Challenging Maths by Ammiel Wan - which grades?
-
Hi
What are the differences between Onsponge and Visible Thinking Maths books?
Is Visible Thinking a textbook or assessment book?
Best wishes -
Hi tianzhu
pls see the below link for the discussion on the 2 books. Hope this info helps.
Regards
http://www.kiasuparents.com/kiasu/forum/viewtopic.php?t=18144&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=30 -
An Overview of \"Visible Thinking in Mathematics\" written by Mr Ammiel Wan (Marshall Cavendish, 2011)
Just to give a rough overview of this new series of assessment/guide books for the benefit for all parents/educators who have queries regarding this new set of books by Mr Ammiel Wan who's now a vice-principle in Rosyth Primary School. Bought the Pri 4A, 5A and Pri 6 version from Popular yesterday. I will focus on the Primary 6 version in this review.
A note before i start, I wish to state that i am in no way affiliated with OnSponge, Visible Maths, Marshall Cavendish or Mr Ammiel Wan. I am just a Maths Educator who wish to share my views on this resource with everyone here.
This book can be considered his 3rd Generation work in \"Cognitive Conceptual Approach in Learning Mathematics\" which Mr Ammiel Wan has been spearheading and refining since 2006 when he first published the popular \"Challenging Problems Made Easy\". He followed up on his early success by teaming up with \"Thinking Maths @ OnSponge\" (which is a education company set up by 2 entrepreneurs) to publish a series of Problem Solving Books (Pri 3 to Pri 6) which uses his set of Heuristics and Concepts to guide student's understanding of the various problem sums and learn how to apply those concepts to conquer problem sums.
As I pointed out before, both \"Challenging Problems Made Easy\" and \"Onsponge\" are focused only on building up the student's thinking skills and procedural learning to tackle Section C / Paper 2 type of problem sums. However, as many educators can attest, a large number of students lack proper understanding of the reasoning behind basic concepts and skills and they would end up memorizing facts and procedures like \"Before you plus 2 fractions together, you must make the denominator the same\" without really understanding why is it so. For very basic questions such as those \"Knowledge Recall\" questions found in section A, this is all well and dandy.
The problem starts when you start loading Problem solving Concepts / Heuristics such as those found in \"On Sponge\" onto such a foundation, the child would be at a loss. This is because he is now surrounded by concepts and thinking skills alien to him but which are essential for problem solving. What they typically do and which i had observed in some of my students when they were using OnSponge under their previous tutors (before they engaged me) is that they would memorize the concept for each particular chapter and keep regurgitating it for each similar question in the same chapter. However they did it without proper understanding of the concepts and when asked by their parents or previous tutors to apply the same concept for a similar question in an exam paper after a couple of weeks, they would look blank and keep insisting that they don't know how to do it.
There are 2 ways to combat this.
The first way is for the Parent or Educator to sit beside the child while he is using \"OnSponge\" or doing other problem solving assessment books and guide him on how to read and understand the context of the problem, think through the proper usage and application of the methods as taught and understand the reasoning on how the various concepts and methods can help you use the facts and information in the question to solve it.
The 2nd way is to start from basics and start getting the child used to a thinking and reasoning based approach rather than a rote -learning approach of learning basic mathematical concepts. This would help the parent or educator to cultivate the child's thinking skills and help direct the student's thought process on key concepts. And in so doing, the student would be better able to integrate the Problem solving concepts and Heuristics as they come along later.
\"Visible Thinking in Mathematics\" is basically the 2nd approach and personally i think its way overdue but nonetheless a welcome addition to my resource of teaching materials.
Below are a number of thoughts about the book :
1) I like the way the chapters are divided into easy to digest sub-chapters which are designed to allow the student to integrate each new concept in a progressive manner and encourage the child's knowledge to spiral upwards and build on top of each other until mastery of the chapter is attained.
2) Also, each sub-chapter is further sub-divided into \"Thinking Platforms\" and \"Mastery Platforms. \"Thinking Platforms\" provides guidance for the student to develop his understanding of the concept by thinking about how the concept can apply to various problems with the same context but different key words or different numerical values. This allows the student to learn by thinking and reasoning about the context of the question rather than simply memorizing methods and concepts. \"Mastery Platforms\" allow the student to practice his newly learnt concepts and skills on various \"Parallel\" questions which has the same context as the examples but which are all slightly different so as to allow the student to understand and integrate the concepts and skills learnt better.
3) The \"Notes\" placed at the end of most thinking platforms provide a valuable tip/resource to the parent or educator on clarifying common misconceptions, areas of difficulties commonly faced by the student, or information on how to make the concept easier to understand by the student.
Overall, i think \"Visible Thinking in Mathematics\" is a good \"Broad-Based\" resource (as compared to \"OnSponge\" which only focuses on Problem Sums) to complement the school's textbook in helping the students master basic and advanced mathematical concepts through both conceptual understanding and critical thinking.
I personally think this would be a good resource for those looking for a assessment book to help them build up their fundamentals while improving their thinking skills and understanding of mathematical concepts. It gels in very well with my own teaching methodology and after a couple of weeks of analyzing the new books and planning on how it will fit into my teaching curriculum, i will provide an update on my review.
Yours
Zhou Shicai
Nicklebee Tutors -
NickleBee Tutors:
An Overview of \"Visible Thinking in Mathematics\" written by Mr Ammiel Wan (Marshall Cavendish, 2011)
I personally think this would be a good resource for those looking for a assessment book to help them build up their fundamentals while improving their thinking skills and understanding of mathematical concepts. It gels in very well with my own teaching methodology and after a couple of weeks of analyzing the new books and planning on how it will fit into my teaching curriculum, i will provide an update on my review.
Yours
Zhou Shicai
Nicklebee Tutors
My heart felt thanks and appreciation to for your classic answer.
I first thought if I buy this book it will be an addition to my pile of other work books.
can you reccomend any english work books please ?
Thank you. -
Hi "NickleBee Tutors"]
There are 2 ways to combat this.
The first way is for the Parent or Educator to sit beside the child while he is using "OnSponge" or doing other problem solving assessment books and guide him on how to read and understand the context of the problem, think through the proper usage and application of the methods as taught and understand the reasoning on how the various concepts and methods can help you use the facts and information in the question to solve it.
The 2nd way is to start from basics and start getting the child used to a thinking and reasoning based approach rather than a rote -learning approach of learning basic mathematical concepts. This would help the parent or educator to cultivate the child’s thinking skills and help direct the student’s thought process on key concepts. And in so doing, the student would be better able to integrate the Problem solving concepts and Heuristics as they come along .
Could u pls kindly illustrate with an example?Am still trying to unlock the math processing skills in ds.thanks alot.
Leanne -
NickleBee Tutors:
Hi Nicklebee Tutors,An Overview of \"Visible Thinking in Mathematics\" written by Mr Ammiel Wan (Marshall Cavendish, 2011)
Overall, i think \"Visible Thinking in Mathematics\" is a good \"Broad-Based\" resource (as compared to \"OnSponge\" which only focuses on Problem Sums) to complement the school's textbook in helping the students master basic and advanced mathematical concepts through both conceptual understanding and critical thinking.
I personally think this would be a good resource for those looking for a assessment book to help them build up their fundamentals while improving their thinking skills and understanding of mathematical concepts.
Yours
Zhou Shicai
Nicklebee Tutors
Thanks for your detailed analysis on the above; appreciates :thankyou:
I am using the Visible Thinking too and find that it helps me as a parent to understand the concept better before coaching my gal with her Maths. I agree that it is one of the \"good resource for those looking for a assessment book to help them build up their fundamentals while improving their thinking skills and understanding of mathematical concepts.\"
I chanced upon this book when one day my gal brought back her Maths \"Impromtus\" test paper and looking for \"clues\", I found the small print at the bottom of the page \"Visible Thinking in Mathematics 3A\"
. Called up the publisher and came to know that this is a new publication (that was on the 2nd or 3rd week Jan 2011) and only available in The Big Bookshop then. But now it is available in Popular Bookstore as well :celebrate:
Since then, I have been the book as a supplmental book to guide my gal in her Maths. Very challenging questions and she has to understand the concept before attempting. -
plum-cake:
Hi PlumCake,NickleBee Tutors:
An Overview of \"Visible Thinking in Mathematics\" written by Mr Ammiel Wan (Marshall Cavendish, 2011)
I personally think this would be a good resource for those looking for a assessment book to help them build up their fundamentals while improving their thinking skills and understanding of mathematical concepts. It gels in very well with my own teaching methodology and after a couple of weeks of analyzing the new books and planning on how it will fit into my teaching curriculum, i will provide an update on my review.
Yours
Zhou Shicai
Nicklebee Tutors
My heart felt thanks and appreciation to for your classic answer.
I first thought if I buy this book it will be an addition to my pile of other work books.
can you reccomend any english work books please ?
Thank you.
I am sorry but as i specialize in teaching only Maths and Science, i am afraid that i am not qualified to recommend good English workbooks for your child.
I think other educators in this forum can help you in this area.
Yours
Zhou Shicai -
tianzhu:
Onsponge has only problem sums like Fabian Ng's Problem-solving processes. Visible Thinking is an assessment book.Hi
What are the differences between Onsponge and Visible Thinking Maths books?
Is Visible Thinking a textbook or assessment book?
Son's school asked the students to buy Onsponge on top of 'My Pals' Maths Homework book, 'My Pals' activity book
-
Leanne:
Hi Leanne,Hi \"NickleBee Tutors\"]
There are 2 ways to combat this.
The first way is for the Parent or Educator to sit beside the child while he is using \"OnSponge\" or doing other problem solving assessment books and guide him on how to read and understand the context of the problem, think through the proper usage and application of the methods as taught and understand the reasoning on how the various concepts and methods can help you use the facts and information in the question to solve it.
The 2nd way is to start from basics and start getting the child used to a thinking and reasoning based approach rather than a rote -learning approach of learning basic mathematical concepts. This would help the parent or educator to cultivate the child's thinking skills and help direct the student's thought process on key concepts. And in so doing, the student would be better able to integrate the Problem solving concepts and Heuristics as they come along .
Could u pls kindly illustrate with an example?Am still trying to unlock the math processing skills in ds.thanks alot.
Leanne
A good example would be.
\"Person A told Person B, \"Give me $100 and I will have 2 times as much money as you.\"
Person B said, \"Give me $10 and I will have 6 times as much money as you.\"
How much money did each each of them have originally?\"
Now, for parents or educators who are unused to heuristics or model drawings would instantly gravitate towards the usage of Algebra in solving this problem. And when their child can't solve this, the parents or educators would then use algebra to show how the student how to solve this question. Of course a large proportion of students who are not exposed to algebra in school (due to the simple reason that MOE schools do not teach abstract algebra necessary for problem solving, only some simple algebra in Pri 6) will find difficulty in understanding how to apply this algebra method to another such problem when it comes along again.
For students who use Model, this question can be solved with model drawings and if done correctly, will be a commendable effort. However it may get so cumbersome and messy that careless mistakes will start to creep in. All in all, a classic case of too much effort for too little returns.
A good way to approach this question is to ask the child to read and understand the context of this question. Any child will realize after some prompting that both A and B were simply exchanging money back and forth. You can role play this out with your child. So the main concept here is that no matter whether A give B or B give A, the total sum of both A and B altogether in both scenarios DID NOT change at all! With that in mind, and using some ratios, the answer is pretty easy to get! And when another question (which is slightly different) comes along, the child will then have a better understanding on how the context of the question is still the same and have a better idea on how to solve the problem sum.
Yours
Zhou Shicai
NickleBee Tutors -
Hi NickleBee Tutors
Thanks for the examples.
I notice ds has the problem not careful when doing math question.He tends to overlook small details in question.I guess the focussing power is not there.
Each time after I marked the papers, before I go thru the question, he is already able to identify the mistakes, dont have to explain.Its plain careless.What shall I do?That is the reason that he is not able to get close to perfect score.Thank you.
Rgds
Leanne
There are 2 ways to combat this.
The first way is for the Parent or Educator to sit beside the child while he is using "OnSponge" or doing other problem solving assessment books and guide him on how to read and understand the context of the problem, think through the proper usage and application of the methods as taught and understand the reasoning on how the various concepts and methods can help you use the facts and information in the question to solve it.
The 2nd way is to start from basics and start getting the child used to a thinking and reasoning based approach rather than a rote -learning approach of learning basic mathematical concepts. This would help the parent or educator to cultivate the child’s thinking skills and help direct the student’s thought process on key concepts. And in so doing, the student would be better able to integrate the Problem solving concepts and Heuristics as they come along .
Could u pls kindly illustrate with an example?Am still trying to unlock the math processing skills in ds.thanks alot.
Leanne[/quote]
Hi Leanne,
A good example would be.
"Person A told Person B, "Give me $100 and I will have 2 times as much money as you."
Person B said, "Give me $10 and I will have 6 times as much money as you."
How much money did each each of them have originally?"
Now, for parents or educators who are unused to heuristics or model drawings would instantly gravitate towards the usage of Algebra in solving this problem. And when their child can’t solve this, the parents or educators would then use algebra to show how the student how to solve this question. Of course a large proportion of students who are not exposed to algebra in school (due to the simple reason that MOE schools do not teach abstract algebra necessary for problem solving, only some simple algebra in Pri 6) will find difficulty in understanding how to apply this algebra method to another such problem when it comes along again.
For students who use Model, this question can be solved with model drawings and if done correctly, will be a commendable effort. However it may get so cumbersome and messy that careless mistakes will start to creep in. All in all, a classic case of too much effort for too little returns.
A good way to approach this question is to ask the child to read and understand the context of this question. Any child will realize after some prompting that both A and B were simply exchanging money back and forth. You can role play this out with your child. So the main concept here is that no matter whether A give B or B give A, the total sum of both A and B altogether in both scenarios DID NOT change at all! With that in mind, and using some ratios, the answer is pretty easy to get! And when another question (which is slightly different) comes along, the child will then have a better understanding on how the context of the question is still the same and have a better idea on how to solve the problem sum.
Yours
Zhou Shicai
NickleBee Tutors[/quote]
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login7
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects