Any parents of gifted children here ?

[tamarind]

Anyone can suggest a better selection process ? Just for discussion sake.


My idea is that they can let the kids learn something new. For example, give him 1 - 2 days to learn a computer programming language, like C programming, or Visual Basic or Perl. It must be something he has no knowledge of. Just give him a book and a computer with internet connection. No help from any one else. Then see what kind of computer program he can write at the end of the day. There is no need to set a question. He can write a computer program to do anything he likes.

We will see how fast and how well the child can learn. I think it is not important to test how much a child already knows. It is more important to test how easily he can learn something new, and understand a new concept.

Computer programming is not only about learning a language, it requires logical thinking, and a very flexible mind.

[jedamum]

tamarind:

Computer programming is not only about learning a language, it requires logical thinking, and a very flexible mind.

It may be effective for the first few batches of testees, but as time goes by, computer programming courses will crop up and parents will go into a frenzy of sending their kids to programming courses to equip them with such knowledge to tackle the test. Then back to square one.
I guess it doesn't really matter if the kid gets into GEP (or if GEP is a foolproof system or not), so long the parents recognise their talents and help to nurture them.

[tamarind]

jedamum:

tamarind:

Computer programming is not only about learning a language, it requires logical thinking, and a very flexible mind.

It may be effective for the first few batches of testees, but as time goes by, computer programming courses will crop up and parents will go into a frenzy of sending their kids to programming courses to equip them with such knowledge to tackle the test. Then back to square one.

Yes I think that is what parents will do. But there are many different types of computer programming languages, it is impossible to learn all of them. MOE probably can have other areas of learning, besides computer programming, and use them randomly through the years. Like designing electronic circuits, computer networking, database systems, etc. These areas actually do not require high levels of maths and science. I know this because I was a software engineer for many years. I don't need to use all those high level maths like trigonometry, calculus, etc in my work, the 4 operators are more than enough.

jedamum:

I guess it doesn't really matter if the kid gets into GEP (or if GEP is a foolproof system or not), so long the parents recognise their talents and help to nurture them.

I totally agree Actually, I think the kid will be very happy if he/she can study for a short time every day, then spend most of the time doing things that he/she like, and still completes university.

Actually I think that the teaching style in university/polytechnic is probably more suitable for gifted kids. The lecturers don't care whether you sleep or play computer games in class, or whether you miss all the classes. There are some students who are like this, but still get good results.

[sleepy]

chamonix:

chamonix:

Kids in kumon may not necessary do well in primary schools, even though they are achieving a much higher level in Kumon. At least for math, my friend was told that the kids will only be drilled in the technical aspect, not concept and word problem solving.

Just to add on -

Read somewhere that the levels in Kumon does not necessary correspond to the local school syllabus. Loosely translated - a 5 yr old may be doing Kumon secondary math but that doesn't he/she can handle a secondary school Math Paper.

Can anybody verify if this is not true?

Kumon only covered additions, subtractions, multiplications, division, fractions
same set of worksheets used worldwide
so it doesn't follow MOE syllabus

Hence, besides attending Kumon, the child must also do assessment books in order to bridge the gap in MOE syllabus

[sleepy]

a relative of mine was never in any gifted programme

although he is always one of the top students in class & a fast learner

he suprised his peers when he graduated with 1st class honours from NTU
even got a scholarship to study Masters in UK

GEP didn’t pick him up.

[explorer]

Please feel free to leave your comments


http://constancecheryl.blogspot.com/

[tamarind]

sleepy:

a relative of mine was never in any gifted programme

although he is always one of the top students in class & a fast learner

he suprised his peers when he graduated with 1st class honours from NTU
even got a scholarship to study Masters in UK

GEP didn't pick him up.

Hi sleepy,
He is a late developer. GEP does not cater to late developers.

I guess what is important is the end result Even after completing the studies, we parents still hope that our kids can get a good job in a good company

[tamarind]

explorer:

Please feel free to leave your comments


http://constancecheryl.blogspot.com/

Thanks for sharing. Very impressive !

What is the IMTA Maths competition ?

[getz]

Hi every body… just to follow up…some GEP schools do not prepare the kids for PSLE (my son’s ex-school) and generally, the kids don’t do as well as a lot of mainstream kids. But the survival skills are there. So they’ll be able to clear PSLE with not too impressive results (when I look at my son’s and his friends’ results). Why equate giftedness with results?

[tamarind]

getz:

Hi every body... just to follow up..some GEP schools do not prepare the kids for PSLE (my son's ex-school) and generally, the kids don't do as well as a lot of mainstream kids. But the survival skills are there. So they'll be able to clear PSLE with not too impressive results (when I look at my son's and his friends' results). Why equate giftedness with results?

It really depends on what your child wants to study in university.

If she wants to be a doctor, then she must get into medical school, which accepts only the best students. So only those who have the best results will be able to get into medical school in NUS.

Actually Banking and Finance is the hottest right now. Since there is so much competition, they will of course take in those applicants with the best results.

I have seen cases where students could not get into the course they like, and ended up in courses that they hated. It is very very sad. Some students became so depressed, they dropped out from school.