"lower-class\" scholarships!)
To be at ease in such an environment was already an achievement in itself.. Not everyone possessed sufficient resilience to escape unscathed. There were suicidal thoughts when lofty expectations (die die must get into Oxbridge!) were not met. Kid you not... In their world, they had failed miserably. Less severely, I had classmates who were so ashamed that they \"only\" made it to the local unis that they evaporated away from our lives forever. And there were many who thought they were destroyed for life when they didn't make it to med school. Every other discipline was a poor second choice. I still recall, vividly, an outstanding girl who was so distraught by her rejection from med school (this was when the med school had an unreasonable 1/3 cap for the number of females) that she spent four years moping about it - she was disgusted with only getting into law school and actually tried pretty hard to flunk out by refusing to study. :roll:
Some friends have admitted that they regret sending their kids to IP schools - their kids are certainly very bright academically, but they are drowning in the stress - not created by their very sensible and increasingly worried parents, but, apparently, by themselves. I can't help thinking that maybe kids should receive psychological assessments when they apply for these 'elite' schools, like in scholarship interviews... -
I agree with clarabella's view on IP. I know of a mother with twin sons-one in IP school and another in a neighbourhood school.
She clearly favours the 'smarter' son bec she will go blah blah blah on how he achieve
in school but for the less 'smarter' son, she always said \"you see, a lousy
son in a lousy school, I don't expect anything from him!!\". It became so
bad that the smart son keep telling her \"I will kill myself if ti-ti's results is
better than me, he must not win me\" and the poor ti-ti is so emotionally distraught that he has
suicidal thoughts and is being counselled by his school. As for the mother,
she has no qualms when she related these to me. I was like :shock: I
told her you have to so something before any tragedy strikes but she
remain nonchalant, saying \"This world is like this, only the strongest will
survive, they have to learn it themselves\". My goodness, I really pray
hard for the 2 boys
It really pains me and my heart goes out to
both the boys. what will they be when they grow older?? -
pinky:
It is not only academic stuff. Some parents have no qualms comparing their kids on anything based on their favouritism towards the kids. I do come across parents who put down the book-smart one (better sec sch) and favored the street-smart one (neighbourhood sch)....As for the mother,
she has no qualms when she related these to me. -
insider:
Speaking from my personal experience, I get to believe that overseas education is beneficial for children. Other than training independence, a child coming from a Singapore education system at least finally have a chance to stop mugging and start thinking.
There are many smart kids in our schools who go unnoticed just becos they don't test well. This is based on personal experience. (Of course, not saying that I'm super smart but I know I'm not stupid.) I've always been introverted and quiet for 8 years of my sch life. Only in Sec 3 did I start opening up in class. Even then, it was nothing compared to those who were outspoken and forthcoming with opinions.
Even up to JC, my teachers' opinions of me were either \"very quiet and pleasant\" or they recognise my English writing ability and put hopes on me. Unfortunately, the S'pore sch exam system and me don't see eye to eye. I would usually end up with average or even below average scores and be ashamed to meet my teachers.
Luckily, when I went to NUS, I had some (not much but still better than sec sch and JC) good feedback from projects/essays that require me to apply rather than mug. That got me thinking. I slowly realised that I wouldn't do well in traditional education systems with emphasis on exams. This realisation was further reinforced when I went on to do 2 postgrad diplomas, especially the 2nd one. I did exceptionally well for my modules for the 2nd diploma because there were no exams at all. It was 100% project-based.
While earning this 2nd diploma, I became what many traditional teachers/lecturers would hate to have in their classes but I feel that it is their loss. I only hope that my DD has the chance to experience such an educational system before she graduates from compulsory education. If not, she has to learn that exams are not the only way to gauge a person's worth, especially in this country. -
clarabella:
Definitely agree on this. Not all scholars are book smart and square. One that I know was even barred by certain Las Vegas casinos.
Rigid education system... yeah. But methinks, not all scholars are \"square\" and \"inside the box\". At least those that I know are not, or perhaps I am super square myself and can't see it
-
insider:
I share a different personal experience and I do not believe in putting the issue on systems alone. Throughout my school days, I had never mugged at all, believe or not, but I had sailed through my school entering all the best schools plus going to local university that many I knew could not make it, and had to use parent's scholarship to go for an overseas education. I played hard and even skipped lessons(not advocating that for children) for training in competition. My belief is, alot is to do with the mindset, if you feel you are being limited, you will be and I share this message with my child. I was outspoken since young too and I dared to challenge my teacher's way of handling certain issues. Still, I did not get into trouble with my teachers and had been teachers' pet throughout my schooling years, again believe it or not. I have never been asked to \"shut up and sit down\" despite my vocal self.
Speaking from my personal experience, I get to believe that overseas education is beneficial for children. Other than training independence, a child coming from a Singapore education system at least finally has a chance to stop mugging and start thinking.
From your account of your growth and liberation experience, it is more like a maturity development...as you grow older some things become clearer to you. I have never memorised my work but have used alot of thinking skills since young and it stays with me until today. In fact, things happen the other way round for me until now, because I use so much thinking cap, it helps me to remember alot of things due to understanding. At this age, people still find me having an elephant memory which I would not say I have when younger.
At work, I had put in decent hard work and due to my local training, had \"leapfrog\" and maximised my earning potential during my prime years. Now I can humbly say I am semi-retired and doing volunteer work. I have the option of working for pleasure now.
Lastly, I won't advocate saving money for an overseas education for my child or give her the idea that I am doing so. I will continue to make extra money for it as a reserve. On her part, she will work towards her own goal with her own efforts first.
Every system has its merits and demerits, the approach I take is to see how the merits can work for me and minimise on its demerits. If an overseas education is only to bring out a perceived \"liberated\" voice in my child and driving individualism, then I can do without because to me, whether local or overseas, her basic principles and beliefs should stick with her. Whatever she gets from the overseas experience should just allow her to assimilate it into some global issues and expound on them to care for our earth and not get into the mindset of strong individualism which most of us are already born with.
Just for the record, I did my post-graduate Masters with an overseas institution and a large part of my career was in MNCs, so I worked with many foreigners of whom some became great pals with me. And you know what? They actually like the way I work and lead them....I am sure I have taught them alot of things.
Lastly, in life, barriers are ample, but we need to get our children to learn how to break barriers and break it nicely, not ugly. Also, some barriers are self-imposed and in the mind, we need to recognise those. -
I have to agree with ks2me, I canโt say I found the local ed system to be particularly restrictive. Am presently working in an research unit in an MNC leading a cross-functional, multinational team including westerners and have not found a lack of overseas exposure a limitation in either work creativity or leadership ability.
In an interview will Bill Gates for his book "The World is Flat", Thomas Friedman asked if the โrigidโ education systems in the East were restrictive and led to limitations of creativity and ability. Gates shot back (from my memory, pardon the imprecision of quote0 that he had never met a programmer that couldnโt do math. I.e. content and substance matters a lot, and you can only do the application part if you have the requisite book knowledge.
James Dobson in one of his vids on "Bringing Up Boys", said in reference to the public school system in the US (again from memory), that if socialisation in schools as opposed to home schooling meant exposure to pressures to do drugs, have sex, and academic underachievement, we could do with less of it. Honestly, I donโt care to put my kids through a system where they need to pass through metal detectors to get to class.
In a nutshell, we tend to beat ourselves up about some of the more perceived restrictions on creativity in school. If what I see is happening in my sonโs preschool curriculum is indicative, there is plenty of creativity going. I think we have a first class education system in Singapore all the way up to post-secondary, one that is highly regarded by overseas educationists and one I would not trade for any other in the world. I donโt see that our top performers at A levels give anything away to the top performers elsewhere. The trick is to manage some of the pressures associated with high expectations in a cool and common-sensical way. Uni and above, I agree there are many more options out there. -
insider:
This one sounds like a dream kid
... like my nephew who doesn't need to study but can easily score a 270+ for PSLE.
insider:
I think that mugging doesn't quite work to do well in the local universities, these days. I just did a postgrad course at one of the local unis, and I observe that the undergrads are expected to think and apply whatever they learn. If they just mug the way they did in sec sch and JC, guaranteed to get Cs and Ds. Open book exams are common in many faculties and are in fact the norm in some. Although I have encountered those who still prefer to mug their way through (and then wonder why they don't do well), I see many, many young people who actually USE their brains. Quite impressed, actually, cos they are not \"square\" lah.Most kids still need to mug books in Singapore. Looking at the way my two children, nieces, nephews and their friends are studying + the teachers' expectation of sort of 'standard answers' (regurgitation), most can't do well without mugging...
-
Hi, something interesting to share while I was visiting this forum site.
Cut and paste from the thread-starter.[quote]I was just watching Fox News just now and a \"News you may find interesting\" bit was just shown and talked about how certain schools in the US have been adopting the \"Singapore Math\" method, and the classes have experienced a 25% jump since introduction.
I've never heard of this method before. Doing a quick search I came across the Wikipedia entry:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Singapore_Math
Anyone of you in Singapore (or elsewhere!) have experience with this method and can share more about what this is about?[/quote]It's kinda amazing to know that there is this method called - Singapore Math method (just like how Shichida Method is so popular here).
I have had a perceived overseas education system too in that it's much 'higher' class there than what we do in Singapore. Was always thinking of ways and means to send children abroad should they be found unsuitable for the local system here.
But at the same time, I do hear of comments about universities overseas (can't comment about the top uni) that the standard there isn't really as high as I thought. One exaggerated comment I heard was: 'You can send any local JC student to compete with the uni undergrads in London for any Math/Physics paper. Any A level student here can easily beat them flat.' This comment came from a graduate from that university in London. He was educated in London since he completed his sec school in Singapore. And he said the perceived 'higher education' that his parents had about London, really isn't true. It's quite chaotic and low class there.
But the good thing about being educated overseas is that they do open up your perceptives, creative-thinking and freedom of speech is highly encouraged. So maybe it really depends on what subjects/type of degree you are doing. Maybe Singapore system do very well when it comes to left-brain subjects (i.e. maths, physics, medical-science) and overseas system support the right-brain subjects (literature, geography, arts) better?
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better ๐
Register Login7
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects