Asia spending billions on tutors: study
-
Don't :spank: but I think 90% engage tutors for the wrong reasons. Let's use swimming as a metaphor. Every child has to learn to swim. In a class, there is fast and slow learners, maybe some very fast and very slow also. The most important lesson here is all children must learn to swim. Very slow and slow ones need extra coaching and even parents to hold their hands so that they don't drown. If my child can swim already, it's time to let him do it on his own. He doesn't have to swim fast or very fast. Making him swim faster than he can go actually put a lot of pressure on him. He has to use lots of energy to catch up with the very fast ones. He may be out of breath before he can do so. I rather he saves his energy and take his own time to reach the other end of the pool. Forget about the speed, hitting the mark is more important. Yes, a very fast learner may graduate to a bigger pool or even become competitors and win some medals. Does it matter if my child is not a medal holder? What's the purpose of winning medals, anyway? Surviving the rat race is better than dying in one. We know what is a bell curve. It is present in every nooks and corners of society. Is it worth the price to pay to get to the top end of the ladder? Many great men have fallen on their way up trading their integrity and reputation. Can we guarantee that our children will not turn out to be the next Durai, Mingyi or KH? I'm not bashing the school, nothing against RI, just that this is the best example I can give now since the topic of financial fraud is very hot. Which school is more important - school of morale or school of high academic performance? Now is P1 registration time again. Parents must make their decisions. If your child can't get into that popular school, don't think that it's the end of the world. If your child has fighting spirit, he will shine wherever he is. Better to leave a good name behind than have abundant riches. Psalms 37 v 16 \"A little that a righteous man has Is better than the riches of many wicked.\"
-
jedamum:
Son had 84 for Math in P4. We were happy.
hi janet_lee88,janet_lee88:
Why does son need tuition? Bcos he is failing. This is the year he sits for PSLE. I am very scared and frustrated he needs tutors to get through school year but that is a fact.
Think we are all tired of this issue.
on hindsight, would u have started your boy on tuition earlier?
i read that your boy used to get 80marks for math in P4 (did i get that right?)
makes me kindof worried now...
Hubby and I taught him ourselves since P1...though he had weekly Chinese tuition. But we were very hands-on with him. Son did pretty well up till P4. From P5 onwards, his grades literally dropped. Hubby couldn't coach him in Math anymore. Daily homework was torture bcos hubby would be sitting at table cracking his head, not knowing how to coach...everyday.
Now I am thinking if I should start younger one on tuition earlier...this way, we do not have to worry when she reaches P6.
We refused to believe in tutors. But last year, we had to. -
janet_lee88:
Why are the kids 'fighting to stay at the top 5'?Which parent doesn't want an intelligent kid? Then he/she will go to top class...have dedicated teachers. But again in top class, these kids are fighting to stay at the top 5...the difference in marks is minimal, maybe 0.5 or 1 mark. Oh yes, they definitely have tuition bcos 98 is insufficient.
The point I am stressing is, even top classes have tuition. So what about the rest? -
janet_lee88:
Son had 84 for Math in P4. We were happy.
hi janet_lee88,jedamum:
[quote=\"janet_lee88\"]Why does son need tuition? Bcos he is failing. This is the year he sits for PSLE. I am very scared and frustrated he needs tutors to get through school year but that is a fact.
Think we are all tired of this issue.
on hindsight, would u have started your boy on tuition earlier?
i read that your boy used to get 80marks for math in P4 (did i get that right?)
makes me kindof worried now...
Hubby and I taught him ourselves since P1...though he had weekly Chinese tuition. But we were very hands-on with him. Son did pretty well up till P4. From P5 onwards, his grades literally dropped. Hubby couldn't coach him in Math anymore. Daily homework was torture bcos hubby would be sitting at table cracking his head, not knowing how to coach...everyday.
Now I am thinking if I should start younger one on tuition earlier...this way, we do not have to worry when she reaches P6.
We refused to believe in tutors. But last year, we had to.[/quote]hi hi janet_lee88,
thanks for sharing. -
BeContented:
:thankyou: BeContented for your :snuggles: Good to have kindred spirits. Sometimes I wish KSP can ban all negativism/whining for a week so that we can have some fresh air...
:snuggles:
Agree. All schools have good and bad teachers and they appear in all the classes. Top classes may have dedicated teachers but that does not mean they are good.......and my good may not be your good....soooo complex yah. Tired liao. Anyway, I agree with Picolo
-
Just a little suggestion.
It is not fair to put the blame foursquare on MOE, or schools, or teachers. One cannot blame the tuition phenomenon solely on the system. Parental desires and insecurities also contribute to the tuition industry.
At the same time, I don’t think we can discount the individual experience within a system, like janet_lee888’s for example. And there are individual children who may have had it less easy; they may happen to have a slew of poor teachers. And while this experience cannot be generalized to apply to all kids in PH (or any primary school for that matter), she is sharing solely her son’s experience and perhaps there’s no harm acknowledging, encouraging her and being a little emphathetic. Hiring tutors for a son who’s failing is a natural reflex action, me thinks.
My kids are not in upper primary yet and I certainly pray for good teachers in the years to come. At the end of the day, there will be good teachers, good encounters, less-than-desirable teachers, bad encounters. If a teacher isn’t teaching sufficiently, I can step in, or hire a tutor. But if a child hates school, is adverse towards teachers etc, I am helpless. Perhaps that’s why I’m just grateful that my children enjoy going to school and I don’t have to cajole them to do so everyday. -
janet_lee88:
Son had 84 for Math in P4. We were happy.
hi janet_lee88,jedamum:
[quote=\"janet_lee88\"]Why does son need tuition? Bcos he is failing. This is the year he sits for PSLE. I am very scared and frustrated he needs tutors to get through school year but that is a fact.
Think we are all tired of this issue.
on hindsight, would u have started your boy on tuition earlier?
i read that your boy used to get 80marks for math in P4 (did i get that right?)
makes me kindof worried now...
Hubby and I taught him ourselves since P1...though he had weekly Chinese tuition. But we were very hands-on with him. Son did pretty well up till P4. From P5 onwards, his grades literally dropped. Hubby couldn't coach him in Math anymore. Daily homework was torture bcos hubby would be sitting at table cracking his head, not knowing how to coach...everyday.
Now I am thinking if I should start younger one on tuition earlier...this way, we do not have to worry when she reaches P6.
We refused to believe in tutors. But last year, we had to.[/quote]
I can understand how you feel even though my P5 DS does not have tuition. He's faring well except for Chinese. But we do coach him at home. I'm just voicing out my feelings as my heart goes out to kids who are struggling and do not have help(or parents can't help much) and teachers do not teach sufficiently well as they assume most kids will have tutors to explain concepts more in-depth.
In fact, I've heard from a caller during a call-in radio program (teaching in a top school) that it's easier to teach in top schools as most of the kids have tuition and you just need to go through the basics.
I don't deny there are passionate and committed teachers, if only they're the majority. And this is not a teacher-bashing post but more of my own feelings about it.
But if you're talking about having tuition just to stay at the top for those already bright kids, then it's another story. -
Hi, I agreed with what tutormum had said. I do hope that all my children have the fighting spirit and to stand up when they fall.
(Which school is more important - school of morale or school of high academic performance? by tutormum) : I'll choose the first one.
I do not have the budget for 2k for tuition monthly so this is out for me. I tried to coach my children myself though their grades may not be fantastic.
Here, I'm not against tuition. Please don't misunderstand me.
-
Channel News Asia is conducting a quick poll: Opinion about private tuition for children.
http://www.channelnewsasia.com/polls/index.php?id=843&ranid=7869 -
It’s simply great to read all your comments. Lots of factors play a part in education system…of course there are black sheep and it’s unfortunate to get that black sheep as teacher.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login2
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects