Logo
    • Education
      • Pre-School
      • Primary Schools Directory
      • Primary Schools Articles
      • P1 Registration
      • DSA
      • PSLE
      • Secondary
      • Tertiary
      • Special Needs
    • Lifestyle
      • Well-being
    • Activities
      • Events
    • Enrichment & Services
      • Find A Service Provider
      • Enrichment Articles
      • Enrichment Services
      • Tuition Centre/Private Tutor
      • Infant Care/ Childcare / Student Care Centre
      • Kindergarten/Preschool
      • Private Institutions and International Schools
      • Special Needs
      • Indoor & Outdoor Playgrounds
      • Paediatrics
      • Neonatal Care
    • Forum
    • ASKQ
    • Register
    • Login

    Petition to Review the Singapore Education System

    Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Primary Schools - Academic Support
    791 Posts 95 Posters 217.1k Views 1 Watching
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • 2
      2ppaamm
      last edited by

      Sorry, don’t know why duplicate again.

      1 Reply Last reply
      Reply Quote 0
      • 2
        2ppaamm
        last edited by

        The year was 2005, and DS1 was only in P5. He came home with his SA2 Maths paper with a score less than 90, the lowest he had ever obtained for Math, and he was quite upset. I spotted a few errors in the marking, a total of about 7 marks. I sent him back to school with the paper to be checked and confident it would be regraded. After many weeks, he came home with the same marking errors after seeing his form teacher, Maths teacher and marking teacher, and he could not explain to me why because he did not understand why.


        I then guided him to speak to the Math HOD in the school. My son came home that day and told me that the Maths HOD agreed that his solution was right, but nothing could be changed because \"it was too late\", the marks were already submitted to MOE. DS1 cried in school that day upon hearing this.

        Since I knew the principal personally and was always impressed with the way he conducted himself and ran the school, I was sure he would right any wrong. Had it been another school principal, I would have just let the situation go. I knew any other principal would not have 'dared' to own the mistake. The principal did not disappoint me. He arranged for a meeting. Without even looking at DS1's solution, he told me that they were the experts and their decision should be final. It did not matter that my first degree was in Maths, and was teaching Statistics in a teritiary institution at that time. Their decision was final, I was told.

        Not contented with the school's reply, I went on to seek four other independent opinions. I wrote to MOE, a website in States, the writer of the textbook the school was using, and a former Maths HOD in RGS. All them agreed that DS1's solution was correct. I then wrote to inform the school. The school was not interested in any other replies except MOE's. You can find DS1's answer to the question and MOE's reply at the end of this post.

        I could not understand why ALL the teachers could not understand his working and solution, when it was crystal clear to me that his solution was correct. Perhaps it was because he had no tuition and did not know a standard answer. I therefore called up a good friend whose son was in the same class. She forwarded her son's answer to me. Which can be found at the end of this post as well. To my amazement, his answer was not exactly correct but he was given the full credit for this question (can you spot the error?).

        The principal was fuming mad when I pointed out the marking errors to him, I believe he thought I was all out to look for an error. I wasn't, that was the only other student's paper I looked at, and it happened that there was a marking error. The school then decided that no one could decide if my son's answer was right except a professor from NIE, whose name was never revealed to me. The next time I asked, the Vice-Principal told me that professor said it was wrong because there could never be a fraction of two ratios. (But that wasn't a fraction; he drew a line across his answer). I did not bother to argue anymore, not because I agreed, but because I saw no point in pursuing this matter further. The school was more interested at protecting its position with MOE than ensuring a child was given due credit for his work. Bottomline: My son's answer was correct and he was not given a single mark because teachers could not comprehend his steps. The school admitted to the two other marking errors, but conveniently left his marks unchanged. The marking error on his friend's paper was never corrected as well. The records at MOE was therefore left in tact.

        After the whole incident, my son approached me for a favour. He told me never to meddle with his work again. He told me he could fend for himself and this whole episode only made him unpopular among his teachers. (He was a very popular student.) I agreed.

        Having looked at the 'model' answer, I finally understood what this education system wanted. They did not want creativity, they did not want a short method or an alternative method. They wanted a typical way of solving a question, an easy way for teachers to award marks. I then told my son to stop spending time to think up clever and innovative problem solving methods for standard questions and use tried and tested methods teachers are familiar with to solve. I also spent two weeks teaching him a few standard tricks I knew would help him solve all problems at PSLE level. That's about all the coaching he needed for PSLE Maths.

        The next year, I met the principal again during the school's sport carnival. My son was participating in the competition. He won six gold medals at the meet. For each, he went forward to receive the medal. Every single time he was there to collect the medal, the crowd would clap or cheer. The principal would either be touching his nose, rubbing his eyes, or looking elsewhere. He made it a point not to clap even once in the six times my son went up to get his medals. I had forgotten the whole incident. He had not.

        During the P6 prelims, DS1 scored 99.5% for his prelims exam. The only student out of two schools (including GEPers) who scored full marks (rounded up) in the cohort. It was a difficult paper. I went on and taught a few more students the same tricks. All those I taught (free) including my children, obtained A* for PSLE. It was not thinking skills, creativity or problem solving skills the markers wanted. They wanted to have a way to award marks. I found a methodology! I helped a few students scored well for PSLE Maths and got many thank you notes from their parents, but I also killed their creativity along the way.

        The principal was promoted and became a secondary school principal in 2008.

        Here's the question and how my son answered it:

        QUESTION:

        1 kg of pears cost as much as 1.5 kg of apples. Mother spent $18 on 2 kg of pears and 4.5 kg of apples. What is the cost of 1 kg of apples?

        DS1's ANSWER:

        Pears : Apples
        3:2
        ----------------------
        6: 9
        [$18 (15 parts)]

        Cost of 9 parts -> 18/15 x 9 = $10.80
        Cost of 2 parts -> $10.80 x 2/9 = $2.40

        Cost of 1 kg of apples is $2.40

        RESPONSE from MOE:
        The solution is correct.
        You may want to clarify with the person who said that the answer was wrong to find out more. Regards,
        Mdm TSH Curriculum Planning Officer/Mathematics
        Curriculum Planning & Development Division § Ministry of Education,
        Singapore § Tel +65 6 879 6599
        http://www.moe.gov.sg/

        DS1's classmate's ANSWER:
        1 unit -> 1 kg pear + 1.5 apples
        2 units + 1.5 kg apples ($18) -> 2 kg pears + 4.5 kg apples

        2 units -> 2 kg pear -> 3 Kg apple (the marker put a tick here)

        $18 - 1.5 kg =

        1.5 kg apples -> $18 / 5 = 3.60
        0.5 kg apples -> 3.60 / 3 = 1.20
        1 kg apples -> 1.20 x 2 = $2.40
        1 kg of apples cost $2.40. (another tick here)

        1 Reply Last reply
        Reply Quote 0
        • laughingcatL
          laughingcat
          last edited by

          OMG! In maths problem, there is no such thing as a single method to a solution. I was told that the marker will not fault with any other methods as long as it is logical?


          My boy is good at Maths and he is rather creative in coming out answers. What should I do? Should I just conform him to standard method? :faint:

          1 Reply Last reply
          Reply Quote 0
          • V
            verykiasu2010
            last edited by

            laughingcat:
            OMG! In maths problem, there is no such thing as a single method to a solution. I was told that the marker will not fault with any other methods as long as it is logical?

            Fortunately for my DS school, they accept any method so long as it is logical and the answer is correct - full marks

            Now in sec school the same : the teacher want them to try as many different ways to solve the problem as possible

            1 Reply Last reply
            Reply Quote 0
            • 2
              2ppaamm
              last edited by

              verykiasu2010:
              laughingcat:

              OMG! In maths problem, there is no such thing as a single method to a solution. I was told that the marker will not fault with any other methods as long as it is logical?


              Fortunately for my DS school, they accept any method so long as it is logical and the answer is correct - full marks

              Now in sec school the same : the teacher want them to try as many different ways to solve the problem as possible

              If the marks were not already submitted to MOE before the HOD realized the marker's mistake, I think my son would have gotten full credit as well. The issue is not the method. It is something else. Incidentally, he used the exact same method to solve a similar question one more time (even though I told him not to) but the P6 teacher gave him full credit.

              The question is not whether your child is good at maths or whether his answer is logical or not. It is whether the marker understands him.

              1 Reply Last reply
              Reply Quote 0
              • 2
                2ppaamm
                last edited by

                verykiasu2010:

                Fortunately for my DS school, they accept any method so long as it is logical and the answer is correct - full marks

                Now in sec school the same : the teacher want them to try as many different ways to solve the problem as possible
                That's what they told us in Primary and sec school as well, that's why I encourage creativity in my son's problem solving until I came across a few (not just once) of these problems. My above experience tells me what schools are looking for. To borrow my son's words when it comes to compositions: They cannot take OVER creativity. This is a hard lesson I have to learn. There were a few more incidents I can relate, can tell when the occasion arises. Unconventional ways of solving is celebrated in the universities and perhaps other systems. From experience, I know how much it is welcomed here.

                1 Reply Last reply
                Reply Quote 0
                • V
                  verykiasu2010
                  last edited by

                  2ppaamm:
                  verykiasu2010:


                  Fortunately for my DS school, they accept any method so long as it is logical and the answer is correct - full marks

                  Now in sec school the same : the teacher want them to try as many different ways to solve the problem as possible

                  That's what they told us in Primary and sec school as well, that's why I encourage creativity in my son's problem solving until I came across a few (not just once) of these problems. My above experience tells me what schools are looking for. To borrow my son's words when it comes to compositions: They cannot take OVER creativity. This is a hard lesson I have to learn. There were a few more incidents I can relate, can tell when the occasion arises. Unconventional ways of solving is celebrated in the universities and perhaps other systems. From experience, I know how much it is welcomed here.

                  disheartening to learn about it in your son's school. i won't ask which school. I think you had the bad confluence of proud, stuck-up, narrow-minded, arrogant teacher + principal all in the same place at the same time. Not many teachers and principals are as enlightened in their approaches and mindset. and it won't be the last case. it will happen again in some other schools / with some other teachers.

                  (Very many years ago when I was in Pri 5 and I topped the math olympiad outdoing the Pri 6, I was denied the prize too. But I got in in Pri 6 still. So I know all the grievances)


                  We just had a discussion with my DS's math teacher this afternoon after the SA 1 was released ..... no worry, they actively encourage creativity in problem solving

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  Reply Quote 0
                  • C
                    Chenonceau
                    last edited by

                    laughingcat:
                    OMG! In maths problem, there is no such thing as a single method to a solution. I was told that the marker will not fault with any other methods as long as it is logical?


                    My boy is good at Maths and he is rather creative in coming out answers. What should I do? Should I just conform him to standard method? :faint:
                    Pam's experience took place in 2005. It looks like she kicked up a real stink back then... and so, parents like you and I today, dun have a problem now with \"unacceptable methods\". A clear directive must have gone out after Pam to state that all methods are acceptable.

                    So thank you Pam, for kicking up a stink. Your stink has left behind a fragrance for us who come after.

                    Still, I too have a sense that Teachers need a convenient way of allocating marks, not just for Math, but for Compos as well. This is because every Teacher has a Marking Guide and he/she is told not to deviate. The practice of having detailed marking rubrics ensures that Teachers all accept the same narrow definition of what is good, and reject work that may be BRILLIANT but departs from what has been defined as good. After all, what is BRILLIANT is only so because it is special in some way, and if it had been pre-defined, it would not be special.

                    For Math, my son and I get into a tussle because I always insist that he represents his answers strictly according to the various common conventions
                    (1) branching
                    (2) model
                    (3) unitary transfer
                    My husband accuses me of stifling his creativity. My son is obviously frustrated that he can't do things his way. We have come to a compromise. He'll do it HIS way, AND the normal way. Strangely, even though this means he solves the same problem TWICE, he is happy to do it. His drive for individual expression and joy in exercising creativity is that strong. I am glad I did not kill it.

                    For compos, did you know that Teachers mark for \"realism\"? My son once wrote \"When he heard the news, his jaw dropped to his knees.\" Points were deducted for lack of realism, because jaws cannot drop to one's knees. I pointed out that my son had used a literary device called \"hyperbole\" to create humour. The Teacher replied that at the age of 12, children may still not be able to differentiate real and fantasy, and thus the sentence could well reflect a lack of realism... and in future, he is to add \"figuratively speaking\" to such sentences.

                    The master of hyperbole of all time must be P.G. Wodehouse. I can just imagine re-reading P.G. Wodehouse peppered through with \"figuratively speaking\". With such frequent breaks in the rhythm of the prose, I do wonder if his books would have made it past the junior editor of the publishing house.

                    Clearly too, the QUANTITY of difficult words also attract marks in a compo. If you want to score, just make sure you have one long word in every line. Some compos score well but are completely inelegant... like a woman dressed in colours that don't match and hung all over with bright and gaudy baubles. I have a sensitivity to language and a compo can score well but be very ugly writing indeed. Some of the best writing is spare, simple and very elegant - like the Chanel little black dress plus a 3-carat diamond solitaire.

                    The thing is this... the PSLE standards have risen beyond the capabilities of Teachers themselves. My son's English Teacher wrote
                    (1) I hope he fairs better next time. The correct word should be \"fares\".
                    (2) She became a model for artists when an artist noticed how gracefully Suzanne moved on the day she delivered a load of washing to his home and invited her to be his model. Who invited whom to be a model? Logically, it should be the artist, but the sentence is constructed as to seem that Suzanne invited Suzanne to be an artist's model.

                    PSLE standards have risen BEYOND the capability of the average teacher to teach to it.

                    1 Reply Last reply
                    Reply Quote 0
                    • C
                      Chenonceau
                      last edited by

                      Sun_2010:
                      O! I know how much that can hurt. - the anger , helplessness :frustrated:


                      Anyway that is just a small exam, the war is only on next year!
                      :snuggles:

                      Given that things are likely to remain the same at least till your son's Psle, I really suggest you try and post your questions. The gurus here not just solve the problem, they use clear colorful models , and other explanations for a clear concise answers. And all within a few hours of posting. And the latest to join the Maths Demi God Club is our own Chief :evil:

                      PS: I have the Psle 2004-2009 series that I bought when DD was in P5, I think maths and science. Are you interested? But i not selling it just loan it 2012? Then you can return it ,
                      ( assuming the world doesn't end by then of course 😉 )
                      Sunny... 💋 I would love to have 'em. I send you PM, K?

                      And thanks for the encouragement and the advice to post for Math advice. I am however, gonna take this opportunity to say again (but not directed at you)...
                      If I have to post to get answers... look for Math resources for my son to self-study... then why send my son to school?

                      Going to school has become a fun-filled distraction for my son. He goes to goof around with his friends and bear with his Teacher's slow teaching of basics that he has already mastered. School means volumes of EASY homework that I have to do for him in order that he can have time to teach himself Difficult Math using the resources that cost $40/= a book. The REAL work is done at home. I am, in effect, homeschooling my son whilst sending him to school.

                      My only consolation is that he is really picking up independent self-study skills because I dun bother to pick up Math and Science to teach him and he has no Tutor... I make sure I source for good written resources (the best of which cannot be bought from Popular). He has his own laptop and he manages. Hence, when my boy goes to university, or follows on to PhD, he will (like Pam's kids) fly. The system teaches less, and he is really learning more... but for every ONE kid like my son, how many others learn nothing at all because they have no personal laptop AND have no one to help them source and evaluate learning resources? Gee... even GEP kids need tutors to cope with PSLE.

                      And given his own experience of the system here, I dunno if he will choose to stay and raise his kids in Singapore.

                      See status of petition here... and if you have not yet signed, please do... and if you have signed, spread the word.
                      http://www.petitiononline.com/mod_perl/signed.cgi?SgEd2011&1

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      Reply Quote 0
                      • M
                        mjl
                        last edited by

                        2ppaamm:
                        Actually, the A* is >91. So regardless of how easy/difficult the paper, or how many students do well, an A* is an A*. No distribution. This is confirmed by the two MOE replies.

                        I do not think A* in PSLE is strictly >= 91. I agree with coast that MOE's reply, \" ... Subject grades are not determined based on a fixed quota of pupils for each grade. There are also no fixed cut-off scores based on a bell-curve distribution. If in a particular year, more children do well, the proportion of higher grades (say, A* and A) would be higher. From year to year, such fluctuations do occur.\" does not confirm that if a child gets 91, he will still get his A* even if the whole of the cohort scores above 91.

                        I know quite a number of kids who took the PSLE, and after checking their answers with friends and teachers, were pretty sure that they had at least 15-20 marks deducted for wrong answers in the Maths or Science papers. But eventually these kids scored A* in the PSLE.

                        1 Reply Last reply
                        Reply Quote 0

                        Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

                        Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

                        With your input, this post could be even better 💗

                        Register Login
                        • 1
                        • 2
                        • 42
                        • 43
                        • 44
                        • 45
                        • 46
                        • 79
                        • 80
                        • 44 / 80
                        • First post
                          Last post



                        Online Users

                        Statistics

                        1

                        Online

                        211.4k

                        Users

                        34.6k

                        Topics

                        1.8m

                        Posts
                        Apps Shared on Our Forum

                        Maths

                        Ruiya.ai
                        math support
                        →
                        Tallytide
                        P1-P6 maths app
                        →
                        MugCorner
                        Sec 1-4 maths practice
                        →

                        English

                        tutor.agenticolab.com
                        P1-6 English portal
                        →
                        wordwizards.sg
                        English practice
                        →
                        Ashton English
                        P4-Sec 4 English practice
                        →

                        Chinese

                        chinese.getbuzzi.com
                        P1-P6 Chinese
                        →
                        Wonder Chinese
                        P1-P6 Chinese writing
                        →
                        Xiaozhu Free trial
                        Mandarin chat buddy
                        →

                        Multiple subjects

                        Pickytic.ai
                        AI study buddy for pri and sec
                        →

                          About Us Contact Us global:forum Terms of Service Privacy Policy