The first photo of the question with the school name was posted by her mother it’s in-between some of her replies to her friend. You need to click to read the "replies"


She replied to her friend that her girl is at "that school" on Tuesday 8.32am

Shortly after, she posted the photo.

Pirate ah


Please go into her FB and see for yourself. The mother posted it first followed by the friend again :slapshead:

Pirate,


Did you click on the link and read ? The worksheet with the school name is there. The picture was obtained from the mother’s FB as quoted by the newspaper.

A Few forummer already commented why is it not right to share this publicly through her FB. If you think it's ok to share nobody can stop you. Hopefully your boss do not share any of your work or email to others and ask for corrections :roll:


Ok that might not happened to you if you are already a retiree.

lee_yl:

Initially, i thought this mum was too much to complain about the matter on the internet. However, if you look through the mum's posting on her facebook, she was polite, not demeaning and just curious why her daughter's answer was not accepted.


This is the power of internet, probably she did not expect to draw a few hundred reads and multiple sharing of this post. She can share anything she likes on her facebook lah. Even without using internet, I have seen worse, for example, one mother by-passing her child's school and complained directly to MOE because she cannot accept that the form teacher graded her child's compo below her expectation.

Personally, I posted on KSP P3 Science thread before when I asked similar question why was my daughter's answer marked wrong, which I think should be acceptable too apart from teacher's model answer! And of cos, not once did I have the intention to shame the teacher here.

You may be right but I was thinking why she allowed her post to be made for public to read. That part I don't understand.

phtthp:

If Gep P3 past years screening questions are sold at Popular outlet, they will fly off the shelf fast, as though got wing

Yes Phtthp! This is precisely why I am saying that if MOE do not reveal the questions then why should parents reveal the model questions here? Just because who and who's daughter had done that before? :yikes:

GiftedGem:

Happyparent222:

I think parents should refrain from discussing any questions to be fair (especially so when round 2 is not finished yet).

No, why refrain? It is a good sharing session. If you are not kiasu, then don't come to this thread. Just like past PSLE papers, it has been released to provide students and parents with greater clarity on the overall standard.

Oh so I know you are supporting the ideas of going thru preparations to get into GEP and not purely based on true abilities !

It is not up to you to ask anyone not to come to this forum too please bear that in mind.

Steadyberry:

Maybe you are right. Her friends are Harvard grad. Moe teachers are not.

Hmm I don't get what you mean ?

I was trying to say this mother purposely blow up this matter.

I read from this mother’s FB that she has No intention to shame the teacher but she is not an expert in this so need to clarify thru her FB among her friends? I find it hardto believed she is not an expert since she graduated from well known institutions and can write so well. She also have the options not to reveal the name of the school but she chose to reveal and made her post available for public to read. Isn’t her intention very obvious?

I thought most parents discourage to prepare the kids for the test but why parents still sharing the model questions here ? :?


I think parents should refrain from discussing any questions to be fair (especially so when round 2 is not finished yet).