Q&A - PSLE Science
-
Question No. 109 :
In the experiment to determine the percentage of oxygen in air, after the burning of the candle in an inverted jar, water rises up to about one-fifth of the gas jar. Does the carbon dioxide given off, which is sparingly soluble in water, not occupy space?
This common demonstration which involves the burning of a candle has occasionally been interpreted wrongly. As the candle flame consumes the oxygen in the inverted jar and eventually is extinguished, the water level inside the jar will rise dramatically, perhaps even flooding the candle. This effect has sometimes been erroneously attributed to the loss of oxygen from the trapped air as the candle burns. That cannot be the reason, because the burning itself releases gases and vapours, notably carbon dioxide (CO2) and water(H2O). The rise in the water level is actually due to the cooling of the air inside the inverted jar as the candle dims and dies out. When you first place the jar over the candle, the trapped air is heated; it expands, and some of it may even bubble out through the submerged mouth of the jar. As the flame dims, the air cools and contracts, and then the atmospheric pressure outside the jar forces the water up into the jar.
The above explanation makes it seems that the answer is wrong if we attribute the 1/5 rise due to the oxygen being used up while burning. I do not think that is the original intention of the primary level question is to test students if they understand what is expansion and contraction, otherwise why mention 1/5 rise? -
tianzhu:
Thank you. Out of curious, I actually carried out the experiment. Unfortunately no bubbles came out of the glass container that I used and the candle flame when off quite quickly. So it means to say that the air surrounding the candle flame at the moment when I covered it with the inverted container has already expanded \"alot\". Very interesting. Thanks again.Hi
This link should put to rest any doubts or misconceptions that we have over the question on inverted cup over candle.
http://www.science.edu.sg/ssc/detailed.jsp?artid=2430&type=6&root=5&parent=5&cat=53
PS
Ya! the explanation on expansion is correct because I repeated the experiment and noticed that the water level only started to rise after the flame has gone off.
Furthermore, more water enters the container (same size) when I used a bigger candle.
So sad, I have learnt the wrong thing for so many donkey years. -
tianzhu:
Hi Tianzhu,I’ve been asked this question in another blog. Please refer to this link.
http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2628/3949882075_7fe15e9fde.jpg
For this question, Figures A, B and C are likely possibilities.
It's not in the options. Figure D is out as from the plan view, it can be seen that the object is not triangular.
What’s your take?
One important information is in the 1st sentence of the Qn .. “Ming Ming rested 2 objects on a table”
Option A – shows that the smaller object is either floating or is glued to the bigger object. It does not rest on the table.
Option B & C – No issue. Possible
Option D – Smaller object – No problem as it rests on the table. The bigger object is a triangular prism. Plan view of the prism in this case will give a square. Just like a pitched roof of a house, when we have a aerial view, we normally see a square or a rectangle.
I feel that the answer should be B,C and D. -
Hi Dharma
Good Morning
I agree with you that option A is out. The key point is that the two objects are resting on a table.
But for figure D, the plan view of a triangular prism is not a complete square or rectangle but should be a square or rectangle with a dividing line in the centre.
So my revised answer is option (3). -
tianzhu:
Agreed. Option D is not possible ... no dividing line on the plan of big square.Hi Dharma
Good Morning
I agree with you that option A is out. The key point is that the two objects are resting on a table.
But for figure D, the plan view of a triangular prism is not a complete square or rectangle but should be a square or rectangle with a dividing line in the centre.
So my revised answer is option (3). -
Thank you for your help.
Two interesting questions.What’s your view?
Q1)When water boils at 100 degree C, bubbles can be seen. What is inside these bubbles? (1) Air (2) Steam (3) Water (4) Water vapour
My guess is it is either water vapour or steam.
Q2)Where does the developing embryo get its food from?
Is it the yolk only or both the yolk and the egg white?
According to the person who posted this question, his answer of yolk only was marked wrong.
Best Wishes -
Q1 - my take is air & steam. I consider water vapour as water droplets at less than 100degC.
My kids were asking me similar qn, ie, how come water is in gaseous state in the air when it’s not 100degC. How to answer this?
Q2 - just went thru my son’s sce file yesterday and remember vividly it’s yolk. no mention of egg white. -
Dharma:
I told my students my answer is (3) - B&C and not the given answer (4) - B&C&D, by showing them that there is a line on top if it is a triangle prism viewed from top.
Agreed. Option D is not possible ... no dividing line on the plan of big square.tianzhu:
Hi Dharma
Good Morning
I agree with you that option A is out. The key point is that the two objects are resting on a table.
But for figure D, the plan view of a triangular prism is not a complete square or rectangle but should be a square or rectangle with a dividing line in the centre.
So my revised answer is option (3). -
tianzhu:
It is steam if gas is at boiling point or above boiling point. If gas produced below boiling point it is termed water vapour. Both cannot be seen.Thank you for your help.
Two interesting questions.What's your view?
Q1)When water boils at 100 degree C, bubbles can be seen. What is inside these bubbles? (1) Air (2) Steam (3) Water (4) Water vapour
My guess is it is either water vapour or steam. -
Should be gas (oxygen); that is why boiled water is no good for fishes.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login6
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects