@bbbay i see. Thanks so much for sharing! So, it is true that SAP IP schools hold their IP students to a higher bar in HCL, compared to students they admit via JAE.
I also heard that for non-SAP IP schools, students just need to obtain a pass for O level HCL and they can opt out of H1 Chinese in Yr 5/6.
You’re right that every school seems to have different requirements for this (wonder if MOE has issued any guidelines), will find out more directly from DC’s preferred sec schools! 
…appreciate if I can get some advice/clarification on HCL in IP school:
. May I know what instrument your child plays in Band?
.