Why screen kids in P1?
-
Mychildren:
Dunno leh... could you read back this thread? I think someone did say...
Chen,Chenonceau:
If there is intent to help weaker kids, there is no need to test everyone. There is already a screening test at the start of the year - a literacy test to assess if the children are familiar with alphabet etc ... These are already put to LSP. At mid-year of P1, which is when they administered this IQ test, teachers should already know whom the weaker ones are... they can pull only these weaker ones out for IQ test. The fact that they TEST every body suggests that they are not just looking for weak students.
Ravens is an IQ test. It can be used to finalise a diagnosis but should not be used as first step to diagnosis.
May I know when was it started the Ravens, in which year? Till now, I don't even know whether my kids have taken these. :? -
So this year then started.
Don't tell me now screening for gifted from p1??? :?
OMG! I have nothing to say now, maybe later when I think about it. :scratchhead: -
Mychildren:
Yah loh... if they continue to test everyone... GEP prep will start with sperm.So this year then started.
Don't tell me now screening for gifted from p1??? :?
OMG! I have nothing to say now, maybe later when I think about it. :scratchhead: -
Mychildren:
Yah loh... if they continue to test everyone... GEP prep will start with sperm.So this year then started.
Don't tell me now screening for gifted from p1??? :?
OMG! I have nothing to say now, maybe later when I think about it. :scratchhead: -
Chenonceau:
I believe the 1st screening is done possibly to identify those who may not have any pre-school ed and really lacking in these areas. So when formal school begin, the school will have a better idea whether it's coz they did not have any foundation or they r just slow.If there is intent to help weaker kids, there is no need to test everyone. There is already a screening test at the start of the year - a literacy test to assess if the children are familiar with alphabet etc ... These are already put to LSP. At mid-year of P1, which is when they administered this IQ test, teachers should already know whom the weaker ones are... they can pull only these weaker ones out for IQ test. The fact that they TEST every body suggests that they are not just looking for weak students.
Ravens is an IQ test. It can be used to finalise a diagnosis but should not be used as first step to diagnosis. Good tests cost money. Free tests are not accurate. To test everyone just to look for weak ones does not make sense. Teachers pull out those they observe to be bottom. Then confirm with IQ test. Makes more sense.
This gives kids who are sick on the day of the test and score badly the benefit of the doubt. If not, teacher look at your score... think you dumb... treat you like dumb. So you really become dumb. Self-fulfilling prophecy mah...
But if Teacher dunno your score but notice you are bottom of class and test you to confirm, then the diagnosis is more accurate because got teacher opinion AND test score. Same like breast cancer test. You notice a lump. Then you test it. If doctor diagnosis matches test diagnosis then you cut the breast. If you test everyone's breasts, you waste money... and if test result is wrong then bye bye boobies.
This iq done in July following ca1 and sa1 probably just to back up the evaluation based on ca and sa, perhaps trying to reduce the chances of the non-performance being coz by lousy teaching. Agree, it looks like some half baked scientific method.
And administering this test on everyone is perhaps their way of masquerading it so it will not hurt the self esteem of the kids ( or parents). The bitchiness can be quite intense in some branded school. -
Nebbermind:
Good IQ test are expensive. I don't think a system that slots people into Normal and Express and Gifted really cares enough to masquerade. A lot of money is required to test everyone. I'm not sure our MOE is the sort to throw money at matters of self-esteem.
I believe the 1st screening is done possibly to identify those who may not have any pre-school ed and really lacking in these areas. So when formal school begin, the school will have a better idea whether it's coz they did not have any foundation or they r just slow.Chenonceau:
If there is intent to help weaker kids, there is no need to test everyone. There is already a screening test at the start of the year - a literacy test to assess if the children are familiar with alphabet etc ... These are already put to LSP. At mid-year of P1, which is when they administered this IQ test, teachers should already know whom the weaker ones are... they can pull only these weaker ones out for IQ test. The fact that they TEST every body suggests that they are not just looking for weak students.
Ravens is an IQ test. It can be used to finalise a diagnosis but should not be used as first step to diagnosis. Good tests cost money. Free tests are not accurate. To test everyone just to look for weak ones does not make sense. Teachers pull out those they observe to be bottom. Then confirm with IQ test. Makes more sense.
This gives kids who are sick on the day of the test and score badly the benefit of the doubt. If not, teacher look at your score... think you dumb... treat you like dumb. So you really become dumb. Self-fulfilling prophecy mah...
But if Teacher dunno your score but notice you are bottom of class and test you to confirm, them the diagnosis is more accurate because got teacher opinion AND test score. Same like breast cancer test. You notice a lump. Then you test it. If doctor diagnosis matches test diagnosis then you cut the breast. If you test everyone's breasts, you waste money... and if test result is wrong then bye bye boobies.
This iq done in July following ca1 and sa1 probably just to back up the evaluation based on ca and sa, perhaps trying to reduce the chances of the non-performance being coz by lousy teaching. Agree, it looks like some half baked scientific method.
And administering this test on everyone is perhaps their way of masquerading it so it will not hurt the self esteem of the kids ( or parents). The bitchiness can be quite intense in some branded school.
If it is a free test, then it is of EVEN greater concern. Funny that you wanna make such positive speculation for the system at every turn. ... I really doubt the school system cares about student bitchiness to waste resources by testing everyone. Gee... it is sometimes hard to get schools to intervene in the case of bullying.
Besides, if you dun test everyone, you can afford to alert parents... explain... and be very discreet so other kids dunno. I do confidential tests and interviews on staff. I am not allowed to tell... HR holds it confidential... There are ways to keep tests secret from people who have NO BUSINESS knowing. Therefore, the test is itself not the bitching issue. Bitching ALREADY starts when others know you are in LSP. There is no way to hide one's LSP, Normal stream, Express stream and Gifted stream status from other kids.
There is a whole lotta bitching going on in our schools anyway. I spoke to an overseas scholar some years ago... I mentioned the word GEP and saw his eyes glaze over. He was a bright kid (now a man) from RI. Played rugby... perfect score at A levels. But he unmistakably disliked GEPpers. In a sense, I sympathize with the GEP. The burden of social prejudice must be hard to bear. For the parents, the pride and the good teaching in GEP may make things quite pleasant... but gifted children carry the burden through life. Some are afraid to tell others they're gifted.
In all, my view is that your speculation does not seem plausible. If they test all, they are not just looking for weak. -
ksi:
Maybe I am not a sophisticated parent. I was more concerned when she told me she had to poo in the middle of the surprised test. So I asked if she poo-ed or continued. When she said poo, I was so relieved and end of story, never spoken about the tests with her again.
Funny right but that was all I cared! Hahaha
Ksi, you are hilarious! :rotflmao: :rotflmao: :rotflmao: -
Chenonceau:
Yah loh... if they continue to test everyone... GEP prep will start with sperm.Mychildren:
So this year then started.
Don't tell me now screening for gifted from p1??? :?
OMG! I have nothing to say now, maybe later when I think about it. :scratchhead:
Good idea then there won't be so many complaints, right??
:siam: -
GLORYmum:
Why would hothousing sperm lead to fewer complaints? :scratchhead:Chenonceau:
Yah loh... if they continue to test everyone... GEP prep will start with sperm.
Good idea then there won't be so many complaints, right??
:siam: -
Chenonceau:
Why would hothousing sperm lead to fewer complaints? :scratchhead:[/quote]There'll be more complains then. With sperms going for GEP prep course.GLORYmum:
[quote=\"Chenonceau\"]
Yah loh... if they continue to test everyone... GEP prep will start with sperm.
Good idea then there won't be so many complaints, right??
:siam:
:rotflmao:
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better š
Register Login4
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects