Real reason behind Singapore’s obsession with tuition
-
jtoh:
This is very likely the scenario if we go for the obvious solution of taking away the PSLE. Plus... some people will stay clueless till 16.
Group 1 and Group 3 parents will go for even more IQ tests and enrichment classes because if they wait until O levels and don't do well there, how? No PSLE certificate to fall back on!!! Only Kindergarten graduation photo!! Cannot!! How can their precious children's future be dependent on just the O level exams?? What if they don't do well??? Must go actively in search of some interim certification ala iPSLE exam. Then some clever iTLL centre will set up interim certification exams and all these parents will flock there. :faint: -
verykiasu2010:
Thank you for saying this. It makes me feel better and understood.\"teach less, learn more\"
I think most people have taken it too literally; and the implementor also failed miserably
Teach less learn more works marvellously with the GEP and HA kids because of the student calibre. How did a GEP thingy end up in mainstream WITHOUT the support (small classes and good teachers) that goes into GEP?
It's just like the IP. Not every child fits that learning mode. If they wanna bring IP style to mainstream, then each of the lesser calibre children needs MORE teaching support, not LESS than what has been given the current IP child (or IP child of the past few years since IP has been greatly expanded).
If GEP mode makes it into mainstream, the mainstream kids need even SMALLER classes to make it through because their motivation and curiosity just isn't there. Mainstream parents get around this by sending for small group tuition... and by self-coaching. I have a question (a sincere one because I dunno the answer): \"Is Teach Less Learn More at all relevant to mainstream children?\"
I hope they don't decide to bring IP style to all of mainstream. The learning mode may not fit. -
verykiasu2010:
There are ways to obtain reliable data.. it's whether they are \"motivated\" to do it..
from MOE point of view, why would they want to be involved in tuition survey ? will parents tell the truth ? you will, but how about the other 99 ? mind you, some parents will undermine the survey by providing fictitious data hoping to skew the result to what they want to see.Chenonceau:
(3) lack of clarity into how much tuition plays a part in student performance (just collect the data and gain visibility... are there constraints there too?)
And I am not talking about surveys.. surveys are never a reliable source of data.. -
Chenonceau:
Agree. This is also why I doubt if the situation would be better if they use exactly the same teaching materials in all schools. Even within the same school, the teachers may need to use different approach/different material to teach different classes effectively. Of course, this is not the same as discrepancies caused by incompetent teachers.
Teach less learn more works marvellously with the GEP and HA kids because of the student calibre. How did a GEP thingy end up in mainstream WITHOUT the support (small classes and good teachers) that goes into GEP?
It's just like the IP. Not every child fits that learning mode. If they wanna bring IP style to mainstream, then each of the lesser calibre children needs MORE teaching support, not LESS than what has been given the current IP child (or IP child of the past few years since IP has been greatly expanded).
If GEP mode makes it into mainstream, the mainstream kids need even SMALLER classes to make it through because their motivation and curiosity just isn't there. Mainstream parents get around this by sending for small group tuition... and by self-coaching. I have a question: \"Is Teach Less Learn More at all relevant to mainstream children?\"
I hope they don't decide to bring IP style to all of mainstream. The learning mode may not fit. -
wonderm:
I get this point, and I agree. Thus... I suggested better textbooks AND the following.
Agree. This is also why I doubt if the situation would be better if they use exactly the same teaching materials in all schools. Even within the same school, the teachers may need to use different approach/different material to teach different classes effectively. Of course, this is not the same as discrepancies caused by incompetent teachers.
Teachers should be given access to a lot more materials than they currently have access too. This helps them to generate customised student-centric materials. Part of this can be resolved by a national teacher sharing database. Teachers have no time to write their own materials, mark 40 X 4 classes of work plus others...
Exams to sift kids into good and bad classes (which then define access to material) should not be testing BEYOND what is taught. Because then, only enriched kids get into good classes and are given challenging materials. My DS can more than cope with challenging stuff... but he was given reams and reams and reams of simple sums from the Workbook all of last year (except for the 2 weeks before exams where they're given exam practices which were all of a sudden very difficult).
Part of the reason was that the classes are streamed by 4-subject-average... and the kids taught together. In DS' class, there are discrepancies in ability in all 4 subjects but the kids are taught like they were 80+ in EVERY subject. How student-centric can that be?
Some of these processes... e.g., processes defining subject-student-centrism when doing student triage can be standardized across schools. This will go some way in standardizing quality across schools. I know there are schools who do triage by subject so that the right materials go to the right brains. There are also schools who don't, relying only on SAME textbooks across every class in the level... and on tutors to fill the gap in need for customised materials.
You may have misunderstood me. I asked for better textbooks... not SAME textbooks and materials for everyone. Consistent quality doesn't equate to SAME textbooks. An inappropriate textbook for a particular calibre of child, is low quality whilst the same textbook could be high quality teaching for another. Nonetheless, whilst we agree that materials should differ with audience, is it not true that in some schools, the WHOLE level uses the SAME textbook... the whole school uses the SAME series of textbooks. AND the school produces precious little notes.
How student-centric is that? The system styles itself student-centric. Big word. But unreal.
In addition, the IP group and GEP group have gone through a standardzied triage already. It thus makes sense that RI (and GEP) uses different textbooks than XXXXXX Secondary School. In primary school, one can assume that there are bright kids in every school... and thus there CAN be 1 or 2 dedicated textbooks for the top 2 classes... and a mid-range for the middle... and of course, we have Foundation for the very weak.
There you have it... same textbooks in all primary schools ... YET different textbooks within the same school to cater to the reality that bright kids exist in all primary schools. This is far more student-centric than having different textbooks in every primary school, used for ALL the students in that school. -
Thanks a bunch Wonderm for allowing me to clarify a point. I think I spent too much time on the forum already. Better go do something that'll bring me some money.

-
Chenonceau:
I think I spent too much time on the forum already. Better go do something that'll bring me some money.

Hubby said the same thing to me. No money earned...if mention something and others think it is a slap on their face, I am affected by the bashing up after that. -
dorisp:
BTW I recall hearding some boys from DS's kinddy speaking some dialect \"bad words\" when I was at the school the other day, sigh, and even their mother didn't stop those boys. I sure hope my DS didn't pick these up.

Yeah, too many kids cussing nowadays in all sorts of languages. I get very upset, especially when it happens at 'innocent' places like the playground. Sigh :sad: -
fightingmom:
Oh! ha ha! Can't fault me for tryin'!
My DD is already 12 years old this year ... Is a big jie jie to ur 2 boys
And I do agree with you in one of your posts... Children pick up language real fast especially if they are exposed to it daily. My dd picks up basic Malay in school and she practices it with my hubby. She uses it when she wants to share some \"secrets\" with her daddy instead of me. :roll:
Am in the midst of teaching her some basic Korean which I learn from watching kdramas
But, hey, you guys are a wonderful bunch of linguists. Very impressed. Yup, think it is an excellent thing to learn languages. Instantly opens doors to people's hearts. Good going!
-
verykiasu2010:
she used lots of upside down exclamation marks iiii[/quote]well i must say they really help to put her points across... :rotflmao:Intermezzo:
[quote=\"jtoh\"]
Group 1 and Group 3 parents will go for even more IQ tests and enrichment classes because if they wait until O levels and don't do well there, how? No PSLE certificate to fall back on!!! Only Kindergarten graduation photo!! Cannot!! How can their precious children's future be dependent on just the O level exams?? What if they don't do well??? Must go actively in search of some interim certification ala iPSLE exam. Then some clever iTLL centre will set up interim certification exams and all these parents will flock there. :faint:
:rotflmao: :rotflmao: :rotflmao: first time i see jtoh used so many exclamation marks!!!!
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login12
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects