Is GEP really necessary?
-
ksi:
:? No leh, this is not what I said. I said MOST (not all) are not omni-gifted, most are skewed. But to expect everyone to be gifted in all areas is not right. I agree with the capacity to learn part, but that does not make them gifted in ALL areas. Many GEPpers are poor in sport for example, but Ben Franklin was an excellent athlete. I even gave an example of Leonardo Da Vinci as an omni-gifted person. But honestly, if the world can only see a few omni-gifted people in HISTORY, how come Singapore expects to see 550 a year?
Thanks for sharing your definition and confirming my understanding of your definition. It differs from 2ppaamm's, she says truly gifted cannot be omni-gifted.atutor2001:
I actually thought that the GEP was targeted at the HA kids and not the truly gifted as there are far too few. Sadly many selected are not even HA but are the products of hot-housing at primary level. Such kids run out of steam. HA kids don't run out of steam but will not do well if the subject is not of interest to them. The results I have shown was refering to A-level, where the kids themselves select the subject of their preference. So we are saying that they could not find 4 subjects that they truly like. I actually think so because they generally, don't like to study.
Truly gifted are all-rounder. I have met many gifted people. While others were busy copying notes, the gifted only sat there, having already understood and stored the information in their own harddisk (brain).
Basic traits of a truly gifted :
a) Speed reading
b) Great ability in understanding and analysis at high speed.
c) Elephant memory with unlimited storage capacity for all subjects
d) Ability to see links and patterns that others don't
Can a truly gifted, who is endowed with such natural talents not do well in exam because they are skewed? Their elephant memory will pull them through easily even if they don't like it.
HA kids usually have (a) and (b) and some also have (d). However, they don't have (c). It is \"elephant memory\" that allows the gifted to process new issues with cross reference to a much bigger data base at high speed and coming up with a solution. A HA kid needs to wake up and start storing all the info to do well. Those that failed to wake up will be lost in the crowd.
Hot-housed kids has only (a). At young age, their (b) appears good as they went through accelerated learning. As years go by, without the other factors, their results will suffer.
So, most are generalists lah, the skewed, highly gifted ones are left out. If we can't even agree that giftedness is often skewed, then errr.... :torchme:
BTW, being gifted is not like you are a god or something... hahaha... I know from observing children who are tested (by real psychologists) who are profoundly gifted. And they are just normal children and you can't really tell what's inside them at all.
-
did you not say they wanted them to be administrators…so generalist fit better, ya?
-
Nebbermind:
did you not say they wanted them to be administrators...so generalist fit better, ya?
Ya lor... so gifted or not does not matter ma... guai guai can already... generalist better mah... No gripe about it, just fed up I wasn't told earlier... and had to find out through much pain and research, and with their own admission. -
:goodpost:
atutor2001:
:goodpost:
I don't believe in statistical bluff. We can reduce the percentage of HIV by killing them. We can reduce the % of empty flats by demolishing them. But the official reasons given would be that there is an improvement to the health situation or that the take up rate of empty flats has increased. (just example - no truth at all)ksi:
Where do you get this statistics?
Personal knowledge is best. All my kids when to Sec and JC with GEPers in the school and I have been kaypohing on who and who are the top students. Besides the few top GEPers in each cohort, most fade away.
Yes, many will jump in and claim that GEPers does not equate to good exam results. I always wonder - exam which is relatively easier than GEPers curriculum. How can one be a GEPer and not do well in A level (no T-score to distort the result and they get to select the subject of their choice). Then others will say \"oh, GEPers were not interested in exam that is why they don't do well\". This makes me even more puzzled because I always remember gifted people are good in nearly everything they do though they are better in those things they like. Ordinary people are no match to them even for things they dislike. Leonardo da Vinci, Michelangelo... are not only good in painting. They are scientist, mathematician, poet.... Ya, another group will claim \"we can't expect our gifted kid to be of that level like these greats.\" Ya definitely not such level, but at least should be able to do well in a simple A level exam.
Lastly, what is better then getting feedback from the students themselves. I have 3 kids and many friends. I may not be a tutor but I know many students. -
Nebbermind:
In every cohort, we will find very nerdy GEPers working very hard 24/7 but produce only average results at A level. These are the ones that I am refering to.
If you know of someone in particular, please name and shame them. Pls donch group everyone else and kept insisting them been hot-housed.
It is not their fault lah. Some are simply born with super kiasu attitude, must do well type of mindset. Some have parents with that mindset and force it upon their kids. It is not a shameful thing. They are doing so because they thought it is good for their kids - though can be harmful.
Just sharing here, hoping that the selection process can be refined so that these groups can be blocked and will not be subjected to unnecessary pressure and suffering under the programme. -
ksi:
Aiyo...how come suddenly I feel so \"naked\"? :oops:
Yes, Yes, Dr ksi.. We know your ''TOP-less'' talent.. And we LOVE it...firefly38:
[quote=\"ksi\"]
This is what people cannot understand and it has been explained... it seems that people are so caught up in being top that everything is only measured by TOP. If TOP-less, then no GEP calibre.
btw, congrats osim, 90%+ is great all-rounder for GEP, even for mainstream is great.
:salute:
[/quote] :rotflmao: :rotflmao: :rotflmao:
-
atutor2001:
I actually thought that the GEP was targeted at the HA kids and not the truly gifted as there are far too few. Sadly many selected are not even HA but are the products of hot-housing at primary level. Such kids run out of steam. HA kids don't run out of steam but will not do well if the subject is not of interest to them. The results I have shown was refering to A-level, where the kids themselves select the subject of their preference. So we are saying that they could not find 4 subjects that they truly like. I actually think so because they generally, don't like to study.
Maybe you should consult 2ppaamm, to her, they are not gifted only HA...so maybe HA run out of steam? or maybe they are gifted children as they are skewed in some subjects, so maybe this results show that they are in fact gifted but skewed? Your expectation is gifted and all rounders, hers is gifted and skewed. So now we understand how the labeling of GEP is made complicated by adults.
......
Truly gifted are all-rounder. I have met many gifted people. While others were busy copying notes, the gifted only sat there, having already understood and stored the information in their own harddisk (brain).
Basic traits of a truly gifted :
a) Speed reading
b) Great ability in understanding and analysis at high speed.
c) Elephant memory with unlimited storage capacity for all subjects
d) Ability to see links and patterns that others don't
Can a truly gifted, who is endowed with such natural talents not do well in exam because they are skewed? Their elephant memory will pull them through easily even if they don't like it.
HA kids usually have (a) and (b) and some also have (d). However, they don't have (c). It is \"elephant memory\" that allows the gifted to process new issues with cross reference to a much bigger data base at high speed and coming up with a solution. A HA kid needs to wake up and start storing all the info to do well. Those that failed to wake up will be lost in the crowd.
Hot-housed kids has only (a). At young age, their (b) appears good as they went through accelerated learning. As years go by, without the other factors, their results will suffer.[/quote]
That shows the selection proceed somehow is not right. It doesn't pick up the real gifted ones. -
ruohoo97:
That shows the selection proceed somehow is not right. It doesn't pick up the real gifted ones.
Obviously u have not attained Enlightenment!
-
2ppaamm:
But that explanation is not correct leh...
I see vlim has offered another approach to explain this, (n+1)th time. Check it out.ksi:
[quote=\"Melodies\"]Hi, tks for your patience to reiterate again, not that I didn't read that, I read that but no want can explain exactly why need to do this type of re-iteration to nth degree by having a standardized program for every GEPper. I'm saying of having a few drafts but I'm saying why there is a standardized program with everything are the same. Are they trying to make every GEPper to be Leonardo da Vinci by using the precision way? :yikes:

A child in my extended family (b. 1989) was chosen for Math alone and the parents were told specifically that he was chosen for Math.
My friend's daughter (b. 1988) was chosen for English alone, for she was an avid reader from 4 years old.
My student1 (b. 1986) was chosen for English and he told me he suffered because it is Math heavy, and classmate to our PM's son.
My student2 (b. 1989) was chosen for Math and he enjoyed the system.
My friend, who was the RGS Math HOD, told me it was impossible to teach those GEPpers who went through in English. These children pulled their class average down, and his KPI down. This current system makes sense, because it makes teaching much easier for teachers. I asked him how about those left out. He said, bo bian lor... teachers' interest must also be taken into consideration...
Not say, say only. Got proof one.
So the current selection DOES leave out all these children, so yes, I have to repeat myself again... hahaha. That the GEP does LEAVE OUT MANY, MANY gifted, and therefore, many, many HIGH ABILITY get in instead. NOTHING WRONG. Just different, MOE has chosen to nurture the High Ability and not the gifted. So be it.
Too bad for the country.[/quote]Hi, my DS's friend got in too because was prepared before hand. So I do somewhat agreed on the above in blue. I don't want to say so much cause his mum might be reading this.
:siam: -
ruohoo97:
Wah...what a BIG conclusion to draw just be reading this.....
That shows the selection proceed somehow is not right. It doesn't pick up the real gifted ones.atutor2001:
I actually thought that the GEP was targeted at the HA kids and not the truly gifted as there are far too few. Sadly many selected are not even HA but are the products of hot-housing at primary level. Such kids run out of steam. HA kids don't run out of steam but will not do well if the subject is not of interest to them. The results I have shown was refering to A-level, where the kids themselves select the subject of their preference. So we are saying that they could not find 4 subjects that they truly like. I actually think so because they generally, don't like to study.
Truly gifted are all-rounder. I have met many gifted people. While others were busy copying notes, the gifted only sat there, having already understood and stored the information in their own harddisk (brain).
Basic traits of a truly gifted :
a) Speed reading
b) Great ability in understanding and analysis at high speed.
c) Elephant memory with unlimited storage capacity for all subjects
d) Ability to see links and patterns that others don't
Can a truly gifted, who is endowed with such natural talents not do well in exam because they are skewed? Their elephant memory will pull them through easily even if they don't like it.
HA kids usually have (a) and (b) and some also have (d). However, they don't have (c). It is \"elephant memory\" that allows the gifted to process new issues with cross reference to a much bigger data base at high speed and coming up with a solution. A HA kid needs to wake up and start storing all the info to do well. Those that failed to wake up will be lost in the crowd.
Hot-housed kids has only (a). At young age, their (b) appears good as they went through accelerated learning. As years go by, without the other factors, their results will suffer.
I sure hope you have read all the other posts.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login5
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects