All About Home Addresses
-
nonoriri\" post_id=\"1989453\" time=\"1596614314\" user_id=\"142921:
Child doesn't need to stay at Caregiver's place. It is for the fetching and student care etc., to be cared by more conveniently. After that go back to parents' place.
Nope that doesn’t make sense. It’s already stated that the child has to stay at the caregiver’s place. So if the child is being taken care of by the caregiver, and the distance is within 1km how can it be magically changed to 1-2km.
You guys totally don’t get this don’t you. This is a lack of common sense and totally unfair.
No diff from Moe saying 1+1=3 and expecting us to accept it. -
My point is the caregivers address falls within 1km it must be treated as such. Not group them/is with the 1-2km people. This rule shows a complete lack of common sense.
Davischew\" post_id=\"1989454\" time=\"1596614488\" user_id=\"132882:
Child doesn't need to stay at Caregiver's place. It is for the fetching and student care etc., to be cared by more conveniently. After that go back to parents' place.nonoriri\" post_id=\"1989453\" time=\"1596614314\" user_id=\"142921:
Nope that doesn’t make sense. It’s already stated that the child has to stay at the caregiver’s place. So if the child is being taken care of by the caregiver, and the distance is within 1km how can it be magically changed to 1-2km.
You guys totally don’t get this don’t you. This is a lack of common sense and totally unfair.
No diff from Moe saying 1+1=3 and expecting us to accept it. -
nonoriri\" post_id=\"1989456\" time=\"1596614949\" user_id=\"142921:
[/quote]Lets agree to disagree then
Child doesn't need to stay at Caregiver's place. It is for the fetching and student care etc., to be cared by more conveniently. After that go back to parents' place.
My point is the caregivers address falls within 1km it must be treated as such. Not group them/is with the 1-2km people. This rule shows a complete lack of common sense.Davischew\" post_id=\"1989454\" time=\"1596614488\" user_id=\"132882:
[quote=nonoriri post_id=1989453 time=1596614314 user_id=142921]Nope that doesn’t make sense. It’s already stated that the child has to stay at the caregiver’s place. So if the child is being taken care of by the caregiver, and the distance is within 1km how can it be magically changed to 1-2km.
You guys totally don’t get this don’t you. This is a lack of common sense and totally unfair.
No diff from Moe saying 1+1=3 and expecting us to accept it.
because I support this policy
maybe the govt should remove the entire caregiver address concept then and insist on parents address to remove the \"confusion\" -
nonoriri\" post_id=\"1989456\" time=\"1596614949\" user_id=\"142921:
[/quote]Understand your frustration, look at it objectively. If you were the one that bought properties within 1km, and several others uses their parents/siblings address to fight the spot with you, with no intention to even really cared for often by caregiver, you would think otherwise.
Child doesn't need to stay at Caregiver's place. It is for the fetching and student care etc., to be cared by more conveniently. After that go back to parents' place.
My point is the caregivers address falls within 1km it must be treated as such. Not group them/is with the 1-2km people. This rule shows a complete lack of common sense.Davischew\" post_id=\"1989454\" time=\"1596614488\" user_id=\"132882:
[quote=nonoriri post_id=1989453 time=1596614314 user_id=142921]Nope that doesn’t make sense. It’s already stated that the child has to stay at the caregiver’s place. So if the child is being taken care of by the caregiver, and the distance is within 1km how can it be magically changed to 1-2km.
You guys totally don’t get this don’t you. This is a lack of common sense and totally unfair.
No diff from Moe saying 1+1=3 and expecting us to accept it. -
nonoriri\" post_id=\"1989453\" time=\"1596614314\" user_id=\"142921:
i don't understand your argument here because it is already stated clearly in MOE website about using caregiver's address for P1 registration. I put it here below:
Nope that doesn’t make sense. It’s already stated that the child has to stay at the caregiver’s place. So if the child is being taken care of by the caregiver, and the distance is within 1km how can it be magically changed to 1-2km.
You guys totally don’t get this don’t you. This is a lack of common sense and totally unfair.
No diff from Moe saying 1+1=3 and expecting us to accept it.
How it should be is, if it’s abused then deal out punishment. Instead of making it unfair for everyone right from the start.
Are you Suggesting to put all Nus male students in jail to prevent them from becoming sexual predators?
If the caregiver’s address is within 2km of the school, your child will be balloted together with those of the same citizenship living between 1km to 2km of the school. This is regardless of how close the caregiver’s address is to the school.
If the caregiver’s address falls outside of 2km from the school, your child will be balloted together with those of the same citizenship living outside of 2km from the school.
