DSA 2017
-
Imp75:
DSA definitely needs preparation. If a child has been consistently placed in the top 10% of a top primary school or perhaps the top few in a neighbourhood school, there is a very high chance they will do very well in the PSLE and thus qualify for all schools. DSA probably is very much unnecessary for this group of pupils.
Of course should dsa. Actually, if good school results means the more one should try dsa since there might be reasonable chance of success. No guarantee but at least can be hopeful. I posted my top takeaway on page 1 ot this thread
The primary benefit of dsa is a calmer state of mind because it is bird in the hand. With a confirmed offer, dd2 had a stress-free psle. Me too
Both kids only applied for dsa to 1 school which is their 1st choice school. If dsa not successful, the 2nd chance would be to apply using t score.
-
sleepy:
Aiyo!!! That's why now MOE is reviewing the DSA scheme........Your girl doesn't need to DSA lah seriously!!Imp75:
DSA definitely needs preparation. If a child has been consistently placed in the top 10% of a top primary school or perhaps the top few in a neighbourhood school, there is a very high chance they will do very well in the PSLE and thus qualify for all schools. DSA probably is very much unnecessary for this group of pupils.
Of course should dsa. Actually, if good school results means the more one should try dsa since there might be reasonable chance of success. No guarantee but at least can be hopeful.
The primary benefit of dsa is a calmer state of mind because it is bird in the hand. With a confirmed offer, dd2 had a stress-free psle. Me too In any case, dd2 only applied for dsa to 1 school which is her 1st choice school. If dsa not successful, the 2nd chance would be to apply using t score. Ditto with dd1. Only dsa to her 1st choice school.
Better run before gets more hammered on this topic... :siam: -
lee_yl:
Don't think music cert played a big role if applying under academic domain. A music cert at most can demonstrate that child is an all-rounder, not just studying and studying the whole time. In any case, every school's selection criteria is different. I think as long as you can show the school of your choice that your child is an all rounder, should be good enough. Not necessarily must be in music, can be CCA or even services.
If that's indeed the case, then DSA is indeed stressful and one has to plan & prepare early for it. My children have been doing violin and piano with Mandeville for years but nowhere near grade 8.
Music dsa would be much tougher. I remember attending an open house for a top school in bukit timah some time ago. One of the parents asked a question on music dsa and the principal replied 40% of their students have music background and many with grade 8 cert & above. Even though principal didn't say outright but I guess everyone in the hall would most likely infer that reply as don't bother trying to dsa by music domain if the only credential is grade 8 cert
-
jenao:
You are correct with your interpretation. Just like DSA via sports, the child must show exceptional achievements in his area of talent. It's not enough to participate in inter-school competitions. Participation at national levels would be advantageous. It would be a more guarantee to get a CO if he is one of the top 3 winners.
This requirement for one subject is fairly new, maybe just started last year, if I am not wrong? There used to be GEP domain, then it was removed maybe 2 yrs back, then General acad domain and now they are replacing it with subject domain. The last 2 years the dsa has changed quite a bit. Not very sure but that's what i gathered since I am first time PSLE mom.lee_yl:
From the RGS website, my understanding of DSA academic is to just look at one subject the student is good at right? Not overall 4 subjects, I think. :? :?
From RGS website for DSA Academic:
DSA ACADEMIC
Applicant must be able to demonstrate interest and talent beyond the abilities of students in the same age group and/or have a history of consistent high academic achievements in one of the following:
English Language
Chinese Language
Malay Language
Tamil Language
Mathematics
Science
I think for last year, a few schools like RGS moved away from general acad domain to subject domain, inline with the new direction? The way I understand it, the key words from these are \"BEYOND the abilities of students in the same age group\" which mean getting good marks are not enough! You need to be very TALENTED in that domain!!! Like if you are getting above 90s for maths is not good enough for maths domain, you need to be maths olympiad platinum! That's how I read it. Really very tough for our kids! How many are platinum or gold medal for any subjects? When I read it, my first thought was, no chance at all! Might as well just concentrate on doing well for PSLE, dont need to waste time and effort.
As for DSA via subject domain, any achievement at national level would be a BIG plus. E.g., for English, if you are in the finals of the annual National Spelling Competition, that would stand you well.
Generally, to apply for DSA via any domain, you must have relevant achievements/accolades to support your application. School academic results are only an indicative (unless MOE start imposing the requirement that the child must score a certain baseline to be admitted to certain schools via DSA).
In any case, schools will be conducting trials, auditions, entry tests, etc to assess the child in the area of talent before making a decision to offer a CO/WL.
To participate in the DSA exercise takes time and effort and can be a roller-coaster ride emotionally (for both parent and child). Do consider carefully before you embark on it. -
Yes indeed, DSA takes time and effort and most often during the prelims period where the child is consolidating her learning for PSLE.
For us, if DD is not a sports national champion with other non-acad achievements, we would not have bothered with DSA to the top schools. It was a lot of work/agony prepping for GAT, application, trials, tests, interviews and finally dreading/waiting for that outcome. I still remembered bringing her to an interview that lasted till evening right in the smack of prelims. In the end, when we looked back, perhaps her results could have brought her there anyway… -
I’m just pondering aloud
If a school prefers subject domain, then child needs to be really outstanding in one particular subject to stand a good chance.
If another school accepts generic academic domain, then a good overall result is probably more important than strong performance in one subject only?
If a child is super strong in one particular subject while overall result is not as good as another child who is reasonably good in all subjects but not particularly outstanding in any specific area.
Subject domain or generic academic domain - which is to your advantage would depend on your child’s strength and whether it aligns with your choice school’s selection criteria -
Imp75:
In the end, when we looked back, perhaps her results could have brought her there anyway....
That is with hindsight
Psle result could unexpectedly swing the other way :nailbite: 2 classmates didn't meet cut off point although the rest far exceeded cut off point. It's exactly that uncertainty that prompted so many students and parents to choose dsa route. -
Which schools dsa by subject domain?
-
what I am saying is; parents probably 心里有数 whether child has been consistently doing well and whether DSA is necessary to put hearts at rest…those that stumble during PSLE are far and few…
-
Nebbermind:
Which schools dsa by subject domain?
Thought you should know better? :evil:
https://www.kiasuparents.com/kiasu/forum/viewtopic.php?f=48&t=78374&p=1750083#p1750083
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login