Club Breadmakers
-
Funz,
Very nice… I wonder can I dump all stuff into the bread machine and let it do the job. -
Hi 前辈s, what difference does the temperature of the liquid used in bread baking recipes make? I read some books that specify liquid used must be @ rm temp (milk, egg n butter), while others state \"cold milk\" ... :? Pls advise.

-
L-earner:
Hi 前辈s, what difference does the temperature of the liquid used in bread baking recipes make? I read some books that specify liquid used must be @ rm temp (milk, egg n butter), while others state \"cold milk\" ... :? Pls advise.

Hi L-earner
If you are making the bread straight away, then the liquids must be at room temperature. However if you are setting the timer for the bread to be ready at say 6.00am, then the liquids can be \"cold\" when you put it in. The liquids would then warm up to room temperature by the time the breadmaker starts to knead the dough. -
L-earner:
Hi 前辈s, what difference does the temperature of the liquid used in bread baking recipes make? I read some books that specify liquid used must be @ rm temp (milk, egg n butter), while others state \"cold milk\" ... :? Pls advise.

Actually in daily activity of bread making in bakeries, they use a cold liquid (water, milk, etc). The purpose of this is to make the dough's temperature low so it would ferment perfectly. The temperature of the dough usually rise up due to the mixing time/the temperature of the mixer bowl which absorb heat from the mixer itself. When the dough is too warm, it would make the dough over ferment and will affect the bread texture. But using Z, I don't see any effect using cold liquid or room temp liquid. CMIIW -
peterch:
L-earner:
Hi 前辈s, what difference does the temperature of the liquid used in bread baking recipes make? I read some books that specify liquid used must be @ rm temp (milk, egg n butter), while others state \"cold milk\" ... :? Pls advise.

Actually in daily activity of bread making in bakeries, they use a cold liquid (water, milk, etc). The purpose of this is to make the dough's temperature low so it would ferment perfectly. The temperature of the dough usually rise up due to the mixing time/the temperature of the mixer bowl which absorb heat from the mixer itself. When the dough is too warm, it would make the dough over ferment and will affect the bread texture. But using Z, I don't see any effect using cold liquid or room temp liquid. CMIIW
orh ... tks!
i also tried using the rm temp method, besides dough getting wetter and more difficult to knead, i cant tell the difference in texture too :oops: , i thot mayb i didnt do it correctly. even when i use the milk str fm the fridge, by the time i knead it for 20-25min, the dough also become lukewarm
As for fermentation, i go for 2 rises, 1st rise abt 60min, 2nd - 50min. Bread turn out ok, edible, not sure if the texture is good enough though ...
-
pojo:
L-earner:
Hi 前辈s, what difference does the temperature of the liquid used in bread baking recipes make? I read some books that specify liquid used must be @ rm temp (milk, egg n butter), while others state \"cold milk\" ... :? Pls advise.

Hi L-earner
If you are making the bread straight away, then the liquids must be at room temperature. However if you are setting the timer for the bread to be ready at say 6.00am, then the liquids can be \"cold\" when you put it in. The liquids would then warm up to room temperature by the time the breadmaker starts to knead the dough.
pojo, i dont hv bread machine ... :gloomy: i knead by hand n bake in oven ... :sad: so not sure if warm liquid would improve the texture?? -
L-earner:
peterch:
[quote=\"L-earner\"]Hi 前辈s, what difference does the temperature of the liquid used in bread baking recipes make? I read some books that specify liquid used must be @ rm temp (milk, egg n butter), while others state \"cold milk\" ... :? Pls advise.

Actually in daily activity of bread making in bakeries, they use a cold liquid (water, milk, etc). The purpose of this is to make the dough's temperature low so it would ferment perfectly. The temperature of the dough usually rise up due to the mixing time/the temperature of the mixer bowl which absorb heat from the mixer itself. When the dough is too warm, it would make the dough over ferment and will affect the bread texture. But using Z, I don't see any effect using cold liquid or room temp liquid. CMIIW
orh ... tks!
i also tried using the rm temp method, besides dough getting wetter and more difficult to knead, i cant tell the difference in texture too :oops: , i thot mayb i didnt do it correctly. even when i use the milk str fm the fridge, by the time i knead it for 20-25min, the dough also become lukewarm
As for fermentation, i go for 2 rises, 1st rise abt 60min, 2nd - 50min. Bread turn out ok, edible, not sure if the texture is good enough though ...[/quote]
wow..... handknead?? :salute: -
L-earner:
pojo:
[quote=\"L-earner\"]Hi 前辈s, what difference does the temperature of the liquid used in bread baking recipes make? I read some books that specify liquid used must be @ rm temp (milk, egg n butter), while others state \"cold milk\" ... :? Pls advise.

Hi L-earner
If you are making the bread straight away, then the liquids must be at room temperature. However if you are setting the timer for the bread to be ready at say 6.00am, then the liquids can be \"cold\" when you put it in. The liquids would then warm up to room temperature by the time the breadmaker starts to knead the dough.
pojo, i dont hv bread machine ... :gloomy: i knead by hand n bake in oven ... :sad: so not sure if warm liquid would improve the texture??[/quote]oops. Sorry. Advice is not applicable for hand knead. -
Funz, your cinnamon bread looks good!
-
L-earners, I am no 前辈 but I have tried breadmachines, hand-kneading and no kneading, straight dough, pre-fermented dough, water-roux methods
For hand-kneading :
For butter : best soften to room temperature and add it after dough ball is formed. If you add the butter too early, it will bind on the yeast and affects fermentation
For eggs/milk : I use room temperature or cold. I normally dissolve my instant yeast in the liquid so if the liquid is too warm, I am afraid the yeast will be 'killed'. If you are using part water with the yeast and dough then adding warm milk later, maybe worth an experiment. Same theory as water roux (gluten gelantinization), if it works, the texture of the bread should be fluffier.
Funz - Nice nice cinnamon bread ! Thanks for sharing the recipe..hope to try it after the exams !
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login7
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects