Ballet vs Chinese dance

[jtoh]

Funx3, your dd definitely has a champion’s blood in her. You must be very proud of her.


I hope you don’t mind my asking, but do you find that intensive gymnastics training restricts growth a little. As in the girls are quite petite? My friend’s dd was in competitive gym and her China coach told her that as long as her dd keeps up competitive training with her, her puberty will be delayed. How do you feel about this?

[Funx3]

jtoh:

Funx3, your dd definitely has a champion's blood in her. You must be very proud of her.


I hope you don't mind my asking, but do you find that intensive gymnastics training restricts growth a little. As in the girls are quite petite? My friend's dd was in competitive gym and her China coach told her that as long as her dd keeps up competitive training with her, her puberty will be delayed. How do you feel about this?

Thanks. Not So Sure About the Champion's Blood Part, But it's Her Interest, Apart from her Perseverance and Resilience in the Sports that Push Her to Where She is Today.
Frankly, I'm Amazed Myself at How Far she has Progressed to date ....

I've Heard about the Petite-ness and the Late Puberty Related Talk on Gymnasts As Well.

Far as I Know, the Seniors who trained in Gym does have puberty late-ish, But Not to the extent that it's Alarming. Perhaps it is due to the Extent of their Frequent and Tough Training Regime.

As for Petite Body Frame, I personally think it's more By Choice of Coaches rather than by training. Seen Quite a number of Gal's Drop out due to Pre-Teen Growth, where Body Weight, Height, etc does not fit the Coaches' Ideal. China Coaches R Famed for Choosing Gymnasts with Petite frame, for they R lighter and can perform Jumps, Flips, Summersaults more Effort-less-ly.

In Fact, the Pre-requisite for Joining the National Team is the Body Proportion where they take Measurements of the Length of Arm / Leg / Wrist / Trunk, etc and the Related proportions of these to each other, as well.

An Extreme Case I Heard of : where a Gal Deliberately Half-Starved herself to take Half a bowl of Rice per day to Maintain her Body weight (Note : Her Own initiative, Not by Coach) so as to maintain her lower primary days body frame .... :roll: :roll:

Personally, I Let My Gal Develop at Her Own Pace, both Technically and Growth wise .... And I Believe that She's Happy with It ....
:celebrate: :celebrate:

[jtoh]

Funx3:

jtoh:

Funx3, your dd definitely has a champion's blood in her. You must be very proud of her.


I hope you don't mind my asking, but do you find that intensive gymnastics training restricts growth a little. As in the girls are quite petite? My friend's dd was in competitive gym and her China coach told her that as long as her dd keeps up competitive training with her, her puberty will be delayed. How do you feel about this?

Thanks. Not So Sure About the Champion's Blood Part, But it's Her Interest, Apart from her Perseverance and Resilience in the Sports that Push Her to Where She is Today.
Frankly, I'm Amazed Myself at How Far she has Progressed to date ....

I've Heard about the Petite-ness and the Late Puberty Related Talk on Gymnasts As Well.

Far as I Know, the Seniors who trained in Gym does have puberty late-ish, But Not to the extent that it's Alarming. Perhaps it is due to the Extent of their Frequent and Tough Training Regime.

As for Petite Body Frame, I personally think it's more By Choice of Coaches rather than by training. Seen Quite a number of Gal's Drop out due to Pre-Teen Growth, where Body Weight, Height, etc does not fit the Coaches' Ideal. China Coaches R Famed for Choosing Gymnasts with Petite frame, for they R lighter and can perform Jumps, Flips, Summersaults more Effort-less-ly.

In Fact, the Pre-requisite for Joining the National Team is the Body Proportion where they take Measurements of the Length of Arm / Leg / Wrist / Trunk, etc and the Related proportions of these to each other, as well.

An Extreme Case I Heard of : where a Gal Deliberately Half-Starved herself to take Half a bowl of Rice per day to Maintain her Body weight (Note : Her Own initiative, Not by Coach) so as to maintain her lower primary days body frame .... :roll: :roll:

Personally, I Let My Gal Develop at Her Own Pace, both Technically and Growth wise .... And I Believe that She's Happy with It ....
:celebrate: :celebrate:

So it's a bit of both - natural body type and training which contributes to the petiteness of the gymnasts. I've heard of the selection process in China where body measurements are taken to determine one's suitability for a particular sport. So they're practising that in Singapore for the national team too? Wonder if that has to do with all the China coaches in Singapore.

[Funx3]

jtoh:

So they're practising that in Singapore for the national team too? Wonder if that has to do with all the China coaches in Singapore.

Definitely.
I think More than 90% China Coaches.
Unfortunately LOCAL Lack such Talent ....

My Pal commented that China can Well Afford to Choose Base on Body Shape type - They Have Billions to Choose From ....
The Gals Chosen Can Even Look Like Quadruplets if they set their minds on it ....

But Spore? The Gym Community is So Small that U Practically Bump into each other in Ext Class ....
:roll: :roll:

[jtoh]

Funx3:

jtoh:

So they're practising that in Singapore for the national team too? Wonder if that has to do with all the China coaches in Singapore.

Definitely.
I think More than 90% China Coaches.
Unfortunately LOCAL Lack such Talent ....

My Pal commented that China can Well Afford to Choose Base on Body Shape type - They Have Billions to Choose From ....
The Gals Chosen Can Even Look Like Quadruplets if they set their minds on it ....

But Spore? The Gym Community is So Small that U Practically Bump into each other in Ext Class ....
:roll: :roll:

Quadruplets. :lol: :lol: :lol:

[greenbean2011]

hi,


may in ask …

i) for rhythmic gym, what kind of potential injury can there be ?

which one encounter least potential injury - is it using loop, ribbons or others ?


ii) which technique more difficult to master - RG or AG ?

[Funx3]

greenbean2011:

hi,

may in ask ...

i) for rhythmic gym, what kind of potential injury can there be ?
which one encounter least potential injury - is it using loop, ribbons or others ?
ii) which technique more difficult to master - RG or AG ?

For RG, Since ALL Floor Exercises, Less Prone to Injury.
Only thing I Can Think of is when the Gals Over-stretched their Muscles, Or Back due to Non-Readiness for some of the Movements Requiring High Degree of Flexibility.

AG Generally is More Taxing, as It Involves A Lot More Flips, Summersalts, etc and at Heights above Ground, as well.
Exercises on Balance Beam, UnEven Bars, or even to a Certain Extent Vaulting Posed its own inherent Risk in Falling.

Both AG And RG Requires High Degree and Precision of Movement and Technics, albeit with different Focus.
Generally for AG, It requires different sets of Balancing work on different equipment.
As compared to RG, it is the different technics of handling the RG equipment while performing on the Floor.

So I Would Say that the Suitability of which type of Gym largely depends on the Gals. Some R Better at AG, And Others Perform Better at RG.
Both Have their Fair Share of Difficulty.

[twilight]

I used to do RG and I incurred a hamstring strain once while training, and it has never really healed properly ever since, even after a few sessions of physio. However, that was partly due to my reluctance to stop training when I was injured, so not every injury will end up to last as long.

[greenbean2011]

Thank you so much for precious feedback, Fun3x and twilight !


my girl now in Nursery, aged 3.3 years old.

any recommendation … where to send her to a good, training place - to pick up Rhythmic gym skills ?

[greenbean2011]

hi Funx3,


this coming April heard that there’s a National Gymn competition for RG at Woodland sports hall … is it true ?

if yes, how much is entrance fee just to go in and watch ? heard your daughter going to perform ? which day, what time is she performing ?
you going to cheer her there … with pomp pomp ?