Q&A - P3 Math
-
OK. Maybe for lower primary and when the numbers are small, the kids should just stick to \"Guess and Check\". If the child's concept of model drawing is strong, they should be able to comprehend if I draw out the model.
http://www.postimage.org/image.php?v=Pq19WrNr
[/img] -
Just to add on a little. This kind of solution is acceptable because it is still based on the model concept.
In upper primary, the Maths paper are too long, 48 questions to be completed in 2h 15 min. And section B and C, which are the open ended 3, 4, 5 marks questions constitute 50%. So need to be fast and accurate if you want to score.
In P6, solutions based on algebra is also acceptable. But I find that when they are so used to model drawing, switching to Algebra can be quite challenging for them. -
Fantastic lizawa! Thanks for the full details!
Doing it by algebra takes only 1 min. Dunno why they have to make the kids go through the thing using these clunky methods. -
Hi lizawa
Thanks for sharing on the model solution.Its really useful.I remember last two weeks, I was still asking my p3 gal using the guess and check, so tedious, this exam. lucky never come out…
I have just pm you.
Hope to learn more about model drawing from you as m still learning how to swim with it…still struggling…thanks and good day. -
Problem Solving Heuristics – Guess and Check
Guess and check (GC) is one of the simplest strategies. Anyone can guess an answer. GC can be used for the following problems
1) Jiexi went out to her grandmother’s farm. She noticed that there were a total of 38 heads and 100 legs among them. How many chickens and how many pigs did her grandmother’s farm have?
2) Anne has five more 20 cents coins than 50 cents coins. The total amount of money she has is $4.50. How many of each coin does she have?
3) Last week, 18 people attended the Koh Family Reunion. As part of the celebration, they went to see a movie. Tickets for the children were $5.00 each. Adult’s tickets cost $7.00. Mr. Koh paid $116 for all the tickets. How many children and how many adults attended the movie?
4) There are 85 plates of fried noodle for 80 people. Each adult eats 2 plates of fried noodle and every three children share 1 plate of fried noodle. How many adults and children are there? (lizawa used Algebra to solve this problem in an earlier thread)
5) 20 boys and girls sold tickets for a funfair. Each ticket was sold at $5.Each boy sold 5 tickets and each girl sold 3 tickets. The amount collected by the boys was $20 more than the amount collected by the girls. Find a) how many girls were there in the group b) how many tickets were sold altogether? (lizawa used Ratio to solve this problem in an earlier thread)
This strategy works on many types of problems but it takes time and a lot of computation. Therefore it may not be efficient in examinations where time management is essential.
Your take, please. Is Guess and Check a waste of time? -
[quote]Your take, please. Is Guess and Check a waste of time?[/quote]
For most P3 and maybe some P4 problems. guess and check is still fine, for smaller numbers. For bigger numbers, still need to use model or some methodology to solve the problem, more efficient and accurate. The school teacher will also encourage that, instead of guess and check.
But if you know no other ways, then guess and check will at least give you some answer.
The first 3 questions posted can be solved easily by the method I once showed in another thread. -
HI
When I read this thread. I began to feel concern over my son’s Math. I am a laisserfaire parent. Since my son scores well, I take a laid-back attitude. Never bother to know what’s in the new syllabus. But when I read the questions posted by you, and I don’t even know how to solve the sums without using the algebra method.
I need to know how many methods are there to solve problem sums for Pri 3? If my son does not use any of the methods but get the answer right, would he be penalised?
Pls help. Desparate already!!! -
Green pastures:
People who have not looked at actual exam questions from Primary schools will always think that parents are just being too kiasu when they complain about how hard the questions are, or when they engage tutors or send their kids to enrichment courses designed to help them with their academic work. We are glad that parents visiting KSP.com can really take a look at some of the more challenging questions and hopefully help them understand the situation. Or at least, get renewed respect for our children who have to deal with all these stuff. And we are fortunate to have parents like lizawa and tianzhu who are sincere in helping us parents learn some of these techniques for ourselves to teach our children.HI
When I read this thread. I began to feel concern over my son's Math. I am a laisserfaire parent. Since my son scores well, I take a laid-back attitude. Never bother to know what's in the new syllabus. But when I read the questions posted by you, and I don't even know how to solve the sums without using the algebra method.
I need to know how many methods are there to solve problem sums for Pri 3? If my son does not use any of the methods but get the answer right, would he be penalised?
Pls help. Desparate already!!!
If your child is already doing well, then you don't have to worry. As long as his method is not incorrect and he is able to get the right answer, it should be ok unless the question explicitly calls for a specific method. Why not have a glance through the exam papers he brings home for you to sign and decide for yourself if your son needs additional coaching? -
[quote]I need to know how many methods are there to solve problem sums for Pri 3? If my son does not use any of the methods but get the answer right, would he be penalised? [/quote]
Don't worry if your son is doing well. Based on MOE's statement sometime back (published in the papers), a child will not be penalized no matter what method he uses for PSLE exam. The markers however, will allocate marks for working, so just make sure his steps and working is clear. If the child just gives an answer without working for problem sums, he only gets the mark for the answer and not working. -
I was already getting nervous for my gal starting P1 next year, after reading all the maths questions here, think I’m already shaking.
Something not related to this - family support. Haiz, just hope the daddy will be as committed as some of the daddies here with her school work. He always tell me not to stress the poor kid, let her enjoy her childhood. I need to drill into him times are different and most parents are doing something so your kid will not be able to catch up if you are NOT doing anything…worse, my MIL also say don’t stress. :twisted:
Sorry, just need to let go… on a Friday somemore…
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login65
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects