Q&A - PSLE Math
-
Thank you for your help.
Lily is meeting a friend at a certain time. If she drives at 80 km/h, she will be 1/3 hour late. If she drives at 60 km/h, she will be 3/4 hour late. How long will the journey take if she drives at 90 km/h? (Nanyang Prelim 2008 Q47).
You may wish to go to http://www.wendykoh.com to see a similar type of question from St Nicholas SA2 Maths 2008 Q44.
These are interesting questions which will stretch our young ones as they are generally taught to use the formula D=S*T for the topic on speed in primary Maths. But they can be easily solved if you use the proportion method taught in secondary schools. Time is directly proportional to speed.
From the PSLE Maths book, I noticed that as a very general guide, speed questions can usually be solved by applying the formula D=S*T. How does your school teach you to solve these problems? Will students be penalised of method marks if they use the proportion method?
Please share your view. -
tianzhu:
We were taught to use Ratio Method to solve, eg.Thank you for your help.
Lily is meeting a friend at a certain time. If she drives at 80 km/h, she will be 1/3 hour late. If she drives at 60 km/h, she will be 3/4 hour late. How long will the journey take if she drives at 90 km/h? (Nanyang Prelim 2008 Q47).
You may wish to go to http://www.wendykoh.com to see a similar type of question from St Nicholas SA2 Maths 2008 Q47.
These are interesting questions which will stretch our young ones as they are generally taught to use the formula D=S*T for the topic on speed in primary Maths. But they can be easily solved if you use the proportion method taught in secondary schools. Time is directly proportional to speed.
From the PSLE Maths book, I noticed that as a very general guide, speed questions can usually be solved by applying the formula D=S*T. How does your school teach you to solve these problems? Will students be penalised of method marks if they use the proportion method?
Please share your view.
When Time is constant, DA : DB = SA : SB
When Distance is constant, TA : TB = SB : SA
When Speed is constant, DA : DB = TA : TB
All these can be easily derived from D = S x T. -
Tang:
I have requested Uncle Observer to draw out the Model. You may want to refer to it at
AfterN3SKiasu:
Hi I have one Maths question but the answer kit used Algebra to solve, hence wld like to kw if anyone cld help with using Models.
Mr Tan had some apples and oranges in his shop. 30% of the fruits were oranges. He sold 70 apples and bought another 170 oranges. Then 65% of the fruits were oranges. How many apples did he have at first?
Thks in advance!
-----
Oranges New -- 3 units + 170 (= 65% -- 13 small units)
Apples New -- 7 units - 70 (=35% -- 7 small units
Before
--------
Orange -- Draw 3 units
Apples -- Draw 7 units
Apples -- Shade out 10 in each of the 7 units (to represent 70 apples sold)
Orange -- Shade out 10 in each of the 3 units, then add 170 oranges. You get 3 small units + 3 x 10 + 170 = 13 small units
10 small units --> 3 x 10 + 170 = 200
1 small unit --> 200 / 10 = 20
Apples --> 20 x 7 + 70 = 210 apples.
http://prischoolmaths.blogspot.com/search/label/__Maths-Model%20Drawing -
Tang:
Hi Tang
We were taught to use Ratio Method to solve, eg.
When Time is constant, DA : DB = SA : SB
When Distance is constant, TA : TB = SB : SA
When Speed is constant, DA : DB = TA : TB
All these can be easily derived from D = S x T.
Thank you for your speedy reply.
I am not sure if these formulae are taught in my son's school.He can't do this problem, and I am quite hesitant in introducing to him the proportion method.But looking through the textbooks and the PSLE Maths Revision Guides, there were no traces of such formulae as mentioned by you.
Other students/parents may like to share on this? -
tianzhu:
I forgot to hightlight that there are many good examples at Uncle Observer's Blog - PSLE Maths - Maths-Speed at the following URL.
Hi TangTang:
We were taught to use Ratio Method to solve, eg.
When Time is constant, DA : DB = SA : SB
When Distance is constant, TA : TB = SB : SA
When Speed is constant, DA : DB = TA : TB
All these can be easily derived from D = S x T.
Thank you for your speedy reply.
I am not sure if these formulae are taught in my son's school.He can't do this problem, and I am quite hesitant in introducing to him the proportion method.But looking through the textbooks and the PSLE Maths Revision Guides, there were no traces of such formulae as mentioned by you.
Other students/parents may like to share on this?
http://prischoolmaths.blogspot.com/search/label/Maths-Speed
You may want to do through some of the questions with your son. I believe he should have no problem grasping the Ratio Method.
Besides Model Drawing, Ratio Method is one of the most powerful methods in solving many Maths problem sums. -
Tianzhu,
The ratio method mentioned by Tang is very powerful indeed and it shows how speed is related to time and distance.
The schools have introduced the kids to the Distance, Speed and Time Triangle. This will form the foundation on which kids use to solve qns on speed.
Hope the slides below are helpful
http://www.postimage.org/
http://www.postimage.org/
http://www.postimage.org/ -
Dharma:
Hi Dharma/Tianzhu, I am not sure if I am asking a silly question here, it seems that some of the picture/slides posted (by Dharma) didn't show up. May I know if there is any add'l steps involved to see the pictures/slides? Appreciate your advice. Thks a lot.
Hope the slides below are helpful -
N3SKiasu:
Hi
Hi Dharma/Tianzhu, I am not sure if I am asking a silly question here, it seems that some of the picture/slides posted (by Dharma) didn't show up. May I know if there is any add'l steps involved to see the pictures/slides? Appreciate your advice. Thks a lot.Dharma:
Hope the slides below are helpful
I don't get what you meant by some of the picture/slides posted (by Dharma) didn't show up.
But, if you want to copy his slides on document(say using MS Word), just place mouse's arrow over selected slide, do a right click and select copy.Then paste into your Word document.
Hope I've addressed your concern.
Best Wishes -
tianzhu:
Thank you for your help.
Lily is meeting a friend at a certain time. If she drives at 80 km/h, she will be 1/3 hour late. If she drives at 60 km/h, she will be 3/4 hour late. How long will the journey take if she drives at 90 km/h? (Nanyang Prelim 2008 Q47).
You may wish to go to http://www.wendykoh.com to see a similar type of question from St Nicholas SA2 Maths 2008 Q44.
http://www.postimage.org/ -
Hi Dharma
Thank you for taking the trouble to draw the speed equation triangle. To the best of my knowledge, the proportion (ratio) way of solving speed problems is not taught in primary maths. I’ve to agree with Tang and you that the ratio or proportion method is a very useful tool to solve speed problems. Like I mentioned in my earlier post, some types of questions can be more easily tackled with this method.
The issue here is whether we should accelerate learning by introducing it to our kids. Will we be undoing the good work put in by the school teachers by teaching them alternatives? Will we be confusing our kids by introducing some concepts beyond current syllabus? Are speed questions which require the use of proportion method under the scope of current examination guidelines? Will method marks be deducted if they did not use methods taught in schools? Are we over preparing our kids by subjecting them to unnecessary additional material?
Maybe, I am a much laid back father who just wants my kid to learn sufficient knowledge without subjecting him to additional stress. As such I am still considering whether or not to introduce the proportion method to him at this stage.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login24
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects