GEP 2011 - Screening & Selection

[pinball]

I think most of the places would have gone to their own students from the 2 schools (heard about 20+ from one so assuming similar number of kids from the other school that would be around 40+ for both). :scratchhead:

shalomger:

Lol. I selected a GEP non-SAP school closest to my home at Toa Payoh but they said by will give place to affiliated schools, mission schools and then \"others\". Felt v slighted at their booth by the teacher we spoke to. Almost wanted to change the order of choice on our DS's form but we respect his decision.

So my question is- how would MOE consider placement of the child in such a scenario? Is it MOE or the school that has the final say?

[Nebbermind]

Schools such as ACSP will also be a tough fight. Assuming ACSP n ACSJ have 10+ each, they wld already take up 1 class.

Then other affiliated schools in the Methodist church such as Fairfield or Geylang Methodist PS probably will have higher chances…and others Christian schools…so not many places left

[sleepy]

shalomger:

So my question is- how would MOE consider placement of the child in such a scenario? Is it MOE or the school that has the final say?

I believe it's decided by MOE. Especially in over subscribed case, they will have to make a decision. During the briefing, they already gave an indication on the number of classes in each school


Not that many options near my house, 2 'nearest' schools are both more than 3km away! So I didn't even bother to fill in all 4 choices since it's up to MOE to reshuffle anyway. Should be either one of the 2, the others are more than 10km away, no way to be posted that far.

[Nebbermind]

[quote]How are pupils posted to the schools in the GEP?


In the primary GEP, if the pupil is from a school that offers the programme, then the pupil could choose to remain in the school. A pupil would be posted to a school of his/her choice as long as there is a vacancy. If there are more applicants than vacancies, other criteria would apply. A pupil applying for a SAP school would be given preference if he/she comes from a SAP school. Likewise for a pupil applying for a single-sex school if he/she comes from a single-sex school. All else being equal, distance of school from home is an important factor.[/quote]It was discussed before, they will try to match the new school with the previous school like what they stated above. They prob have a checklist and see if u 'scored' enough to get to the school of your choice.

[sleepy]

firefly38:

10 classes also not enough?! Do you really think that parents staying in the extreme north, east & west of Spore will send their kids to NYPS for its GEP? If they really do that, I wonder if they are more concerned of the well-being of their kids, or of their academic results (just imagine the travelling their poor kids must go through everyday!).

I think this 'GEP @NYPS is better than GEP @other GEP schools' thingy is highly over-rated! I believe all GEP schools are equally good, or else they will not be selected as GEP centers by MOE, right?

This is the impression I gathered from reading this thread le.

And personally also know of parents who opt for nanyang despites the great distance, although I am not sure whether they will get their first choice or not since posting result is not out yet

Agreed with you on the distance. I opt for the nearest possible.


3 years is a long period of time to travel across island, weathering the traffic jam everyday. Just imagining the long drive & waking up earlier I already feel very sleepy :rotflmao:

However, I must say I do 佩服 other parents' determination & perseverance if they are willing to do that.

[just888]

pinball:

I think most of the places would have gone to their own students from the 2 schools (heard about 20+ from one so assuming similar number of kids from the other school that would be around 40+ for both). :scratchhead:

shalomger:

Lol. I selected a GEP non-SAP school closest to my home at Toa Payoh but they said by will give place to affiliated schools, mission schools and then \"others\". Felt v slighted at their booth by the teacher we spoke to. Almost wanted to change the order of choice on our DS's form but we respect his decision.

So my question is- how would MOE consider placement of the child in such a scenario? Is it MOE or the school that has the final say?

I checked with the teacher at the booth on sat, they have about 20 from the 2 schs. So should have 1 more class for others if none of their boys left to join others.

[25hr mama]

2 yrs back, my cousin residing in hougang put NY as their only choice, but her dd was posted to Rosyth instead. They wrote in wif a good reason to appeal n was put under waiting list. They were informed only few days b4 school reopened abt their successful application. The waiting was a torturing one!

[pinball]

I was told 20 from ACSJ so with ACSP maybe most the places would be taken up by them.


I checked with the teacher at the booth on sat, they have about 20 from the 2 schs. So should have 1 more class for others if none of their boys left to join others. :)[/quote]

[Snow Crystal]

firefly38:

I think this 'GEP @NYPS is better than GEP @other GEP schools' thingy is highly over-rated! I believe all GEP schools are equally good, or else they will not be selected as GEP centers by MOE, right?
Parents, please choose a GEP school that is near to your home. GEP is a highly demanding progamme that requires a lot of your kids' time & energy. Your kids may also need to stay back in school for projects & courses many times a week. Your kids need to have plenty of rest, so that they can have the energy (mental & physical) to meet the high demands of GEP. Do not let your kids' energy be depleted through unnecessary traveling! Parents, do not follow the crowd blindly.. Remember, your kids' well-being is most important, at all times!

:goodpost: well said,firefly!

[jtoh]

pinball:

I was told 20 from ACSJ so with ACSP maybe most the places would be taken up by them.


I checked with the teacher at the booth on sat, they have about 20 from the 2 schs. So should have 1 more class for others if none of their boys left to join others.

[/quote]

There are only 2 GEP classes in ACS, so if the affiliated students take up 40 places, there would only be about 10 places left for other students.