2014 P1 Registration Exercise for 2015 In-Take
-
Let's also remember that these 4 parents who gave up their slots also benefitted 4 other parents who were vying from their withdrawals
Absolutely!!!!!!!
:udawoman:
Agreed -
ChiefKiasu:
I agree with ChiefK. Many of my friends and relatives are in that 'Top etc etc' category, and trust me, they fret a lot!
This generalisation not only puts down \"not so well educated young parents\", but also unduly accord \"top executives, top professionals, doctors\" with sage-like characteristics. Perhaps those \"very well-educated professionals\" have secured places in those super-popular schools in earlier phases, which explains the phenomenon you observed.jennylim80:
... I see a trend of not so well educated young parents who get trapped in this beliefs whuch causes such a phenomenon in Singapore. If you noticed Top executives, top professionals., Doctors etc. do not fret like the average employees about their children's primary schools.
I am worried for these generation.
It takes a parent to understand what parents go through. We should give credit to all Singaporean parents for caring so much for each and every one of their children. -
congratulations to those who have successfully registered their children.
for those who are facing balloting, I wish you all the best.
at the end of p1 registration, the education journey has just begun.
top elite executives have their fair level of stress making sure their kids perform well in school too…maybe they have more money for tutors. whether parents are highly educated or not so well educated, we all want the best for our kids.
whether it is a top school or neighbourhood school, parents cannot leave everything to the teachers. -
MOE only publishes primary schools vacancies by phases and the ministry does not give the breakdown of application by distances. It encourages parents to apply schools nearby.
With this unfortunate incident in ATS, schools would be wise not to give any details of the number of applications for each distance category. Perhaps MOE should make it strictly confidential.
This will discourage earlier phases applicants who have already secured a place to risk giving it up to try their luck for the ideal primary school they have in mind. Phase 2c applicants will want to up their chances in securing a place for their DD/DS by looking at school within 1km. After all, MOE says every school a good school.
No more last minute changes resulting in unhappiness and arguments over unfairness… -
putien:
I think schools can reveal how many applications for each distance category so that parents do not waste their choice at P2C. No point registering in a school which you do not even stand a chance to ballot.MOE only publishes primary schools vacancies by phases and the ministry does not give the breakdown of application by distances. It encourages parents to apply schools nearby.
With this unfortunate incident in ATS, schools would be wise not to give any details of the number of applications for each distance category. Perhaps MOE should make it strictly confidential.
This will discourage earlier phases applicants who have already secured a place to risk giving it up to try their luck for the ideal primary school they have in mind. Phase 2c applicants will want to up their chances in securing a place for their DD/DS by looking at school within 1km. After all, MOE says every school a good school.
No more last minute changes resulting in unhappiness and arguments over unfairness...
It's the withdrawing from earlier phases to register for a subsequent phase that should be looked into. -
MOE only publishes primary schools vacancies by phases and the ministry does not give the breakdown of application by distances. It encourages parents to apply schools nearby.
With this unfortunate incident in ATS, schools would be wise not to give any details of the number of applications for each distance category. Perhaps MOE should make it strictly confidential.
This will discourage earlier phases applicants who have already secured a place to risk giving it up to try their luck for the ideal primary school they have in mind. Phase 2c applicants will want to up their chances in securing a place for their DD/DS by looking at school within 1km. After all, MOE says every school a good school.
No more last minute changes resulting in unhappiness and arguments over unfairness…
I think schools can reveal how many applications for each distance category so that parents do not waste their choice at P2C. No point registering in a school which you do not even stand a chance to ballot.
It’s the withdrawing from earlier phases to register for a subsequent phase that should be looked into.
If SC parents apply for schools within 1km, they will definitely stand a chance to ballot if the school is oversubscribed or get a place if it is not oversubscribed. -
putien:
No, schools should provide online breakdown data by distance, by SC / PR.MOE only publishes primary schools vacancies by phases and the ministry does not give the breakdown of application by distances. It encourages parents to apply schools nearby.
With this unfortunate incident in ATS, schools would be wise not to give any details of the number of applications for each distance category. Perhaps MOE should make it strictly confidential.
This will discourage earlier phases applicants who have already secured a place to risk giving it up to try their luck for the ideal primary school they have in mind. Phase 2c applicants will want to up their chances in securing a place for their DD/DS by looking at school within 1km. After all, MOE says every school a good school.
No more last minute changes resulting in unhappiness and arguments over unfairness...
All schools should make their data transparent, to all parents.
Nan Hua primary is a very good example, that all other schools should follow.
Once parents know online live data -
- on the last day of Phase 2C -
if they know that their first choice school zero chance, because high chance of balloting, then they can focus on second choice school.
But if second choice school also need to ballot, then go straight to backup school (third choice)
It is the withdrawal process on the last day, last hour (3.30 pm to 4.30 pm) -
This seriously need re-looking into, by MOE.
If not addressed, year after year, can have other schools repeat Ai Tong unfortunate incident. -
Would it make the whole P1 reg process less stressful if there’s a rule to state that if someone reg at an earlier phase (e.g. P2B), once that phase has passed, he can’t go back to de-register to apply to a later phase when opportunity arises.
Just throwing up some suggestions. Please don’t wallop me hur (I’m not one of the four).
I think this is a suggestion worth taking note.
In my humble view,phase 2A1/2 are already in a privileged position.
"Chope-ing" a place in in 2A phase and still hoping to get a better deal at later phases will really put parents in phase 2C in a further disadvantageous situation. -
ChiefKiasu:
Well, I know more than a few \"very well-educated professionals\". Many live in the Central or Bukit Timah Area. However, I have yet to come across a single one whose first choice for his/her child is Bukit Timah or Stamford Primary School. I wonder why. :scratchhead:
This generalisation not only puts down \"not so well educated young parents\", but also unduly accord \"top executives, top professionals, doctors\" with sage-like characteristics. Perhaps those \"very well-educated professionals\" have secured places in those super-popular schools in earlier phases, which explains the phenomenon you observed.jennylim80:
... I see a trend of not so well educated young parents who get trapped in this beliefs whuch causes such a phenomenon in Singapore. If you noticed Top executives, top professionals., Doctors etc. do not fret like the average employees about their children's primary schools.
I am worried for these generation.
It takes a parent to understand what parents go through. We should give credit to all Singaporean parents for caring so much for each and every one of their children. -
Sharing some information from crunching the numbers …
Description\t Places\tRemarks
Total Available\t 42,460 \t
Taken Till P2B\t 22,140 \t
P2C Available \t 20,320 \t
P2C Applicants\t 16,161 \tEnd of Day #3
Total P2C Taken (Final) 13,927 \tAfter Balloting
Total P2C Rejected\t 2,234 \t
P2CS Available\t 6,393 \t
\t\t
Estimates\t\t
Total Till P2C\t 36,067 \t
Total P2CS \t 2,234 \t
Places Taken Till P2CS\t 38,301 \t
Total 2008 SC Babies\t 39,826 \tData from DOS (?)
\t\t
Hot Primary Schools\t# of Schools\t
Oversubscribed \t 91 \t
2X Oversubscribed\t 12 \t
3X Oversubscribed\t 2 \t
\t\t
3X Oversubscribed\t\t
Rulang Primary School\t\t
Rosyth School\t\t
\t\t
2X Oversubscribed\t\t
Red Swastika School\t\t
Temasek Primary School\t\t
Yu Neng Primary School\t\t
Radin Mas Primary School\t\t
Henry Park Primary School\t\t
Nan Hua Primary School\t\t
Rulang Primary School\t\t
Pasir Ris Primary School\t\t
Rosyth School\t\t
Mee Toh School\t\t
Nan Chiau Primary School\t
Northland Primary School
Please note that Rosyth School &\t Rulang Primary School is also reflected in the 2X oversubscribed category.
Total Primary Schools\t 186
Undersubscribed\t 95
Oversubscribed\t 91
* I made the necessary correction to reflect the correct information so that there is no confusion. Thanks for pointing out the errors.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login