All About Autism
-
schweppes:
Have not been following the thread for some time. Did helplessmum's son get a formal diagnosis for ASD? He sounds high functioning and normal.
Masy and Schweppes,
I asked Helplessmum the same question too (if you refer to earlier thread). From the way she describes her son, I really don't see how he is autistic. And yes, Helplessmum mentioned that he was diagnosed by KKH.
So far, what I gathered from Helplessmum's post is that her son talks alot, wants to play with his peers, can imitate, interested in peers, can read, can spell, shows affections by asking for mummy to hug him. Seriously, her son sounds more like a gifted kid rather than ASD. And mind you, Helplessmum said that her son is a year end baby, which means he may not be even 3 years old yet. But all the things that he can do now is really advance and I don't see anything autistic about it.
If he is really diagnosed to be ASD by KKH, I really doubt the diagnosis. -
Double E:
Wonder if it was a diagnosis by the pd or the psychologist... We had to go thru the psychologist and IQ test before being confirmed at kkh. If that person just did a cursory look and give diagnosis, then it's likely the PD. however, the actual diagnosis is from the psychologist and she had to fill up a form on each observation. So not so easy. There are many questions that she has to answer and parents also need to fill up the general ability form.schweppes:
Have not been following the thread for some time. Did helplessmum's son get a formal diagnosis for ASD? He sounds high functioning and normal.
Masy and Schweppes,
I asked Helplessmum the same question too (if you refer to earlier thread). From the way she describes her son, I really don't see how he is autistic. And yes, Helplessmum mentioned that he was diagnosed by KKH.
So far, what I gathered from Helplessmum's post is that her son talks alot, wants to play with his peers, can imitate, interested in peers, can read, can spell, shows affections by asking for mummy to hug him. Seriously, her son sounds more like a gifted kid rather than ASD. And mind you, Helplessmum said that her son is a year end baby, which means he may not be even 3 years old yet. But all the things that he can do now is really advance and I don't see anything autistic about it.
If he is really diagnosed to be ASD by KKH, I really doubt the diagnosis. -
And I think Helplessmum also mentioned her son felt sad when other kids don’t want to play with him. My goodness, my boy didn’t even bother at 3 yrs old! He probably wasn’t even aware that other kids didn’t want to play with him. It’s only now at 6 yrs old, he’s starting to be more aware and wants to play with others. However he still doesn’t know how to get himself involved and will simply cry when others don’t let him play with them.
-
Kkh physcologist has diagnosed him at st Andrew hospital .
He has above average iq. That’s all.
He is still ASD. At that time according to the physcologist as long 3 out of 6 already confirm as ASD.
Today his trail school teacher say when teacher angry n firm to him he will act to be an angel by lean on her n smooth his head on her body…
Manipulating …
Double E, yr son is more advance then my son…
Yr son talk more then my son n he is able to answer yr phone call.
I also confuse . They say ASD is a wide range.
For my son talking wise he only know how to request this request that n answer simple questions n when give choices he is able to say his choice .
Instruction talking he too able to do it , 3 steps instructions
It’s the interaction that very lacking . Others normal kids can hav conversation Tru n fro smoothly but my son can’t.
He can draw alot of item from loliipop , umbrella , ice cream, potatoes, triangle , recently he draw car. He can write A , M , E
He can color within each picture w difference color on each of them.
He can feed him self even scoop soup, he can drink from cup. He can use fork.
He can pull up his pants, he can put his hands into sleeves hand by hand
He can climb NET chain, ladder , staircase up n down.
These are the basic .
Usually motor skill not really a problem to ASD child.
He will show affectionate when kids cry by go near smile at them n give them a hug.
He can walk freely at shopping mall n turn around to see if we still w him.
He he talk very loud he will peep at us see if we are looking at him .
He will come to me n play w me , squeeze my nose & etc.
He love to see himself in the mirror to do all kind of expression -
helplessmum3:
What are the 3 out of 6?Kkh physcologist has diagnosed him at st Andrew hospital .
He has above average iq. That's all.
He is still ASD. At that time according to the physcologist as long 3 out of 6 already confirm as ASD.
Today his trail school teacher say when teacher angry n firm to him he will act to be an angel by lean on her n smooth his head on her body..
Manipulating ...
Double E, yr son is more advance then my son..
Yr son talk more then my son n he is able to answer yr phone call.
I also confuse . They say ASD is a wide range.
For my son talking wise he only know how to request this request that n answer simple questions n when give choices he is able to say his choice .
Instruction talking he too able to do it , 3 steps instructions
It's the interaction that very lacking . Others normal kids can hav conversation Tru n fro smoothly but my son can't.
He can draw alot of item from loliipop , umbrella , ice cream, potatoes, triangle , recently he draw car. He can write A , M , E
He can color within each picture w difference color on each of them.
He can feed him self even scoop soup, he can drink from cup. He can use fork.
He can pull up his pants, he can put his hands into sleeves hand by hand
He can climb NET chain, ladder , staircase up n down.
These are the basic .
Usually motor skill not really a problem to ASD child.
He will show affectionate when kids cry by go near smile at them n give them a hug.
He can walk freely at shopping mall n turn around to see if we still w him.
He he talk very loud he will peep at us see if we are looking at him .
He will come to me n play w me , squeeze my nose & etc.
He love to see himself in the mirror to do all kind of expression -
ArielMermaid:
Arielmermaid, care to share your plans for your child on school placement options when he is due for primary school education? My daughter is currently 5 yo and I am looking into the school placement options.
He is currently 6 years old, in the afternoon session. There are about 6 others in his class, with 3 teachers and some volunteers.
Hrmmmm... as for his progress, when he was 3 years old, he ran around whenever he had the chance, spoke only a few words and was totally unregulated. Now, at 6+, generally he listens to instructions but knows who he can bully and \"override\", can sit down and work with me for about 2 hours at a stretch, talks alot, can read and write and do simple math. Of course, he still have his quirks and autistic and socially- inappropriate behaviour and other challenges.
I have to add that other than Rainbow, he also has a lot of classes and therapies. In fact, until recently, his mondays to saturdays were totally filled up with classes and therapies.
I find that there is still a lot of emphasis on academics at this early age of 7-8 years old, and wonder whether this is the right direction for special needs children.
TIA. -
And why was he diagnosed by kkh psychologist in st Andrew’s hospital? Don’t they diagnose cases in kkh itself?
Isn’t st Andrew for children above 7 yrs old? Wouldn’t a 3 yr old be better assessed in kkh that is meant for preschoolers? -
Helplessmum
so what 3 criteria did he meet out of the 6? And for his iq, how many points did he get? i wonder how is IQ test conducted.
ASD kids also can have motor issues like motor planning and fine motor. My boy has fine motor issues, eg. he doesn’t know how to tear paper,instead of pulling it forward, he will pull the paper side way. But it is also improving, there are many things that he can’t do previously, he is slowly catching up now.
Your boy is doing very well already. He has not reached 3 right? My son is already 3.5, he will be due for P1 in 2.5 years time.
Actually until now, I am still thinking if I should send him to a mainstream primary or Pathlight. I had actually decided on mainstream until I met my ex-colleague yesterday. Her son is in P2 at Pathlight and doing well. Apart from speech which is slower than his peers, he doesn’t seem to have any other issues. Can make friends, able to cope with studies and no behaviour or sensory issues. My colleague said Pathlight is good and provides a very good learning environment for his son.
However, I am still tempted to let my boy try out mainstream and only if he can’t take it, then transfer him to Pathlight. But Pathlight has a long wait list.
For mummies whose kids are in mainstream, have u ever thought of sending your kids to Pathlight ? what makes u decide to let your kid go to mainstream? Care to share? -
Double E:
I haven't thought of pathlight at all honestly. Ok, maybe just a fleeting moment. Like u said, I rather let him try a mainstream school and if cannot cope then transfer. I don't want to take away the chance of mingling with other NT kids because of what I thought. It's his life. I really want it to be as normal as possible. And I'm happy that he's coping well and improving all the time.Helplessmum
so what 3 criteria did he meet out of the 6? And for his iq, how many points did he get? i wonder how is IQ test conducted.
ASD kids also can have motor issues like motor planning and fine motor. My boy has fine motor issues, eg. he doesn't know how to tear paper,instead of pulling it forward, he will pull the paper side way. But it is also improving, there are many things that he can't do previously, he is slowly catching up now.
Your boy is doing very well already. He has not reached 3 right? My son is already 3.5, he will be due for P1 in 2.5 years time.
Actually until now, I am still thinking if I should send him to a mainstream primary or Pathlight. I had actually decided on mainstream until I met my ex-colleague yesterday. Her son is in P2 at Pathlight and doing well. Apart from speech which is slower than his peers, he doesn't seem to have any other issues. Can make friends, able to cope with studies and no behaviour or sensory issues. My colleague said Pathlight is good and provides a very good learning environment for his son.
However, I am still tempted to let my boy try out mainstream and only if he can't take it, then transfer him to Pathlight. But Pathlight has a long wait list.
For mummies whose kids are in mainstream, have u ever thought of sending your kids to Pathlight ? what makes u decide to let your kid go to mainstream? Care to share?
-
Helplessmum
Maybe is worthwhile for u to get a second opinion. If he is still progressing as well as you have mentioned, you can perhaps re-assess him when he is 3.5 years?
I feel that the most glaring sign that your son has that makes him very unlikely to be ASD is his interest to interact and play with his peers.
No doubt, there are ASD kids who are high-functioning and maybe with high IQ, but the common thread is that they are not interested to interact or play with their peers. That’s why we say ASD kids’ main problem is social impairment. But from what you have described, clearly, he doesn’t have this issue.
If you are to go for a second diagnosis and you tell the psychologist just like what you have told us here, there is a chance that your son’s ASD status may be revoked.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login