[PSLE MT] PSLE less weightage in Chinese / Mother Tongue
-
http://www.channelnewsasia.com/stories/singaporelocalnews/view/1052718/1/.html
Reducing weightage of Mother Tongue in PSLE will help students: MOE
By Jessica Yeo | Posted: 26 April 2010 2228 hrs
SINGAPORE: The Education Ministry said reducing the weightage for Mother Tongue in the Primary School Leaving Examination (PSLE) can help students whose scores border between the normal and express stream.
Senior Parliamentary Secretary Masagos Zulkifli said this can help when streaming students to secondary schools.
It will allow those stronger in mother tongues, but weaker in other subjects, to go into streams that are more suitable for them.
Some primary schools recognise that building up a student's confidence and team spirit are just as important as grades, and they are organising more camps and activities in this regard.
- CNA/yb -
James Ang:
huh...so it means if the kid is only strong in mother tongue, he or she might to post to normal stream instead of express under the new weightage..and by doing so it help them to go into a stream more suitable for them(downgraded???) :faint:
Senior Parliamentary Secretary Masagos Zulkifli said this can help when streaming students to secondary schools.
It will allow those stronger in mother tongues, but weaker in other subjects, to go into streams that are more suitable for them.
- CNA/yb -
vlim:
OMG, their reasoning is getting more and more ridiculous! So a student must be penalised for being good in MT and weak in other subjects. Since his/her science and maths are weak, he must go to Normal stream, SHOULD not stay in Express.
huh...so it means if the kid is only strong in mother tongue, he or she might to post to normal stream instead of express under the new weightage..and by doing so it help them to go into a stream more suitable for them(downgraded???) :faint:James Ang:
Senior Parliamentary Secretary Masagos Zulkifli said this can help when streaming students to secondary schools.
It will allow those stronger in mother tongues, but weaker in other subjects, to go into streams that are more suitable for them.
- CNA/yb -
vlim:
i would intepret it that those who are stronger in mother tongue but weaker in other subjects to be posted to streams that do not demand them to tackle 8 other subjects which demands good English language and other subject skills (math, science) in Secondary Level; in other words, it seems to be that the general feel is that good in MT is not good enough in SG education system. cos medium of teaching is in english for english and humanities subject and maths alone already have E, A, F math, calculus and what not, but MT governs mainly MT, so if you are good in MT but not in other subjects, you are not at the same competition platform as those who are good in other subjects but pulled down by MT although both groups score the same range of PSLE score.
huh...so it means if the kid is only strong in mother tongue, he or she might to post to normal stream instead of express under the new weightage..and by doing so it help them to go into a stream more suitable for them(downgraded???) :faint:James Ang:
Senior Parliamentary Secretary Masagos Zulkifli said this can help when streaming students to secondary schools.
It will allow those stronger in mother tongues, but weaker in other subjects, to go into streams that are more suitable for them.
- CNA/yb
to me, reduction of MT weightage clearly favours the middle upper english-speaking class demographics where MT is currently pulling down their overall scores. to me, change in MT weightage will favour this group as well as the 'stronger MT, weaker other subjects' group (on a broad basis), but the group of slightly above average students who leverage on consistent all rounded scores for all subjects (ie Jack of all Trades, master of none) will be greatly disadvantaged.
IMO, when the govt has already publicly announced their hint of intention, it is not surprising that some sort of plan is already in the pipeline.
to those who feared that Chinese culture will be lost, force-feeding kids to learn Chinese is also not a solution. IMO, rewarding those who do well, must continue in the form that application for places in SAP sec schools will still take performance of MT as one of the main criteria. those who really are concerned about culture will continue to focus on MT education despite lesser weightage. to those who fear that SAP schools are obsolete, is their intention of sending their children to these schools based on inculcating strong chinese culture roots or have better PSLE advantage in the first place?
JMHO. -
In the definitiion of education, there is a need to maintain fairness. Of course it is obvious that school dun forcus on music/art or health education. But it is very rare that we see a country education choose to neglect mother tongue education and allocate it a lower status by reducing weightage or relegating students good in Mother Tongue to lower league (in this case, normal stream).
For a move like that, it would only cost regrets in parents in future. I sincerely hope parents would rethink our child learning attitude and not let the policy makers sway our children future with their unsound policy.
I strongly oppose to what MOE is proposing. Concerned parents please feedback:
http://www.moe.edu.sg/feedback -
ihavethingtosay:
to those mummies and daddies who feedbacked/emailed, did they reply? what did they say?
Basically, just that they note the merits of our arguments but that the education system should try to accomodate the different groups in our society.
The teaching and learning of MTL will always be maintained in the system and they will retain the incentives for students who can excel in HMTL.
They will take various views rec'd from members of public into considerations in the MTL review. -
The key message I caught in the argument of the response in lego’s original post is:
1. if you are confident in scoring for MT, you will still score…but these people are losing their competitive edge by being all-rounders.
2. if those who are not strong in MT, give them a chance to score and not penalise them but overnight they would make the people in point 1 lose their edge which takes years to build.
They are indeed lowering the standards of MT competency but they are not addressing, just saying that as long as they don’t take MT away totally, it is good enough.
Honestly, reading such replies, you cannot fight much. They maintain the framework, just changing dosage, so it’s a small change to them. They fail to see that most people are exam-oriented and exam-smart so it will dilute the interest of learning MT. The other assumption or claim made is smart children will learn the MT language with interest, exam or no exam.
All-rounders seem over-rated…time to think specialists. -
BlackAngel:
That's not true. People like to compare with the Japanese, French, Finnish, etc etc but they forget that in these countries, the MT IS the working language. So of course it's emphasised. Singapore is an immigrant country, our working language is English. Chinese/Malay/Tamil is not truly MT, it's a 2nd language. In fact, no other country in the world places as much importance on 2nd language exam as 1st language. If you compare with Malaysia, Indonesia, US, how many Chinese in these countries can't even speak a word of the language? It doesn't make them any less \"Chinese\".But it is very rare that we see a country education choose to neglect mother tongue education.
[quote]. if you are confident in scoring for MT, you will still score....but these people are losing their competitive edge by being all-rounders.
2. if those who are not strong in MT, give them a chance to score and not penalise them but overnight they would make the people in point 1 lose their edge which takes years to build.[/quote]For those who are strong in MT and other 3 subjects, they will STILL have higher t-score than those who are good only in the 3 and not MT. Just that with reduced weightage, the scores may be closer, not so far apart. So for the true all-rounders, they don't lose out at all, I don't understand why they must win at the cost of all others. -
rags:
Those strong in MT and other 3 subjects is never in the equation cos they are super kids; it is the group that are slightly above average in 3 other subjects (ie the average joe) but strong in MT that are losing out.
For those who are strong in MT and other 3 subjects, they will STILL have higher t-score than those who are good only in the 3 and not MT. Just that with reduced weightage, the scores may be closer, not so far apart.
Comparing those who are strong in MT and slightly above average in 3 other subjects and those who are strong in 3 other subjects (ie above-above average) but weak in MT (prevalent in english-speaking homes), the latter will have that advantage over the former cos the MOE's decision to reduce MT weightage.rags:
because of COP into entry to sec school, everyone is competiting against one another, so of course must aim to win. if COP is 238, the one who scored 238 has already 'won' (in that sense) at the cost of the one who has 237.I don't understand why they must win at the cost of all others.
-
jedamum:
But if that's the case, it's debatable whether you can consider them \"all-rounders\" since in 3 subjects, they are not as strong as the other group. The other group can claim that they are strong in everything, except Chinese. Saying that the first group deserves to get higher is equally prejudiced. JMO.
Those strong in MT and other 3 subjects is never in the equation cos they are super kids; it is the group that are slightly above average in 3 other subjects (ie the average joe) but strong in MT that are losing out.
Comparing those who are strong in MT and slightly above average in 3 other subjects and those who are strong in 3 other subjects (ie above-above average) but weak in MT (prevalent in english-speaking homes), the latter will have that advantage over the former cos the MOE's decision to reduce MT weightage.jedamum:
Of course it's a competition, that's why everybody is so kiasu. But if you want someone else to be penalized so that you can \"win more\" is very bad. It's totally against what the Chinese culture teaches. With the new system, those strong in Chinese may not get as high t-score but it doesn't penalize them. If you're good in Chinese, you will still get higher marks since only the weightage is lowered and we don't know yet how much lower. May end up only very little. But the current system penalizes those bad in Chinese.because of COP into entry to sec school, everyone is competiting against one another, so of course must aim to win. if COP is 238, the one who scored 238 has already 'won' (in that sense) at the cost of the one who has 237.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better đź’—
Register Login2
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects