Secondary School Chinese

[jtoh]

jollybea:

hie jtoh


I do not intend for my child to take HCL in his PSLE.

Thanks for your info. I'm relieved that they do not need to take HCL in order to take HCL in secondary. However u're saying it is compulsory in mostly SAP schools.

My child is aiming Dunman High or Victoria.

If he is to go in thru DSA Academics, he's strong in his other 3 subjects. Mainly As and A*. Does it means it's a 6 years IP, which requires them to do HCL, right ?

Could someone enighten me on this aspect ? Thanks.

If I'm not mistaken, HCL is compulsory in Dunman High. And their standard of Chinese is high. So think carefully if your son will be able to cope with HCL in DHS. Of course some students who didn't take HCL in primary school are doing fine in DHS. It depends on the student's ability. You should know roughly your son's standard. Victoria is not an SAP school so I don't think HCL is compulsory.

[Nebbermind]

Can consider ACSI....nobody talks about Chinese....higher or otherwise! :rotflmao:

[3kiddos]

Hi, all IP students in VS take HcL in yr 1. Ds didnt do HCL at all in primary school and he dsa through sports last year. He was also offered a place at DHS although he has no HCL at psle.


He is taking HCL now at VS. So far coping fine. As far as I know, all IP students (cedar, tjc etc) have to take HCL, at least in year 1. Not sure if there is an option to drop later on. Hope that helps.

[jtoh]

3kiddos:

Hi, all IP students in VS take HcL in yr 1. Ds didnt do HCL at all in primary school and he dsa through sports last year. He was also offered a place at DHS although he has no HCL at psle.


He is taking HCL now at VS. So far coping fine. As far as I know, all IP students (cedar, tjc etc) have to take HCL, at least in year 1. Not sure if there is an option to drop later on. Hope that helps.

Thanks for clarifying about Victoria. Not all IP schools require you to take HCL. RGS, RI, SCGS, MGS, ACSI all do not stipulate HCL as compulsory.

[3kiddos]

jtoh:

3kiddos:

Hi, all IP students in VS take HcL in yr 1. Ds didnt do HCL at all in primary school and he dsa through sports last year. He was also offered a place at DHS although he has no HCL at psle.


He is taking HCL now at VS. So far coping fine. As far as I know, all IP students (cedar, tjc etc) have to take HCL, at least in year 1. Not sure if there is an option to drop later on. Hope that helps.

Thanks for clarifying about Victoria. Not all IP schools require you to take HCL. RGS, RI, SCGS, MGS, ACSI all do not stipulate HCL as compulsory.

I think although hcl not compulsory for admission (dhs also not compulsory) but in year 1, the schools dont offer normal chi right? All need to take hcl? Are there normal chi classes in RGS and RI?

[jtoh]

3kiddos:

jtoh:

[quote=\"3kiddos\"]Hi, all IP students in VS take HcL in yr 1. Ds didnt do HCL at all in primary school and he dsa through sports last year. He was also offered a place at DHS although he has no HCL at psle.


He is taking HCL now at VS. So far coping fine. As far as I know, all IP students (cedar, tjc etc) have to take HCL, at least in year 1. Not sure if there is an option to drop later on. Hope that helps.

Thanks for clarifying about Victoria. Not all IP schools require you to take HCL. RGS, RI, SCGS, MGS, ACSI all do not stipulate HCL as compulsory.

I think although hcl not compulsory for admission (dhs also not compulsory) but in year 1, the schools dont offer normal chi right? All need to take hcl? Are there normal chi classes in RGS and RI?[/quote]All the schools I mentioned above offer normal chinese from Year 1. It's up to the students to decide if they would rather take normal chinese rather than HCL.

[3kiddos]

I see. I didnt know that. Thanks. Ds was just told that he would be taking hcl since he is in IP.

[jollybea]

ok ... so just to summarise up :


1. HCL are not needed during primary school.

2. DSA do not need students to have HCL.

3. If students take HCL in PSLE, extra points are given and
VALID only in SAPs school.

4. RGS, RI, SCGS, MGS, ACSI do not stipulate having HCL.
Could it be these schools are only referring to their 4 yrs ?

5. IP students need to take HCL ? We know this as some parents reported child has to take HCL in VS cause he's in IP of 6 yrs.


Hope more could contribute so we could have a more crystallize idea between this HCL, IP and DSA.

Tanks a lot for yr kind help, everyone. We're more relieved now.

[Augmum]

jollybea:

ok ... so just to summarise up :


1. HCL are not needed during primary school.

2. DSA do not need students to have HCL.

3. If students take HCL in PSLE, extra points are given and
VALID only in SAPs school.

4. RGS, RI, SCGS, MGS, ACSI do not stipulate having HCL.
Could it be these schools are only referring to their 4 yrs ?

5. IP students need to take HCL ? We know this as some parents reported child has to take HCL in VS cause he's in IP of 6 yrs.


Hope more could contribute so we could have a more crystallize idea between this HCL, IP and DSA.

Tanks a lot for yr kind help, everyone. We're more relieved now.

For Point 5) It depends on which schs u DSA to ....

If u are targeting at DHS which u have mentioned....
ALL pupils in DHS do HCL...unless u cannot pass yr HCL at the end of yr 2 or even yr 3...
U' ll be auto downgrade to only doing CL at O level...
And if u do not clear yr HCL at O level, u'll required to take H1 CL at JC level....
Hence, most pupils would rather put in effort to clear their HCL at O level...instead of doing another subj, ie H1 CL in JC...

But for some IP schs, a pass alone in HCL at O level is not good enough to be exempted from doing H1 CL in yr 5, so it still depends on which IP sch....

[sparks]

MT results will be released tmr from seab website. Good luck everyone!