2022 P1 Registration Exercise for 2023 In-take

[beatbo]

Ouch Pei Hwa numbers are fierce, 112 appplied for 43 spots. As expected, balloting in 1-2 km bracket. Rosyth also balloting 1-2 km but at least there are 73 spots for 113 applicants.

SG_KP1\" post_id=\"2074398\" time=\"1657789377\" user_id=\"188234:

Just updated!

[floppy]

SG_KP1\" post_id=\"2074399\" time=\"1657789623\" user_id=\"188234:

Doesn't seem as bad as feared. Ex-MK schools:

-Nan Hua: no ballot, only those within 2 km
-PHPPS: 1-2 km
-Rosyth: 1-2 km

Pretty much the same usual suspects along some new ones (MK schools mostly new).

[SG_KP1]

beatbo\" post_id=\"2074402\" time=\"1657790074\" user_id=\"178388:

Ouch Pei Hwa numbers are fierce, 112 appplied for 43 spots. As expected, balloting in 1-2 km bracket. Rosyth also balloting 1-2 km but at least there are 73 spots for 113 applicants.

It's still hard to make heads or tails out of the odds though, no? I.e. need to know how many < 1 km to take out of available spots and then how many > 2 km not eligible to spin the wheel?

Notwithstanding, Pei Hwa probably not so great while Rosyth may not be that bad?

Again, in the end only really matters ballot in or ballot out though...

[skii]

floppy\" post_id=\"2074403\" time=\"1657790345\" user_id=\"97579:

Pretty much the same usual suspects along some new ones (MK schools mostly new).

join MK can jump phase, of cos everyone will join la.

[skii]

SG_KP1\" post_id=\"2074405\" time=\"1657790454\" user_id=\"188234:

It's still hard to make heads or tails out of the odds though, no? I.e. need to know how many < 1 km to take out of available spots and then how many > 2 km not eligible to spin the wheel?

Notwithstanding, Pei Hwa probably not so great while Rosyth may not be that bad?

Again, in the end only really matters ballot in or ballot out though...

ya - hard but not impossible
eg: Pei Hwa,
44 places with 112 applicants.

call the school for the breakdown lo... if use a sweet voice, maybe the GO clerk will be kind to release the numbers within the 1-2km.

[floppy]

beatbo\" post_id=\"2074402\" time=\"1657790074\" user_id=\"178388:

Ouch Pei Hwa numbers are fierce, 112 appplied for 43 spots. As expected, balloting in 1-2 km bracket. Rosyth also balloting 1-2 km but at least there are 73 spots for 113 applicants.

For Pei Hwa, it doesn't mean 112 for 44 places.
Given that balloting is only for 1-2km, you do not know how much places are taken up by < 1km, and how many people among the 112 are > 2km.
In the worst possible case scenario:
43 applicants are < 1km, 0 applicant > 2km.
Resulting in 69 applicants balloting for 1 spot.

[skii]

floppy\" post_id=\"2074409\" time=\"1657790622\" user_id=\"97579:

For Pei Hwa, it doesn't mean 112 for 44 places.
Given that balloting is only for 1-2km, you do not know how much places are taken up by < 1km, and how many people among the 112 are > 2km.
In the worst possible case scenario:
43 applicants are < 1km, 0 applicant > 2km.
Resulting in 69 applicants balloting for 1 spot.

Best case,
within 1km: 1 (no need to ballot)
1-2km: 44 (balloting)
above 2km: 67 (no chance to ballot)

44 ballot for 43 spot.

Therefore, the odds is from 1/69 to 43/44

[floppy]

skii\" post_id=\"2074413\" time=\"1657790847\" user_id=\"82603:

...
Therefore, the odds is from 1/69 to 43/44

:rotflmao:

Between 1.4% and 97.7%.

[skii]

floppy\" post_id=\"2074417\" time=\"1657791278\" user_id=\"97579:

:rotflmao:

Between 1.4% and 97.7%.

plus plus minus minus

(scar-lee Chief give me warning points for pointless analysis) :rotflmao: :rotflmao: :rotflmao: :rotflmao:

[cosycornercreek]

https://postimg.cc/9R0t93yn


Hi everyone, I applied for SCGS for my daughter under Phase 2A - it says that there are 79 applicants for 77 places (see image/screenshot), but that NO balloting is required. Can anyone shed light on why this might be so given that there seems to be an excess of 2 applicants?