How far is too far?
-
10km from home to school… too much?
Any parents have children who have to travel 10km from home to school? How they are coping?
We are staying in Seng Kang, but school will be in Bishan. I’m very worried if the distance will be too much for my girl to cope? -
Wow it is no joke to let a kid travel 10Km away to a school. Suggest you target to try school near your house.
-
titank:
Wow it is no joke to let a kid travel 10Km away to a school. Suggest you target to try school near your house.
Even if the school is Ai Tong and I'm an ex-school girl so chances very very high in Phase 2A2? -
I have a friend who used to stay in an offshore island. Everyday he had to take the 5am ferry to Singapore followed by the school bus. He graduated as a President Scholar, and is one of the most down to earth and friendly people I know.
If we see it in that perspective, maybe distance from school isn’t such a major factor in a child’s education compared to other things. -
Personally, I think Bishan isn't really that far from Seng Kang (the traffic from Seng Kang to Bishan could be a killer though :P) If I was in your position, I would go ahead to apply for Ai Tong especially since your child is guaranteed a place in the school. The fact that it is a school with good credentials and much coveted by many parents is a definite plus too
-
Hi simplyjo,
I all depend whether are you a stay-at-home mu or working mum. If you’re SAYM mum and you drive then I think shouldn’t be a problem to choose Ai Tong. But if you’re a working mum and the poor girl has to take a school bus then I think you better think twice. Moreover when comes to upper primary, they’ll have ECA sometime after school and the school bus don’t wait for them. Who is going to send her back? Seng Kang has some good schools. One of them is Nan Chiau Primary School which you can consider. I’m staying near geylang. I’ve a neighbour who has a grand daughter studying in Canossa Convent at Salim Road. She has to take a school bus. When she is the the pm session, she has to leave house at 11.15 am for 1 pm class and by the time she reached home is 7.30 pm. We are staying just slighty outside 2 km away from the school. Just imagine yours is 10km. No joke better think twice. Good Luck. -
register for Ai Tong at ph2A first, secure a place first. I assume you are in phase 2B or 2C if you are going for Nan chiau. monitor vacancy and if confirm can get place, then you consider if want drop AiTong and switch to Nan chiau.
-
cheonght:
register for Ai Tong at ph2A first, secure a place first. I assume you are in phase 2B or 2C if you are going for Nan chiau. monitor vacancy and if confirm can get place, then you consider if want drop AiTong and switch to Nan chiau.
hmm, good strategy... but can I do this? -
I am staying at Bukit Panjang … got my son in Phase 2B Maris Stella…
still thinking whether I should move to some where closer…
Tried driving in the morning to the school (off Bartley Rd) via PIE exit
Upper Serangoon Rd … took abt 25 - 30 mins at constant speed…traffic wise quite smooth at around 6.15 am
Don’t know if there is a School Bus Service that goes from West to MS…
Anyone has some contacts please share…thanks…
I believe we have made a right choice …although we need to make some
BIG Sacrifices… -
Wow…that’s a very very BIG sacrifice, in terms of time & $$ & ZZZzzz too. With the rising petrol cost, ERP…
You may not feel it when in lower primary, as you have more remedial, supplementary, CCA…your child will be exhausted with the long journey. The time spent on the road could be better managed.
Well…new property development on sale now, you can consider Kovan Residence…haha -
Well that's what being \"Kiasu Parents\" is all about but you'll be surprise
how many of \"US\" are out there....hahaha. Thanks for the advice on
Kovan...still looking for that perfect place...:) -
Hi.
I stay in Jurong & my daughter school is in Bukit Timah. For the 1st two years, she took the school bus to and from school as traffic is horrendous in the evening. The school gives priority to the school bus & parents fetching their child can only drive in at 6.45 after school buses leave the premise. The number of cars queing for pick up, countless. My daughter leave the house at 11.15 am and will only reach home at 7.30pm. Naturally she’s tired all the time. Now that she’s in the morning session, traffic is not as bad. So I send and fetch her from school. Of course has to make way when she has extra classes or eca but the time taken to travel is only 15-20 minutes by car. -
I just transferred my dd, P3 this year, from a sch less than 5min walks to a sch 9km away. She is more happy in this current sch, so the trouble of travelling is worth it.
She was taking sch bus for the 1st 3mos and I stopped her in April as she was starting her CCA (3x a week). I’m sending her to sch and because I’m working from home, my hrs are flexible, so can pick her up from sch too. -
mumwgals:
Good to know your kid managed to make the transition. How is she coping with her new friends?I just transferred my dd, P3 this year, from a sch less than 5min walks to a sch 9km away. She is more happy in this current sch, so the trouble of travelling is worth it.
She was taking sch bus for the 1st 3mos and I stopped her in April as she was starting her CCA (3x a week). I'm sending her to sch and because I'm working from home, my hrs are flexible, so can pick her up from sch too. -
ChiefKiasu:
She is enjoying the sch with no boys, so she said. :lol:
Good to know your kid managed to make the transition. How is she coping with her new friends?
Because in her old sch, there were a few boys who like her and she found it irritating as they kept disturbing her, writting her love letters, wanting to hold her hands..... The funny thing is, her good friend in the old sch was an australian-chinese boy.... :roll:. -
mumwgals:
:shock: Wow. They sure start young these days, don't they? :roll:
She is enjoying the sch with no boys, so she said. :lol:
Because in her old sch, there were a few boys who like her and she found it irritating as they kept disturbing her, writting her love letters, wanting to hold her hands..... The funny thing is, her good friend in the old sch was an australian-chinese boy.... :roll:. -
[Moderator’s Note: Threads merged.]
Hi,
I am living in Ang Mo Kio but I am considering to register my girl to CHIJ (kellock) which is in Bukit Merah. Basically because I was an old girl from CHIJ(kellock) and I think it is easier for my girl to get into the school (save the panic feelings of balloting). I think it is more than 10km of travel. Does anyone has experience on travelling such a distance everyday to fetch your child to and from school?
Rdgs, -
Hi, We used to stay in changi area and my daughter travels to MBS at macpherson. Surprisingly, the bus comes at 11.45am and she reaches home by 7.20pm. We pay more for the school bus due to the distance and also there are lesser student in that area but the auntie is great (as she used to be the bus assistant during my era). She arranges for my girl to take another bus when coming back so that she can drop off earlier. I believe the distance in our case is more than 10km.
However, you mentioned that you are staying in AMK. Given that we just moved to upp serangoon area and heavily dependent on CTE now, I am not too sure if it will be a strain travelling from AMK to Bukit Merah every morning esp if you drive. You might want to check if school bus is an option. BTW, in our case, despite being nearer to school now, my girl hops on the bus at 11am (45 mins earlier than previously) and she reaches home around 7pm… so sometimes it just doesn’t make sense. -
I think distance is pretty important especially for a primary one student. He or she will be too tired from the travelling. So is the parent who has to do the ferrying. THe time could be spent on other more meaningful activities. Best balance is try to get into the best school within 5km of your house. Of course, there is no such thing as best, i should say the most optimal and balanced one in terms of academic performance, environment etc. Balloting may be required but you at least stand a chance. AMK to BT merah - u need to use the CTE which is the most congested part of the highway in singapore. CHIJ Toa payoh is nearer…but not counted right?
-
smallfly:
Not advisable to travel from AMK to CHIJ (Kellock). CTE would be the worst traffic in the morning & evening. Take note that ERP charges also.Hi,
I am living in Ang Mo Kio but I am considering to register my girl to CHIJ (kellock) which is in Bukit Merah. Basically because I was an old girl from CHIJ(kellock) and I think it is easier for my girl to get into the school (save the panic feelings of balloting). I think it is more than 10km of travel. Does anyone has experience on travelling such a distance everyday to fetch your child to and from school?
Rdgs,