Are good schools really necessary for our kids?
-
Although having a good teacher is important...whether the child ends up with a good teacher in school is a matter of pure luck, beyond his or his parents' control
What's within control is parental guidance. Coach him at home. -
i agree, good teacher is very important. I have a friend’s daughter who is in one of the most desirable primary school in Singapore. During the PT meeting, the teacher told my friend to engage tuition for his daughter in order to catch up. The teacher simply "wash hand".
-
I think 'good schools' are mostly more established and through years of valuable experiences, most of them have their methods of nurturing their students but of course there will be few kids that will have attitude problems or otherwise. Nevertheless, good and kind teachers still play an important roles.... :roll:
-
I commonly hear these claims from parents whom die-die must go into a \"good\" primary school
(a) MOE sent better teachers there
(b) Papers/Exams standards are higher
I am not sure the validity of above but am using my DS as a guinea pig to assess (b)
For primary schools - I am neutral. As a parent, if have a choice, I will choose a popular school but will not shift house or make kid travel a long distance for it. Actually, depending on each kid, some may actually thrive better in a not so result-oriented or competitive environment - -gives them time to build their self-confidence which is most important to me.
& afterall, my primary school is unknown (& closed down in fact ;-<) but I did get into a \"good\" secondary school - like many other friends I know. -
I have a child who is now in P4, but is in her third primary school.
I agree that good teacher is more important than a good school - but this point does not help in choosing a school at all. Simply because we can often choose the school, but can never choose the teacher. Also, what is viewed as a good teacher to one child might not be viewed as a good teacher to another child.
IMHO, when deciding whether to switch school, we need to be clear why we are doing that. Each school has its strength and it is not how strong the school is, but how well it matches what we want for our kids after understanding their interests, strength and weakness.
But one thing is definitely more important than the school, and that is the support from us parents. -
radiantmum:
I was from an unknown pri school (also closed down) and then went on to a good sec school. It was only in that sec sch that I realise there is so much that was untaught, so much that I had to see - felt like a frog in a well. Good school I feel has its worth more in the programmes and exposure it gives to the kids.
For primary schools - I am neutral. As a parent, if have a choice, I will choose a popular school but will not shift house or make kid travel a long distance for it. Actually, depending on each kid, some may actually thrive better in a not so result-oriented or competitive environment - -gives them time to build their self-confidence which is most important to me.
& afterall, my primary school is unknown (& closed down in fact ;-<) but I did get into a \"good\" secondary school - like many other friends I know.
So from that basis, I feel it's important for my son to go to the best school within my location - mum is taking care of kids so logistics has to be considered, I'm not so good as to shift house to get closer to school. Ultimately, I have to consider the logistics for the next 8 years (DS1 & 2 mah). -
why are good schools deemed "good" by the public ?
because they produce lots of top students ?
then why are they able to do so ?
because of their experience and expertise in their program, how they run the classes [ same text as determined by MOE - and yet markedly better outcome in terms of PSLE results ] - how the teachers teach, how they manage he kids, how they know how to bring out the students’ ability - not just BLINDLY teach and throw the lessons at the students.
also, good schools usually always have many other useful enrichment programs that benefit the students, giving them a more holistic and broader education - not just academic subjects teaching / learning. the whole host of enrichment programs in some good schools are astounding and they have trusted service providers to run them and make for seamless integration with the school’s core time-table. for those students who want them, and are willing to pay for them (whole year basis is about two to three hundred $$) - they are really worth every cent of it -
Personally I feel that good secondary schools is necessary for our children.
I intentionally put my son into a neighbourhood pri school, of course, occassionally I have my doubts. But I try to remind myself of my intention and the reason why I did so.
I came from an unknown pri sch in a poor neighbourhood. I learned to get along with many different kinds of friends, poor ones, very poor ones and even had a big "brother" from VITB class (I think it was called something like that, it was the predecessor of monolingual class) taking care of me. These experiences shaped my outlook in life and how I interact with different strata of society.
I went to a very very branded secondary school. It was a good balance for my development, and at the right time. I would not have benefited that much if the sequence had been reverse. -
agentcodybank:
i agree a gd sec is more important.Personally I feel that good secondary schools is necessary for our children.
I intentionally put my son into a neighbourhood pri school, of course, occassionally I have my doubts. But I try to remind myself of my intention and the reason why I did so.
but if i have a choice, i will choose a good pri sch for my kids. i will feel more secured if my kids are with gd sch.
in addition, not all neighbourhood pri sch are that bad.
nowadays, a top tier neighbourhood pri sch still outperforms some SAP or Hueykuan sch. and a gd neighbourhood sch also provides good enrichment program for kids.
that is why some neighbourhood pri sch require PV of 60 hrs! -
good primary schools provide good foundation
good neighbourhood sec schools have some good aspects but not able to eliminate / minimise negative issues - being a government school, principals MAY at times look at their posting as temporary and some plans take years to show results
one thing for sure : more headaches with student disciplines
sure - good school also has other issues to deal with but not that kind of discipline issues that involve the police force
not every school is like that - so PLEASE DON’T GET ME WRONG
but less likely with any well known school where the culture and system is already well established, and any new principal will not be able to shift too much due to stronger PTA in such schools
i have taught in neighbourhood school, good school, children in neighbourhood school and good school and being involved in PTA to make the above comment - personal comment
good schools exist due to the above, else where got good schools ? think !!
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login4
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects