MOE to stop publishing names of top students?
-
CayennePepper:
You need more than geniuses. The team will need to include a hypnotist. :rotflmao:
I congratulate, in advance, the group of geniuses who comes up with something that pleases EVERYone. *holds breath!*SAHM_TAN:
:offtopic: different pple, different sense of humour.
The fengshui is right for MOE to achieve something significant. I wait with bated breath to find out what it will be.
I will be very suspicious leh if can pls everyone. :evil:
For me, if they can achieve to the extent that even pple who don't like but deep in heart know it's the correct thing to do, that would be the best liao -
sinoboy:
Just guarantee university places for everyone who wants to go, that should shut many mouths up. And after that guarantee jobs. Must be good jobs.
Maybe scrap DSA, IP program, GEP perhaps then everyone can be on level playing field. :skeptical:SAHM_TAN:
:offtopic: different pple, different sense of humour.
The fengshui is right for MOE to achieve something significant. I wait with bated breath to find out what it will be.
At the end of the day, what are all the complaints about? Isn't the chatter about how many are deprived (!!!) of good results to enter good IP schs, which of cos should then lead to university degrees, good jobs, and so we can all live happily ever after. :rahrah: -
sinoboy:
Is the above really sufficient to level the playing field?
Maybe scrap DSA, IP program, GEP perhaps then everyone can be on level playing field. :skeptical:SAHM_TAN:
:offtopic: different pple, different sense of humour.
The fengshui is right for MOE to achieve something significant. I wait with bated breath to find out what it will be.
After the above are accomplished, no other requests?
Are we over-sheltering & cushioning our kids from the real world? :skeptical:
What I have been reading scares me. :scared: -
BeContented:
Is the above really sufficient to level the playing field?
Maybe scrap DSA, IP program, GEP perhaps then everyone can be on level playing field. :skeptical:sinoboy:
[quote=\"SAHM_TAN\"]:offtopic: different pple, different sense of humour.
The fengshui is right for MOE to achieve something significant. I wait with bated breath to find out what it will be.
After the above are accomplished, no other requests?
Are we over-sheltering & cushioning our kids from the real world? :skeptical:
What I have been reading scares me. :scared:[/quote]I'm trying very hard to understand why is it that when the majority (I assume, based on numbers) can't get into IP/GEP/through DSA, then the playing field is deemed not level and NOT FAIR.
It's a little like the priority phases in P1 registration -- not fair cos you can get in and I can't! -
It’s this whole mindset of envy. If my kid can’t get into GEP/IP/DSA/university, no other kid should be allowed to do so. There will never be a solution to satisfy this kind of mindset.
-
The last 2-3 pages of comments confirms the fact that parents are taking such exams as a competition which I find is the need for change. I feel like I am re-watching the 2012 Olympic Games - so and so broke the record - cannot be- she must be doping... :slapshead: Although it isn't about cheating here, but it is like saying there is non-level playing ground and unfairness, which is what education should not be in the first place - it should not be viewed as a competition in the first place. All these talks about who is top and if not you are mediocre is driving everyone madly in a competition of academic competition - at the expense of real learning and real education.
The key issue is that many people have a very narrow definition of success. And such narrow definition of success being ingrained in children at this very early stage is uncalled for, is dangerous, and detrimental to future success of our country. We have been carrying this narrow definition for the past decade. To continue to prosper and propel ourselves, we need to take on a broader view and celebrate success in various fields. Although I would personally prefer that things be more transparent, instead of censoring this and that, there comes a time when things tend to take on extreme and side-effects, and calls for some form of administering.
I do not believe that those who are already working hard would stop doing so because top students are not being glorified, unless the ultimate aim of the student / parent is to be in that limelight. To go on to say why not stop disclosing this achiever and that achiever is carrying this too far and is not being rational in thinking.
On the contrary, I see goodness and nobility in shining the lime light on those who have all odds against them to succeed, yet they did it, although they may not be the best of the best in results. It gives hope. At least for now. -
concern2:
:goodpost:The last 2-3 pages of comments confirms the fact that parents are taking such exams as a competition which I find is the need for change. I feel like I am re-watching the 2012 Olympic Games - so and so broke the record - cannot be- she must be doping... :slapshead: Although it isn't about cheating here, but it is like saying there is non-level playing ground and unfairness, which is what education should not be in the first place - it should not be viewed as a competition in the first place. All these talks about who is top and if not you are mediocre is driving everyone madly in a competition of academic competition - at the expense of real learning and real education.
The key issue is that many people have a very narrow definition of success. And such narrow definition of success being ingrained in children at this very early stage is uncalled for, is dangerous, and detrimental to future success of our country. We have been carrying this narrow definition for the past decade. To continue to prosper and propel ourselves, we need to take on a broader view and celebrate success in various fields. Although I would personally prefer that things be more transparent, instead of censoring this and that, there comes a time when things tend to take on extreme and side-effects, and calls for some form of administering.
I do not believe that those who are already working hard would stop doing so because top students are not being glorified, unless the ultimate aim of the student / parent is to be in that limelight. To go on to say why not stop disclosing this achiever and that achiever is carrying this too far and is not being rational in thinking.
On the contrary, I see goodness and nobility in shining the lime light on those who have all odds against them to succeed, yet they did it, although they may not be the best of the best in results. It gives hope. At least for now. -
jtoh:
It's this whole mindset of envy. If my kid can't get into GEP/IP/DSA/university, no other kid should be allowed to do so. There will never be a solution to satisfy this kind of mindset.
:goodpost:
agree with you, so tired of all these complaining that I dont even bother reading anymore ..the other thing that I cant stand hearing is that 75% or 90% kids who do well or enter into GEP/Top sec schools have tuition ..BUT that is not true, I know many in my son's class (GEP) who do not have tuition...and many in RGS who dont have tuition too (my DD has zero tuition)....having said that, what is wrong if the smart kids genuinely need tuition in a subect that they are genuinely weak in ...
many also said that GEPers have privileges in DSA etc but there are also cases of GEPers who dont do well in PSLE and not offered DSA and they join o level sec schools (I dont see anything wrong with that tho)....My point is at the end of the day...hard work at any level or any school is essential for good results.... -
I believe the comments in the previous pages are said tongue-in-cheek. In any case, there will always be criticism about any system. Those already in GEP will feel they are being unfairly criticised. Those not in GEP will feel Geppers are being given unfair advantage. Concerns about fairness should not be directed at each other, but should rather be fed back to MOE whose policies on GEP/DSA have created this divide.
-
jtoh:
It's this whole mindset of envy. If my kid can't get into GEP/IP/DSA/university, no other kid should be allowed to do so. There will never be a solution to satisfy this kind of mindset.
:goodpost:
I hope the MOE will understand this and not have knee-jerk reactions.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login6
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects