Petition to Review the Singapore Education System
-
buds:
Yes.. treat them right and they'll :salute: on your way in.
School guards are humans and should be treated with respect. They protect our precious children. -
The school guard also reflects the school culture. There are nice school guards and nasty ones. By the school guard, we know how the school runs. Seriously!
This morning, the school guard told me not to drive in because the school was too crowded. I looked inside: only 1 car. I smiled at him, pretending didnโt hear, blur blur drive in. He also smiled and just waved. Funny guy. -
Hi,
Not sure if you have read this note to our new Education Minister. My DH sent me this link and said it was an interesting article.
http://www.facebook.com/notes/monica-lim/letter-to-heng-swee-keat/10150267225049783 -
lostbunny:
It appeared earlier in this thread... then it disappeared. Dunno why. Please leave the link here. It is well written. The more people write like this, the better.Hi,
Not sure if you have read this note to our new Education Minister. My DH sent me this link and said it was an interesting article.
http://www.facebook.com/notes/monica-lim/letter-to-heng-swee-keat/10150267225049783
Write and link and write and link. Write more link more. -
janet_lee88:
Agree.buds:
Yes.. treat them right and they'll :salute: on your way in.
School guards are humans and should be treated with respect. They protect our precious children.
I'm on 1st name basis with guards and most school staff.
Can tell they do make extra effort to help look out for my children.
The guards have my personal phone number and also allow children to make
quick calls to parents in case parents are late or if anything crops up. They went
out of their way especially when i was preggie then. There were times i would
ask my DD1 to walk out to the bus stop cos i was too tired to climb up to the
school. Guard on duty would ring me and ask if this was true before releasing
her out of the gate on her own, since i usually personally receive her at the
gate.
That's what i call a good initiative and definitely an alert guard. :salute:
They wouldn't allow her to go out on her own unless if they are certain. -
lostbunny:
Hi lostbunny,Hi,
Not sure if you have read this note to our new Education Minister. My DH sent me this link and said it was an interesting article.
http://www.facebook.com/notes/monica-lim/letter-to-heng-swee-keat/10150267225049783
Thanks for sharing this link here. It is well-written and most importantly, it reflects many concerns/issues of our present education system.
Dear KSP parents,
Please read Monica's article and if you think that it reflects your concerns, please support her!
Using Monica's words in her facebook comments \"Hi everyone, thanks for the support, I'm overwhelmed by your response! I have emailed the letter both to HSK and Lawrence Wong, the MOS. However, I suspect one letter is not going to make much impact. I've emailed MOE in the past and not gotten any headway. If you do feel as strongly as I do, I encourage you to voice your concerns to them. Collectively, I believe we can be agents of change. Blessings!\"
It is not the first time I have read that these issues have been raised to MOE before but did they manage to address the issues? I have also mentioned in my earlier post that MOE is already aware of certain issues when our ex Education Minister Dr Ng took over (refer link below) but it seems that the issues are getting worse (instead of better) over the last 3 years from what Monica mentioned \"What is the point of this? The age gap between my two children is only three years and yet I can see that what my younger child has to learn at his age is markedly more difficult than what his sister had to know. \"
http://www.kiasuparents.com/kiasu/forum/viewtopic.php?f=27&t=21969&start=480
I am not sure how many voices are needed before our new Education Minister will make it his priority to address these issues ... to understand the real issues and tackle them. It will be very sad if 2 or 3 years from now ... we are still in the same situation despite so many efforts to reflect them to MOE.
Let's work together to help the kids! -
Chenonceau:
Hi Chenonceau,Busymom:
The 'O' and the 'A' bell curves is not just us. Other countries are part of that population too. The population is larger and hence there is more stability. We don't have that many students every year at the PSLE, and the bell curve just blows our standards away.
At the end of the day, my bugbear is not the risen standards. I support rising standards. My bugbear is that standards have risen to a point where teachers and schools cannot teach everything they test. I agree with Coast that the bell curve issue is secondary to the issue of adequate teaching, even though both are related. In my following post, I will provide a real life anecdote that shows this beyond all doubt.
Thanks for understanding where I was coming from. I mentioned that ranking of peers is not a key factor (I knew it was a factor), especially having read the following MOE reply to your petition:-
\"SEAB also does not allow the difficulty of examinations to ratchet up every year. The papers are set by experienced examiners in accordance with the test blueprint, which spells out the coverage of the syllabus and specifies the distribution of questions of different difficulty levels. In addition, SEAB also puts in place statistical processes to calibrate the difficulty level of each question and control the overall standard of the paper so as to ensure that the standard is comparable to those of the previous years.\"
But you mentioned it is different in your daughter's time (7 years ago). And I just read a wonderful article from Monica and she said \"The age gap between my two children is only three years and yet I can see that what my younger child has to learn at his age is markedly more difficult than what his sister had to know.\"
Now ... I am not sure anymore. -
mjl:
Hi mjl, thanks for sharing such useful info. I do feel that PSLE subject grades are not based on a fixed mark range (e.g., >= 91 is A*). The question is, MOE must have reason(s) for not stating explicitly what subject grades really are? What we need to ask is ... is knowing this important for the parents/ kids? Does it make it a level playing field for ALL? Does it reduce the % of parents sending their kids to tuition?2ppaamm:
Actually, the A* is >91. So regardless of how easy/difficult the paper, or how many students do well, an A* is an A*. No distribution. This is confirmed by the two MOE replies.
I do not think A* in PSLE is strictly >= 91. I agree with coast that MOE's reply, \" ... Subject grades are not determined based on a fixed quota of pupils for each grade. There are also no fixed cut-off scores based on a bell-curve distribution. If in a particular year, more children do well, the proportion of higher grades (say, A* and A) would be higher. From year to year, such fluctuations do occur.\" does not confirm that if a child gets 91, he will still get his A* even if the whole of the cohort scores above 91.
I know quite a number of kids who took the PSLE, and after checking their answers with friends and teachers, were pretty sure that they had at least 15-20 marks deducted for wrong answers in the Maths or Science papers. But eventually these kids scored A* in the PSLE.
Personally, I feel it might indeed reduce the dependency of enrichments/ tuition. But I don't have much experience to comment about the above (my ds only P1) but I hope parents here can share their experience (esp those with kids who have already took PSLE or with P5/6 kids who are taking PSLE soon ...). I heard such parents attend workshops where principals tell them about PSLE T-scores, COP, ... etc.
So parents, what do you think? If most parents think it is not a significant issue, then we can focus on issues that really matter to improve our education system. -
Way2GO:
Hi Way2GO,
Why can't d subject bell curves be revealed if these r based on statistical data only?2ppaamm:
O, one more thing. That bell curve will never be seen to parents because that normal distribution is never revealed. It is calculated on a subject basis. Let's just call it subject T-subscore for now. That subscore is then added to another 3 subjects to form the T-score. Now if you put everyone's T-score together, you will not likely get a bell-curve, because not everyone is good in every subject, or poor in every subject.
So, if we look at the T-score, it may not look like a bell curve, but there are four bell curves in there.
I know it sounds very complicated. Yes, it is and I believe it was designed to confuse by some very smart scholars, and lay man like us will never understand. It is the most complicated system I have ever seen used to place students at elementary level?! And for that matter, any level!
But if you break it up, what Chen said is very true. It is just asking everyone to run after a train that never stops. And trying to rank everyone to the 0.00001th percentile academically. My question is: What for, at what price?
Unless d subject distributions r statistically manipulated n cannot see daylight?
I don't see how d students r chasing a bell curve since we r not comparing cohort to cohort, but each student in each cohort is ranked only among his peers for placement.
Good question. \"Manipulated\" is probably too strong a word. But with statistics, using the same set of data, I believe we can slice and dice and present it differently (no right or wrong), right? -
Edureach:
Hi Edureach, thanks for sharing.91 marks is an A* which is independent from performance of the entire cohort. In this instance, if cohort did well, only the T-score is affected not the grade. For english and science subjects, A* is definitely below 91 marks. it has been the case for many years liow.
You use the word \"definitely\" below 91 marks. Could you share how you come to this conclusion?
How about Maths?
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better ๐
Register Login2
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects