2019 PSLE Discussions and Strategies (Children born in 2007)

[Dino]

chenlaoshi\" post_id=\"1928982\" time=\"1565851544\" user_id=\"162894:

dylanmummy2003\" post_id=\"1928981\" time=\"1565851252\" user_id=\"116705:

but isnt 13 questions abit too much for the kid? my gal says her classmate took the longest time among all, and has the most questions ask. maybe she was overwhelmed with the amount of questions, thus she broke down when she leave the room.

Very hard for me to comment as I'm not sure how her classmate responded to those questions and if questions like 为什么 is also counted in that 13 questions (how did she keep track of that number in the first place :p). >_<

I would guess that it's either her answers are all very short and lack depth/content or she was going out of point (maybe misunderstanding the questions)

xie xie chenlaoshi....... so normally, number of qns that the teachers will ask to be considered to have performed ok is ard how many? 4, 5, 6 or ?

[dylanmummy2003]

chenlaoshi\" post_id=\"1928982\" time=\"1565851544\" user_id=\"162894:

Very hard for me to comment as I'm not sure how her classmate responded to those questions and if questions like 为什么 is also counted in that 13 questions (how did she keep track of that number in the first place :p). >_<

I would guess that it's either her answers are all very short and lack depth/content or she was going out of point (maybe misunderstanding the questions)

thank you chenlaoshi!
hope her classmate will put it past her and concentrate on tmr's english oral.
now i worry if my gal provided her 'answer' correctly. when she was ask what other interesting method she has encountered. she say e-learning. cos sometimes in school, the teachers are too busy to attend to their questions, but via e-learning/online, the teachers do replies to their queries.
like :offtopic: liao.... she also says she like when the teachers bring them outdoor to conduct lessons, especially visiting garden, as she can learn more about different plants/flowers.

[MrsKiasu]

my dd mentioned learning from adults/their experiences, visiting old age home..no e learning mentioned I hope not entirely out..

[dylanmummy2003]

what is consider 转向题?

[Dino]

MrsKiasu\" post_id=\"1928997\" time=\"1565853008\" user_id=\"43981:

my dd mentioned learning from adults/their experiences, visiting old age home..no e learning mentioned I hope not entirely out..

sounds ok leh

[phtthp]

Dino\" post_id=\"1929000\" time=\"1565853642\" user_id=\"6726:

MrsKiasu\" post_id=\"1928997\" time=\"1565853008\" user_id=\"43981:

my dd mentioned learning from adults/their experiences, visiting old age home..no e learning mentioned I hope not entirely out..

sounds ok leh

Yes, sounds good to me, what your daughter mentioned are All relevant points, not out of point

actually the Chinese Oral not simple, in that some of the points are inter-linked

[phtthp]

-

[chenlaoshi]

FHP\" post_id=\"1928989\" time=\"1565852651\" user_id=\"27202:

Apologies for being direct but based on my personal experience, if I ask the student that number of 转向问题，chances are his answers to the initial questions weren't in depth. Thus unlikely to be 1st tier (13-15) of the grading for content.

Dino\" post_id=\"1928991\" time=\"1565852701\" user_id=\"6726:

chenlaoshi\" post_id=\"1928982\" time=\"1565851544\" user_id=\"162894:[quote=chenlaoshi post_id=1928982 time=1565851544 user_id=162894][quote=dylanmummy2003 post_id=1928981 time=1565851252 user_id=116705]but isnt 13 questions abit too much for the kid? my gal says her classmate took the longest time among all, and has the most questions ask. maybe she was overwhelmed with the amount of questions, thus she broke down when she leave the room.

Very hard for me to comment as I'm not sure how her classmate responded to those questions and if questions like 为什么 is also counted in that 13 questions (how did she keep track of that number in the first place :p). >_<

I would guess that it's either her answers are all very short and lack depth/content or she was going out of point (maybe misunderstanding the questions)

xie xie chenlaoshi....... so normally, number of qns that the teachers will ask to be considered to have performed ok is ard how many? 4, 5, 6 or ?[/quote]The list of questions provided to invigilators contain 3 main + 2 to 3 additional ones.

I wouldn't say it's dependent on the number of questions that \"had to be\" asked but more of how the students responded to the questions.

For the 15 marks related to content, to achieve 13-15, the rubrics state that the student:
•\t需要极少的引导 (i.e. don't need further prompting/questions in addition to the 3 main + 1 转向)
•\t能够做出全面的回应和充分地扩展个人看法
•\t能够参与对话和持续地交流

dylanmummy2003\" post_id=\"1928992\" time=\"1565852705\" user_id=\"116705:

chenlaoshi\" post_id=\"1928982\" time=\"1565851544\" user_id=\"162894:

Very hard for me to comment as I'm not sure how her classmate responded to those questions and if questions like 为什么 is also counted in that 13 questions (how did she keep track of that number in the first place :p). >_<

I would guess that it's either her answers are all very short and lack depth/content or she was going out of point (maybe misunderstanding the questions)

thank you chenlaoshi!
hope her classmate will put it past her and concentrate on tmr's english oral.
now i worry if my gal provided her 'answer' correctly. when she was ask what other interesting method she has encountered. she say e-learning. cos sometimes in school, the teachers are too busy to attend to their questions, but via e-learning/online, the teachers do replies to their queries.
like :offtopic: liao.... she also says she like when the teachers bring them outdoor to conduct lessons, especially visiting garden, as she can learn more about different plants/flowers.

Yes, make good use of today's experience to handle tomorrow's oral.

Yup, if you look at my earlier posts, e learning, learning journey, outdoor journey all acceptable. although how well the elaboration (logical, in depth - and in this case, covering the various advantages) goes will decide how well the students fare.

MrsKiasu\" post_id=\"1928997\" time=\"1565853008\" user_id=\"43981:

my dd mentioned learning from adults/their experiences, visiting old age home..no e learning mentioned I hope not entirely out..

Yes. Other includes going to library, going online (surfing the internet, watching videos) and doing project work

[phtthp]

so far, today both (EL + CL) Oral topic focus on ... learning. Tomorrow ?

[Dino]

xie xie again laoshi for your precious time.

Dino\" post_id=\"1928991\" time=\"1565852701\" user_id=\"6726:

chenlaoshi\" post_id=\"1928982\" time=\"1565851544\" user_id=\"162894:

Very hard for me to comment as I'm not sure how her classmate responded to those questions and if questions like 为什么 is also counted in that 13 questions (how did she keep track of that number in the first place :p). >_<

I would guess that it's either her answers are all very short and lack depth/content or she was going out of point (maybe misunderstanding the questions)

xie xie chenlaoshi....... so normally, number of qns that the teachers will ask to be considered to have performed ok is ard how many? 4, 5, 6 or ?

The list of questions provided to invigilators contain 3 main + 2 to 3 additional ones.

I wouldn't say it's dependent on the number of questions that \"had to be\" asked but more of how the students responded to the questions.

For the 15 marks related to content, to achieve 13-15, the rubrics state that the student:
•\t需要极少的引导 (i.e. don't need further prompting/questions in addition to the 3 main + 1 转向)
•\t能够做出全面的回应和充分地扩展个人看法
•\t能够参与对话和持续地交流