Why screen kids in P1?
-
ksi:
I didn't speculate. I just asked a few questions and raised concerns. Parents say there is nothing to be concerned about. I say yes...Chenonceau:
I am only raising questions. There could be a perfectly good explanation for all this.
True la...then just wait for reply lor. If want to deduce, can only use logic lor...like my logical deduction for no action. Otherwise it is speculations after speculations.
To me, no news is good news.
(1) Question of research ethics and informed consent
(2) Is there intervention or not? If yes, when and what?
We don't know and that bothers me. Some have said it is LSP. I question if it is ONLY LSP since this is an IQ test, not a literacy nor numeracy test. Others say it is developmental test and used to help those slow in development. It can EQUALLY be used to accelerate the high IQ. Whatever excuses we make for MOE, we don't know do we?
The questions remain. They are important questions that deserve answers. The forum writer was not making a big fuss. These are important questions. -
Chenonceau:
If there is nothing to be done, do you still expect them to contact you? I won't.
I repeat. I expect nothing. I merely point out that MOE itself said it would intervene after the screening.ksi:
The above means you are expecting intervention right? If they collect the info and only after that then they know need intervention or not right? So if they find that there is no need for intervention, then no action lor... logical? :scratchhead: -
ksi:
If there is nothing to be done, do you still expect them to contact you? I won't.[/quote]Ummm... yes I do. If they take my son's IQ, I not only expect them to ask my permission first... I expect them to give me the results of the IQ test. Again, this is stipulated in research ethics legislation in many countries. In UNSW tests, we get results back. In school tests, we get results back. In PE tests, we get results back. PSLE gives us results back. Why not this?
I repeat. I expect nothing. I merely point out that MOE itself said it would intervene after the screening.Chenonceau:
[quote=\"ksi\"]
The above means you are expecting intervention right? If they collect the info and only after that then they know need intervention or not right? So if they find that there is no need for intervention, then no action lor... logical? :scratchhead:
But whether I expect or not doesn't matter. The fact is this... MOE said that it intended to intervene. So in some cases, it would intervene (unless it is lying which I think not). Even if in YOUR case, there is no intervention.
I think we misunderstand each other. You reason that since the MOE said it would intervene then I expect them to contact YOU. Not at all. I quite understand YOUR child may not need intervention. I am saying that even if YOUR child requires no intervention, other children will. My questions are...
- What is the data used for?
- What are the interventions, if any are required? -
alng:
That I can't dispute. She even complained that it wasn't fair that some of her classmates started working on the paper when they weren't supposed to, who finished early etc... :rotflmao:chamonix:
Sigh, she even drew a simplified version of the answer sheet to explain to me. Top - to fill in name, school, date. Rest of the paper taken up by sections A - D on the same page while Section E is at the back. Most questions have 6 circles, and few have 8 circles. I was :scared: But she was nonchalant about it and said she 'checked' the answers...
Your dd is so much more detailed than my ds.
But hor, she insisted they were given 40-45 minutes, not 30 minutes... -
chamonix:
That I can't dispute. She even complained that it wasn't fair that some of her classmates started working on the paper when they weren't supposed to, who finished early etc... :rotflmao:alng:
[quote=\"chamonix\"]Sigh, she even drew a simplified version of the answer sheet to explain to me. Top - to fill in name, school, date. Rest of the paper taken up by sections A - D on the same page while Section E is at the back. Most questions have 6 circles, and few have 8 circles. I was :scared: But she was nonchalant about it and said she 'checked' the answers...
Your dd is so much more detailed than my ds.
But hor, she insisted they were given 40-45 minutes, not 30 minutes...[/quote]Timing wise, I cannot verify with dd1, she's rather iffy with time
-
Chenonceau:
Ummm... yes I do. If they take my son's IQ, I not only expect them to ask my permission first... I expect them to give me the results of the IQ test. Again, this is stipulated in research ethics legislation in many countries. In UNSW tests, we get results back. In school tests, we get results back. In PE tests, we get results back. PSLE gives us results back. Why not this?
If there is nothing to be done, do you still expect them to contact you? I won't.ksi:
[quote=\"Chenonceau\"]
I repeat. I expect nothing. I merely point out that MOE itself said it would intervene after the screening.
But whether I expect or not doesn't matter. The fact is this... MOE said that it intended to intervene. So in some cases, it would intervene (unless it is lying which I think not). Even if in YOUR case, there is no intervention.
I think we misunderstand each other. You reason that since the MOE said it would intervene then I expect them to contact YOU. Not at all. I quite understand YOUR child may not need intervention. I am saying that even if YOUR child requires no intervention, other children will. My questions are...
- What is the data used for?
- What are the interventions, if any are required?[/quote]Assuming it is intervention for discussion sake. So aren't intervention supposed to be confidential? Why is there a need to share with parents who do not matter assuming my child has nothing to do with this? :? not that I am not concerned... I am more concerned about other stuff in our environment.
To me the most worrying signs in our education today is behaviour. I am still quite appalled though no longer surprised that people can mistaken \"L\" for losers class.... Food for thought. -
ksi:
Why would you assume there is intervention for discussion's sake? Didn't MOE already say it will intervene? Do you suspect MOE is lying then?
Assuming it is intervention for discussion sake. So aren't intervention supposed to be confidential? Why is there a need to share with parents who do not matter assuming my child has nothing to do with this? :? not that I am not concerned... I am more concerned about other stuff in our environment.Chenonceau:
Ummm... yes I do. If they take my son's IQ, I not only expect them to ask my permission first... I expect them to give me the results of the IQ test. Again, this is stipulated in research ethics legislation in many countries. In UNSW tests, we get results back. In school tests, we get results back. In PE tests, we get results back. PSLE gives us results back. Why not this?
But whether I expect or not doesn't matter. The fact is this... MOE said that it intended to intervene. So in some cases, it would intervene (unless it is lying which I think not). Even if in YOUR case, there is no intervention.
I think we misunderstand each other. You reason that since the MOE said it would intervene then I expect them to contact YOU. Not at all. I quite understand YOUR child may not need intervention. I am saying that even if YOUR child requires no intervention, other children will. My questions are...
- What is the data used for?
- What are the interventions, if any are required?
To me the most worrying signs in our education today is behaviour. I am still quite appalled though no longer surprised that people can mistaken \"L\" for losers class.... Food for thought.
I never said that MOE should share other people's interventions with parents just to satisfy some nosey parkers... BUT if they took data from my kid, they need to tell me what potential intervention my kid COULD be subjected to... and seek my agreement before taking that data.
AFTER taking the data, they need to follow up by telling my me MY kid's results. Of course it is confidential... but my kid and I should know results pertinent to ourselves.
If ADULTS respected the privacy and confidentiality of our children to keep their hands off our children's IQ data... AND refrain from putting them into high ability and low ability classes in P1, the Losers issue wouldn't surface at all.
The adults at MOE don't behave... we expect the children to?
I better stop this now. I am starting to repeat myself. Apologies if I have offended. Your goodwill is important to me. -
I read you Chen :hugs:
Very very loud and super duper whooper clear
My kiddo is not in Pri sch yet, but I would feel quite uncomfortable if he was subjected to a test like this and I was unaware about it.
A letter from the school, or a verbal announcement would suffice. If they need the data, so be it, go ahead and administer the test. But, I SHOULD be informed that my child is being used as a GUINEA PIG for for any streaming purposes, research or academic programme in the pipe line if that is the intention behind the test.
That's only common courtesy.
And I was under the impression that schools were into fostering a relationship with parents through partnership?
My 2 cents. Very naively perceived perhaps
PS: the multiple edits are due to my kiddos interrupting my flow of thoughts :love: -
I am not sure what happens in the other schools. In my DS school, the children were not streamed into their \"ability\" classes. They remained in the same class throughout. The so-called \"identified\" ones were \"monitored\". A small percentage were selected for extra help from the LSP co-ordinators, with their parents' consent. Some \"identified\" ones were later \"dropped\" as they were able to cope and move along with the rest of the class.
Perhaps I am seen as naive here, but I see it as it is in my DS school. Maybe there was more to it, like a conspiracy theory. But I have seen how some of the children have benefited from this exercise. The children themselves are not affected until adults start declaring its evil intent. Most of us do not see the \"intervention\" aspect of it purely because we have played our part in ensuring our children are developmentally ready for school, and our children do not have learning difficulties that would require \"intervention\".
Just to share my thoughts here.
-
Is the test administered randomly in selected schools or across the board? :?
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better š
Register Login6
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects