Will kids who are not plugged into pop culture suffer?

[Chenonceau]

shirley.tamzil:

For my children, I expose them 'with filter' and 'added opinion' from me. I listen to radio while driving, so there are chances that pop music or conversations between DJ would pop up. DS1 will sometimes tell me that his fren is listening to songs by that singer or that song. I have always advise DS1 that some songs are not written 'responsibly', so he has to know what is right and wrong even when listening to songs. Whenever I hear opinions from DJs which I dun agree or hav opinions about, I would voice it out and discuss it with DS1.


For TV shows, I try to watch it together with my children if I feel that some 'education' are needed. There was once where the show was very sexual (I had already explained the 'birds n bees' to him), DS1 complains that the show is not good and boring bcos it's too sexual :oops: , and he subsequently lost interest in following it.

So I think it's ok to expose them as long as we give them proper guidance about the world.

I do exactly this too.

[3Boys]

My 2 y.o. sings to Lady Gaga.....Ga Ga O la la, Roma roma.....


Come to think of it, her songs are a bit like kids nursery rhymes.

[Tinkerbelle]

I restrict my DDs but do not ban them. I believe everything in moderation is healthy. My DDs watch TV, play computer games, read Harry Potter and Twillight books and love her music but she’s not overly obsessed with them.


DD1 in P6 has mentioned to me that her classmates are all into pop music. However, there’e one particular classmate who is not allowed to play computer games, read books on vampires or listen to music. She didn’t even know who Lady Gaga is. As a result, she could not relate to the other classmates and felt left out when they talk about the latest books or music. In the end, to fit in, she borrowed the Twillight book from her classmates and read them secretly in sch.

[Alex001]

Your kids play the Wii? That’s a privilege… depending on the type of games they have. I understand that disallowing your children from playing the computer and listening to today’s music is acceptable, but not allowing them to read popular children’s books? I understand that following Christianity is important, but books are educational and contain morales for children. Check out some family sites regarding what types of books children should read…it may be useful.

[HappyFaye]

Most of the time, my kids and I quarrel over the duration of the exposure each time, but not the content.


I monitor quietly the games they play and the friends they have. So far, no cause for concern yet.

This brings back to one of my experience when I was young. My father was a heavy smoker and hence it was easy for us to access to cigarette. One day, my elderest brother stole a cigarette and ask his 4 siblings to try. 5 of us were hiding under the blanket and lit up the cigarette (luckily no fire outbreak ) We took turn to take a puff. Results - all of us hated the smell and the dryness so much that we stay away from cigarette till today.

During my secondary school time, I did mix with friends that smoked and was offered to try too but the first experience just stopped me from trying 2nd time.

So exposure with close monitoring should be fine? I thought sometimes it is good to let them try different things...

[toddles]

mummy always:

I have a question. My P4 & P5 boys do not play much computer games nor watch much TV. They do not have a handphone either. They do not read books which are popular among children their age, like harry potter or on witches/vampires because we are christians and these books are not aligned to our values.


They are this way due to our strict controls (on TV and computer), and they dont seemed very deprived - they do not hanker after TV, or games or even the books I mentioned. (Although I was ever told by a teen that I was depriving the kids but of course my kids won't know better). My kids do play the Wii, watch nature programmes, programs on Okto, read a lot (mostly non-fiction as they are interested in Science; they do read fiction too). Anyway, their only source of pop culture is from their school friends, where they learn things like Mr Brown's songs.

I realised that many young children nowadays are very much into songs and mtv and games starting from very young age. So I wonder whether our chosen way of bringing up our children will cause them to suffer in the near future, or when they are in their teens - esp when they go into sec school. Will they be labelled as weird, or aliens or something?

I will much appreciate any views. Thanks v much.

I share your values, and wanted to go on the IBLP standard of not having a TV at home. but hubby quite likes watching TV as form of relaxation.

I wish I could limit TV exposure to near-zero, but my kid now sings \"Wah meng Tiiiiiiiiiiiiii\" thanks to my mum SIGH. can't wait for that drama to END.

I suppose going forward, I will probably operate on the \"limit the time spent on TV/pop-culture/computer games\" so that they have some awareness of what is going on in the world, and I will always be there alongside to provide some 'commentary' or general principles of guidance on how to process such 'downloads' from the world wisely.

After all, no way to not be 'in' the world, just have to make sure we are not 'of' it.