There isn't any category for <1KM, 1-2KM & >2KM, but they rather categorized it as within 2KM or more than 2KM, which i feel it is fair to the residents that really staying near to the school.
source: https://beta.moe.gov.sg/primary/p1-registration/home-address/ -
Davischew\" post_id=\"1989462\" time=\"1596615656\" user_id=\"132882:
Understand your frustration, look at it objectively. If you were the one that bought properties within 1km, and several others uses their parents/siblings address to fight the spot with you, with no intention to even really cared for often by caregiver, you would think otherwise.[/quote]Seconded.nonoriri\" post_id=\"1989456\" time=\"1596614949\" user_id=\"142921:
My point is the caregivers address falls within 1km it must be treated as such. Not group them/is with the 1-2km people. This rule shows a complete lack of common sense.
[quote=Davischew post_id=1989454 time=1596614488 user_id=132882]
Child doesn't need to stay at Caregiver's place. It is for the fetching and student care etc., to be cared by more conveniently. After that go back to parents' place.
This policy probably arose because of the prevalence of this type of abuse. -
Hi seniors. Need some clarification on the 30 mths rule for phase 2C. Thanks!
1) If say there was balloting conducted for SCs for 1-2km n we directly got in via SCs <1km. Does this mean that we r bounded by the 30 mth rule?
2) If there was another scenario whereby all SCs got in regardless of distance and only PRs had to ballot. Does that mean we are NOT bounded by the 30 mths ruling? Or as long as balloting is invoked (i.e demand > supply) regardless of nationality, the 30 mths rule stands?
3) what is the reprecussions of breaching the 30 mth rule? MOE withdraw ur kid n throw to some ulu sch? If we changed the original pri sch to another pri sch nearer to the new address then its all good?
4) if we got in via SC <1km route but we shifted to a new hm that is 1-2km instead. Do we breach the 30 mths rule? -
Jennia14\" post_id=\"1990082\" time=\"1596907106\" user_id=\"186027:
Once you got in with distance priority, you have to obey the 30months. If you shift, you have to shift to same distance or better. Else MOE reserves the right to transfer your child to another school.
Hi seniors. Need some clarification on the 30 mths rule for phase 2C. Thanks!
1) If say there was balloting conducted for SCs for 1-2km n we directly got in via SCs <1km. Does this mean that we r bounded by the 30 mth rule?
2) If there was another scenario whereby all SCs got in regardless of distance and only PRs had to ballot. Does that mean we are NOT bounded by the 30 mths ruling? Or as long as balloting is invoked (i.e demand > supply) regardless of nationality, the 30 mths rule stands?
3) what is the reprecussions of breaching the 30 mth rule? MOE withdraw ur kid n throw to some ulu sch? If we changed the original pri sch to another pri sch nearer to the new address then its all good?
4) if we got in via SC <1km route but we shifted to a new hm that is 1-2km instead. Do we breach the 30 mths rule? -
Jennia14\" post_id=\"1990082\" time=\"1596907106\" user_id=\"186027:Yes.
As long as you benefited over someone else due to your distance category, you have to honor the 30 months.Jennia14\" post_id=\"1990082\" time=\"1596907106\" user_id=\"186027:[quote=Jennia14 post_id=1990082 time=1596907106 user_id=186027]2) If there was another scenario whereby all SCs got in regardless of distance and only PRs had to ballot. Does that mean we are NOT bounded by the 30 mths ruling? Or as long as balloting is invoked (i.e demand > supply) regardless of nationality, the 30 mths rule stands?
Jennia14\" post_id=\"1990082\" time=\"1596907106\" user_id=\"186027:Not ulu school, most likely the least popular school within your same schooling district that still has vacancies even after Phase 3. There’s always at least one such school in every district.
Yes. So please 乖乖 stay 30 months like everyone else then move away.Jennia14\" post_id=\"1990082\" time=\"1596907106\" user_id=\"186027:[quote=Jennia14 post_id=1990082 time=1596907106 user_id=186027]4) if we got in via SC <1km route but we shifted to a new hm that is 1-2km instead. Do we breach the 30 mths rule?
-
Jennia14\" post_id=\"1990082\" time=\"1596907106\" user_id=\"186027:
any parent caught cheating using P1 registration rule,
3) what is the reprecussions of breaching the 30 mth rule? MOE withdraw ur kid n throw to some ulu sch? If we changed the original pri sch to another pri sch nearer to the new address then its all good?
- MOE (school) will publish the parents' name onto newspapers, social media.
Parents shamed can lose job, go jail, etc
- the kid leave the coveted school, posted by MOE to another primary school that still have Phase 3 vacancies left
https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/courts-crime/father-who-lied-about-address-during-pri-1-registration-gets-fine-instead-of
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login