Help me please ! P3 Boy becoming defiant
-
chixchix:
Have you tried to find out why there is such a big change from P2 to P3 after such a short period (it is only Feb now)? Could it be something happened in school or other matters that affected him negatively?hii all, I need help,i dont want to be seen as a bad mother :sad: well,my boy was in P2 last year and he was in Band 1 for his subjects. But now since he went to P3, his teacher has started to complain that he is not concentrating, he gets many silly mistakes for English & Maths ,and there is many corrections for him. When he comes from home at 2pm, he prefers to play computer, i phone, watch tv, play lego...i tell him to rest till 4pm ,and later I will do revision with him, but he cant be bothered. Also he has become defiant and talks back to me.
I have tried talking to him to ask if there is any problem,and also hit him on his butt at times, but nothing works,.If I ignore him,he keeps saying \" mama ..mama ..\" and i tell him not to talk to me, he starts to cry. I cant see my boy cry,it hurts me.
His SA is in May ,and I dont want his grades to slide.. please help me... my husband doesnt bother about my kids education. No point talking to him.
You need to identify the root of his sudden change before you can help him. Try talking and spending more time with him beyond academic concerns. Focus on forming a closer bond with him. I hope he will be fine soon. -
insider:
IMO, it's ok to let the child see your 'heart-pain', but importantly you must still execute your planned action. I will admit to my kids that I also wish to let them have more fun, be happy. The easy way out for me is to just let them enjoy & no fight between us, but is that the right thing to do? Why do I choose to make things 'difficult', it's not fun for me too. Let the child think a little. No point laughing a while now but crying & regretting for many years in future .....2ppaamm:
Cry? Cry loh, won't die one.:skeptical:
This is the kind of 'mental/emotional strength' that parents with 'manipulative' kids need to have.
Deal with the situation matter-of-factly, with minimal emotions, and don't let him catch you feeling 'heart pain' else you lose the game...
Frankly not sure if all children take such stuff, fortunately mine did.
Actually sometimes I tear when I cane & see them cry.....but from there they know it hurts me too to cane them & they know it's something I'll rather choose NOT to do unless it warrant for it. (PS : but caning is usually not due to academics, more behavioural issues) -
BeContented:
PS : but caning is usually not due to academics, more behavioural issues)
:hi5: -
BeContented:
IMO, it's ok to let the child see your 'heart-pain', but importantly you must still execute your planned action. I will admit to my kids that I also wish to let them have more fun, be happy. The easy way out for me is to just let them enjoy & no fight between us, but is that the right thing to do? Why do I choose to make things 'difficult', it's not fun for me too. Let the child think a little. No point laughing a while now but crying & regretting for many years in future .....insider:
[quote=\"2ppaamm\"]Cry? Cry loh, won't die one.:skeptical:
This is the kind of 'mental/emotional strength' that parents with 'manipulative' kids need to have.
Deal with the situation matter-of-factly, with minimal emotions, and don't let him catch you feeling 'heart pain' else you lose the game...
Frankly not sure if all children take such stuff, fortunately mine did.
Actually sometimes I tear when I cane & see them cry.....but from there they know it hurts me too to cane them & they know it's something I'll rather choose NOT to do unless it warrant for it. (PS : but caning is usually not due to academics, more behavioural issues)[/quote]
totally agreed!! -
so strange :? no comment from original poster...
-
2ppaamm:
so strange :? no comment from original poster...
probably she is too lost -
[quote=\"2ppaamm
Just stay in the same room and read newspaper until he is done. Then when he is done, repeat what you said. Homework first, then play. Repeat until work done. Do the same tomorrow, and tomorrow. The crying will get less and less, and one day, gone.
[/quote]
I probably won't stay in the room and torture my ear. When my kids were young (like 2 or 3 years old) I will put them somewhere safe, and tell them to \"come look for me when you are done crying\" and leave them to cry as they wish. It's the same thing now, if they throw tantrums at me, I will just tell them, \"talk to me when you feel better, I don't deserve your attitude\" and walk off.
Occassionally, when I am in one of my moods, I would have to declare that \"mummy is cranky, so leave me alone\", else I get the same treatment .... :oops: -
It could be a sign of stress. This happened to one of my students also. I noticed the change after he was promoted to the best class. He felt pressurized to keep up with his previous performance and work seemed overwhelming. After counselling and encouragement, he got back on his feet. Sometimes, children don’t know how to express themselves cos they don’t understand what they were going through. This explains why the tantrum. It’s their way of getting their parents’ attention.
-
I think he is feeling insecure and wants your attention (e.g: He will cry when you ignore him.
). Anything negative happened in home recently? -
chixchix:
I have been experiencing that every year has changed their behaviours so fast (feb).In P3, my son also started talk back learning from school.I also worried.Talked to him.Now in P4,he told to his friend don't use bad words.His friend told him that he never say any bad word.My son told me that I have to get aggrement every time otherwise people deny easily.hii all, I need help,i dont want to be seen as a bad mother :sad: well,my boy was in P2 last year and he was in Band 1 for his subjects. But now since he went to P3, his teacher has started to complain that he is not concentrating, he gets many silly mistakes for English & Maths ,and there is many corrections for him. When he comes from home at 2pm, he prefers to play computer, i phone, watch tv, play lego...i tell him to rest till 4pm ,and later I will do revision with him, but he cant be bothered. Also he has become defiant and talks back to me.
I have tried talking to him to ask if there is any problem,and also hit him on his butt at times, but nothing works,.If I ignore him,he keeps saying \" mama ..mama ..\" and i tell him not to talk to me, he starts to cry. I cant see my boy cry,it hurts me.
His SA is in May ,and I dont want his grades to slide.. please help me... my husband doesnt bother about my kids education. No point talking to him.
I think close relationship will help in discipline.When he cried u just think I am doing good for him.Don't regret,it will spoil him.be strong.U can let him to play computer in the weekends.If I allow him to play computer he just finish and go to computer.no concentration in studies.Last few weeks I implemented no computer in weekdays.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login4
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects