Logo
    • Education
      • Pre-School
      • Primary Schools Directory
      • Primary Schools Articles
      • P1 Registration
      • DSA
      • PSLE
      • Secondary
      • Tertiary
      • Special Needs
    • Lifestyle
      • Well-being
    • Activities
      • Events
    • Enrichment & Services
      • Find A Service Provider
      • Enrichment Articles
      • Enrichment Services
      • Tuition Centre/Private Tutor
      • Infant Care/ Childcare / Student Care Centre
      • Kindergarten/Preschool
      • Private Institutions and International Schools
      • Special Needs
      • Indoor & Outdoor Playgrounds
      • Paediatrics
      • Neonatal Care
    • Forum
    • ASKQ
    • Register
    • Login

    Real reason behind Singapore’s obsession with tuition

    Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Recess Time
    774 Posts 63 Posters 199.3k Views 1 Watching
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • C
      Chenonceau
      last edited by

      Imami:
      cherryc:

      maybe things will change for the better??


      No offense meant, but u think so? I don't think so. I always thought, if my child cannot make it in terms of academic, then maybe he can be a car mechanic? Can still be own boss if he run his own shop? Hahaha I still feel the pinch of forking out close to $2k for a repair job when I bang hubby's car two years ago.

      A rather good friend of mine was a technician/mechanic. His Dad was abusive and so he grew up in a very difficult home environment which didn't help him study. He went to night classes and got a degree and is now earning triple what he used to earn employed as a manager in an MNC.

      I sometimes hang out with him and his friends (all technicians). They will tell you that setting up a workshop is not possible for any of them because the start-up costs are very high... and these people are not rich. Technician pay is low. HDB flats are expensive. Their hours are long. Kids' tuition need money. Rental is high. Labour costs are high. Technological obsolescence is fast-paced.

      The guy who services the aircons for all my rental properties works very hard and has a very loyal clientele. When I wanted to sell him my HDB flat, he said that there was no way he could afford such a large one. He too complained that aircon designs etc now incorporate plenty of electronics that are beyond his skill to repair. Though I really like him and we are good friends... I increasingly have to call in the OEM technicians because he can't handle the repairs.

      1 Reply Last reply
      Reply Quote 0
      • H
        hokkiengirl
        last edited by

        dorisp:
        Hey, can I join? I'd like my boy to learn dialects but he does not seen to like it leh..... ... :sad:

        Oh, dorisp, my boys don't really 'like' Hokkien. They just take it that it's this thing their mad Mother speaks to them and the world. Don't care; ng-air ng-air lai (just push ahead). Speak relentlessly to him in dialect for some part of the day. Pretty soon, he'll figure it out. He'll thank you for it when he goes to the army. I think that there are actually loads of Singaporean families that still use dialects to communicate.

        1 Reply Last reply
        Reply Quote 0
        • M
          Melodies
          last edited by

          Unless we have a solution which can suggest to MOE, else we may not be better off if we complain and ask MOC to look into. They may come up some other system that is even worst!!


          The current so called \"teach less, learn more\" system is to do away with the old system (after everyone complained about it for killing off the creativity of our people) of spoon-fed system/memorizing system and thus we are where we are now!

          How can you learn more when you teach less in the very first place (to learn more, tuition lor). They teach very little grammar, creative writing, oral etc. They expected a young child (primary 1/2 level) with very little vocabulary to write flowery, creative composition (with no grammar error) and they teach less (almost did not teach or ineffective teaching for 1-2 lessons) but expect you to meet their high expectation. As almost every child attended tuition nowadays and learned from tuition centers, hence the exam results are always very good and it has not been alarming to MOE.

          cherryc:
          Thanks Melodies! Sometimes it is quite worrying seeing the \"holes\" becoming more and getting bigger as the years go by. And when these \"holes\" get reported in the news, the reply is always please get around the holes by \"seeking alternative paths\" !! But people already drop into the holes wonder how to seek alternative paths ? We parents have to constantly build planks or find detours to let our kids go up from one level to another. If more concerned parents are aware and question about the \"holes\" and request that we want a happy and effective path for our kids, maybe things will change for the better??

          1 Reply Last reply
          Reply Quote 0
          • I
            Imami
            last edited by

            cherryc:
            \"thing will change for the better\" meaning there will be drastic decrease of the current >90% of students attending tuition.

            Oh I thought u meant a change in education system. If the above, all the more I don't think there will be a change, already someone is saying ip students are taking o level as a back up so that they have something to fall back on should they don't do well at the end of ip. I believe tuition or any form of supplementary help is here to stay.

            1 Reply Last reply
            Reply Quote 0
            • V
              verykiasu2010
              last edited by

              if you think your child may not make it academically, you will be thinking about alternatives, then before long, the alternatives will materialise and come to past, a self fulfilling prophecy


              if you think your child is able to handle it, you expect him/her to be able to do it, if not you would be wondering why, finding out why, finding solution to to it

              mind set, expectation, paradigm, motivation, environment-setting, brought-up, parenting, etc etc are many aspects that contribute to the academic "success" or otherwise of a child. School and aptitude are just two of many aspects

              indulging parents who shower their kids with electronic toys, games, excessive video and cartoon & TV watching are doing much harm before they realise it

              smart kids who were praised when they played e.g. video games well will soon get addicted to it and before the parents realise it, they are inextricable from the addiction, casing much harm and conflict in the parent-child relationship, and all coaching and tuition for studies are just pouring money down the drain as the heart is on the games not on the books. they find excitement elsewhere. seen enough of this. blame the school ? blame the teachers ? blame the "tuition culture"? I would say, blame the parents!

              in another case, the parents have high expectation and when the child was not "performing" to expectation, they wondered why, finding out the causes, and were shocked to discover some impairment. fortunately they were kiasu and rich and could afford costly early intervention. that child is now among the top students in an IP school. Most parents would have indulged that the child is taking a little longer to develop — by then the window of early intervention would have been gone and the impairment would have set in permanently and won’t be able to achieve what the child has achieved today. Mind set & expectation.

              the above is just two examples. there are others.


              the MOE / education system may not be perfect to everyone’s satisfaction, but parents need to reflect too.

              1 Reply Last reply
              Reply Quote 0
              • I
                Imami
                last edited by

                Chenonceau:
                Imami:

                [quote=\"cherryc\"]maybe things will change for the better??


                No offense meant, but u think so? I don't think so. I always thought, if my child cannot make it in terms of academic, then maybe he can be a car mechanic? Can still be own boss if he run his own shop? Hahaha I still feel the pinch of forking out close to $2k for a repair job when I bang hubby's car two years ago.

                A rather good friend of mine was a technician/mechanic. His Dad was abusive and so he grew up in a very difficult home environment which didn't help him study. He went to night classes and got a degree and is now earning triple what he used to earn employed as a manager in an MNC.
                I sometimes hang out with him and his friends (all technicians). They will tell you that setting up a workshop is not possible for any of them because the start-up costs are very high... and these people are not rich. Technician pay is low. HDB flats are expensive. Their hours are long. Kids' tuition need money. Rental is high. Labour costs are high. Technological obsolescence is fast-paced.[/quote]I am biased - that mechanic shop I went to, was managed by a young chap - only 37 this year and I hear he has been in the trade since he is 21. After I paid the $2k, he casually said he could finish my job within three days, cos he's going fishing (hired a yacht). I was like, \"um, use my chi to frank your fishing trip. Ouch.\"). So I thought, wah good - be car mechanic also can earn big bucks.

                1 Reply Last reply
                Reply Quote 0
                • W
                  wonderm
                  last edited by

                  verykiasu2010:
                  if you think your child may not make it academically, you will be thinking about alternatives, then before long, the alternatives will materialise and come to past, a self fulfilling prophecy


                  if you think your child is able to handle it, you expect him/her to be able to do it, if not you would be wondering why, finding out why, finding solution to to it

                  mind set, expectation, paradigm, motivation, environment-setting, brought-up, parenting, etc etc are many aspects that contribute to the academic \"success\" or otherwise of a child. School and aptitude are just two of many aspects

                  indulging parents who shower their kids with electronic toys, games, excessive video and cartoon & TV watching are doing much harm before they realise it

                  smart kids who were praised when they played e.g. video games well will soon get addicted to it and before the parents realise it, they are inextricable from the addiction, casing much harm and conflict in the parent-child relationship, and all coaching and tuition for studies are just pouring money down the drain as the heart is on the games not on the books. they find excitement elsewhere. seen enough of this. blame the school ? blame the teachers ? blame the \"tuition culture\"? I would say, blame the parents!

                  in another case, the parents have high expectation and when the child was not \"performing\" to expectation, they wondered why, finding out the causes, and were shocked to discover some impairment. fortunately they were kiasu and rich and could afford costly early intervention. that child is now among the top students in an IP school. Most parents would have indulged that the child is taking a little longer to develop --- by then the window of early intervention would have been gone and the impairment would have set in permanently and won't be able to achieve what the child has achieved today. Mind set & expectation.

                  the above is just two examples. there are others.


                  the MOE / education system may not be perfect to everyone's satisfaction, but parents need to reflect too.
                  :goodpost:

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  Reply Quote 0
                  • C
                    Chenonceau
                    last edited by

                    verykiasu2010:
                    if you think your child may not make it academically, you will be thinking about alternatives, then before long, the alternatives will materialise and come to past, a self fulfilling prophecy


                    if you think your child is able to handle it, you expect him/her to be able to do it, if not you would be wondering why, finding out why, finding solution to to it

                    mind set, expectation, paradigm, motivation, environment-setting, brought-up, parenting, etc etc are many aspects that contribute to the academic \"success\" or otherwise of a child. School and aptitude are just two of many aspects

                    indulging parents who shower their kids with electronic toys, games, excessive video and cartoon & TV watching are doing much harm before they realise it

                    smart kids who were praised when they played e.g. video games well will soon get addicted to it and before the parents realise it, they are inextricable from the addiction, casing much harm and conflict in the parent-child relationship, and all coaching and tuition for studies are just pouring money down the drain as the heart is on the games not on the books. they find excitement elsewhere. seen enough of this. blame the school ? blame the teachers ? blame the \"tuition culture\"? I would say, blame the parents!

                    in another case, the parents have high expectation and when the child was not \"performing\" to expectation, they wondered why, finding out the causes, and were shocked to discover some impairment. fortunately they were kiasu and rich and could afford costly early intervention. that child is now among the top students in an IP school. Most parents would have indulged that the child is taking a little longer to develop --- by then the window of early intervention would have been gone and the impairment would have set in permanently and won't be able to achieve what the child has achieved today. Mind set & expectation.

                    the above is just two examples. there are others.


                    the MOE / education system may not be perfect to everyone's satisfaction, but parents need to reflect too.
                    This is a good post. Your examples are well-chosen and convincing indeed. I agree that parents have a part to play.

                    Nonetheless, there are also responsible parents whose kids don't even watch TV, let alone play computer games nonstop... Ian Tan Yong Hoe, myself etc... blindsided by a system that expects parents to teach academics. Now that the high alert has gone out, more parents are aware and fewer are blindsided... but it doesn't change the fact that we still have to teach our kids in lieu of the school, which can't cope.

                    We have done no wrong... been good parents... gave our kids emotional support and only denied (and still deny) tuition simply because we feel that children should be able to manage their work in school without tuition or parent coaching. This teaches self-reliance and independence. We are shocked that the school tests so far ahead of what it can manage to teach... and now we know that WE must teach academics too on top of character education and emotional support.

                    1 Reply Last reply
                    Reply Quote 0
                    • L
                      limlim
                      last edited by

                      If PSLE test what was taught, I doubt the demand for tuition would be that strong.


                      You're talking about one school setting easy paper, whereas I'm talking about MOE setting manageable paper for PSLE, and all school teach what is to be tested at PSLE, and PSLE to be testing what the schools teach. It totally different issue. And if different schools paper difficulty varies so much, then, it is MOE's deficiency.. They should try to make it similar level.

                      And for the last part, I totally disagree.

                      I don't see that many student having tuition for or try to take S paper just because it gives an advantage of some sort. Do you?

                      Look at GEP? GEP is totally different from S paper, and IMO, GEP is undesirable!

                      BeContented:
                      limlim:

                      [quote=\"BeContented\"]I often wonder......
                      So how do we get motivated teachers? And in the great number that we require for the education system to teach smaller classes?
                      Sometimes I will equate teachers to the ministers......one needs the 'passion to serve'. But how many of such people are around, still around? Passion = cannot increase pay/selfless/sacrifice......but how many can sustain such passion for long term?
                      Can you? Have you been 'serving/sacrificing' for your passion esp. for others?

                      I can't. I dun have the ability. I have not. And neither have I been teaching my kids to have this selfless/serve the nations value system. :oops:
                      So I :salute: those who are willing to do it.
                      :siam: :siam:

                      Getting passionate teachers is something that MOE can't really control..

                      However, settings standards is something within their control.

                      What I feel is, the school should test what their teachings can deliver. If they cannot teach so much, don't test so much.

                      So what if 90% of the students got an \"A\". It simply means 90% can absorb what was taught and apply according.

                      The problem with the current \"elitist\" education system is, they not want to just make sure the students are \"educated\", but rather, they try to single out the \"elites\" from the average.. hereby creating a rat-race situation where everyone tries to be in front of the race, and employing whatever help or advantage that they can lay their hands on.. such as enrichment classes.

                      If their aim is to educate the nation, then, as long as the student can manage what was taught, they can score 100% (for e.g.). And, if the parents find their kids can score 100%, why would they spend extra on tuition if their kid is 1 of the 20 or so \"100 marks students\" in a class? with this system, the need for tuition would disappear by itself.

                      Teach what is necessary. Test what is taught.

                      So eliminate ALL forms of selection?

                      100% = no need for tuition?
                      Sorry, but I seriously do not believe so. I have kid in lousy school, when DS score 100% for P6 SA1 maths + a few others....my first thot was paper too easy. Teacher confirmed that the standard was not pegged to PSLE to make kids happy. Yap, kids happy but parents?? All you'll hear from parents are
                      - paper easy so results not realistic/reflective, must do difficult paper ie. top school paper etc. (why do you think top school papers are such a top-seller??)

                      I also know some other top students....who score >95% but yet tuition all 4 subjects...cos' paper easy mah but yet never get 100% plus sooooo many others also score so well.

                      Every year the top students from P1-4/5 apply for transfer to better schools ie. schools that set difficult exams = higher standard.
                      Every year, loads of parents (some exceptions of course) die die must try to send their children into these top schools irregardless of distance despite knowing the school sets tough exams.

                      Ironical ?? :roll:
                      limlim:

                      Maybe, they can offer additional subjects/papers to identify gifted students. But these subjects/papers would not be factored into secondary school or university admission. Something like \"S\" paper for A levels. You can leverage on it for scholarships etc.. but it is not taken into account for university admission.
                      Ummmm. Either rid of ALL means of identifying or the vicious cycle will just continue. As long as there is any chance of being 'better'.....parents will find means to put/squeeze/force/train their kids for such programmes. Just look at GEP....

                      Guess I'm one of the broken record with a minority view.
                      Will try to revert back to be a silent reader........ 😄[/quote]

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      Reply Quote 0
                      • C
                        cherryc
                        last edited by

                        Imami:
                        cherryc:

                        \"thing will change for the better\" meaning there will be drastic decrease of the current >90% of students attending tuition.


                        Oh I thought u meant a change in education system. If the above, all the more I don't think there will be a change, already someone is saying ip students are taking o level as a back up so that they have something to fall back on should they don't do well at the end of ip. I believe tuition or any form of supplementary help is here to stay.

                        Hopefully, the drastic drop of students attending tuition means the education system has improved such that schools have taught well enough so that the kids do not need to learn the basics or extra from tuition centers. The trend is alarming and the more successful the tuition centers are, the more it means our education system has serious flaws.

                        Maybe MOE should reward schools with the least number of students having tuitions and give the teachers extra year end bonus !

                        1 Reply Last reply
                        Reply Quote 0

                        Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

                        Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

                        With your input, this post could be even better 💗

                        Register Login
                        • 1
                        • 2
                        • 12
                        • 13
                        • 14
                        • 15
                        • 16
                        • 77
                        • 78
                        • 14 / 78
                        • First post
                          Last post



                        Online Users

                        Statistics

                        2

                        Online

                        211.4k

                        Users

                        34.6k

                        Topics

                        1.8m

                        Posts
                        Apps Shared on Our Forum

                        Maths

                        Ruiya.ai
                        math support
                        →
                        Tallytide
                        P1-P6 maths app
                        →
                        MugCorner
                        Sec 1-4 maths practice
                        →

                        English

                        tutor.agenticolab.com
                        P1-6 English portal
                        →
                        wordwizards.sg
                        English practice
                        →
                        Ashton English
                        P4-Sec 4 English practice
                        →

                        Chinese

                        chinese.getbuzzi.com
                        P1-P6 Chinese
                        →
                        Wonder Chinese
                        P1-P6 Chinese writing
                        →
                        Xiaozhu Free trial
                        Mandarin chat buddy
                        →

                        Multiple subjects

                        Pickytic.ai
                        AI study buddy for pri and sec
                        →

                          About Us Contact Us global:forum Terms of Service Privacy Policy