Property Views
-
verykiasu2010:
canDesertWind:
[quote=\"verykiasu2010\"] but why cannot like the HDB owner - hoard the HDB first, then rent out private ppty leh ? why force people to sell an income generating asset and don't force HDB owner to sell also income generating asset ?......
Hi Hi,
Sorry for my ignorant but under new policy, can I buy HDB, sell off my private prop. within 6 months (which means effectively I only have HDB in meantime). Then after some time, buy private property again to generate passive income?
:?
but you will lose the opportunity in that 5 years of MOP
by then private ppty escalate until don know where liao ? fair ? while the existing HDB owner holding on to the private ppty and laughing all the way to the bank......hope you see the inequity here
if you want to have a policy, it has to be balanced on both sides, especially when it deals with large amount of blood and sweat money of citizens....eg you force someone to sell the private ppty for S$800k now, you expect him to buy back 5 years later at S$800k still ? siao!!![/quote]
Were you planning to buy a HDB flat, before the new rule kicks in?
If you are an existing flat owner with private properties, no impact right?
Although cannot buy more private properties until you satisfy MOP but meantime still can hold on to existing private properties to collect rental -
verykiasu2010:
For the case you quoted.. I guess they really really just need to pay a visit to their MPs.. policy is policy.. it's targeted at the maybe 90%..
esp those who are retrenched and retired with no income, thinking of using the old private property to rent out for income / sustenance while live in HDB flat...but now some smart alec in HDB caused them more hardship....and these are true blue citizens, given their youth in serving the country till retirement and now no income, even forced to sell away an income generating asset when buying HDB flat...while those HDB flat owners can buy spanking new condo to invest for rental income while earning another income in full time job....not fair right ?
For the 10% who suffered unnecessarily.. there's always exceptional case right? Just talk to the MP lah.. they're there to lent a listening ear. they might be able to work out something.. There is no reason to forsake a policy that is 90% effective for the sake of a few exceptional cases.. But they should be able to make exception for those cases that justifies it. i.e. allow them to buy HDB and still keep their pte pty.. maybe someone can try and then share share the result..? If it is a really justified case and the MPs don't help, then write to ST lor.. -
Hi hi
I see quite heated up exchange here. To be honest I am in the same boat as verykiasu2010. I am also thinking hey it’s not fair that after the new rules set in, HDB dwellers after 5yrs MOP can go buy a pte and yet keep their HDB; while on the other hand private ppty owners are not given the same treatment. Yes, I can identify with verykiasu2010 frustrations.
On second thoughts, in reality how many HDB dwellers are there who can actually keep their HDB flats while still able to fork out the downpayment of 20% or 30% if their HDB loan is still oustanding. I have a good friend who has bought a pte apt before 30 Aug, he has been trying to sell his flat. After 30 Aug, I say to him why not keep your HDB flat and not sell it since it has overnight become a prized possession that not all SC are entitled. He says that’s not possible as he needs the cashflow for his downpayment. Hence the reality is, even with that privilege, not many can actually truely enjoy it. Then again I am not saying that this equate to being fair.
5 years down the road, how much would the pte ppty cost? With rich foreigners coming in with so much liquidity, and these people are not eyeing on HDB flats, they are eyeing our private properties, calling them "cheap". Therefore the upside for pte properties is still very promising. It is definitely not a all-lost thing for pte ppty owners.
There are many viewpoints & arguments re the new housing rules which range from HDB dwellers vs pte ppty owners, SC vs PR vs FT vs FW. At the end of the day, what I read from the Straits Times last weekend - the SG housing rules change from time to time across the decades (as mentioned by my 70yo+ dad even before the reports). Meanwhile we just have to ride through it. We never know. -
Seem to me that if a person has both hdb and private property; and wishes to change hdb flat (for whatever reason), it means that the person will have to sell off EVERYTHING he owns just to change hdb…a bit the odd right?
I should think that if a hdb owner wants to buy private property, he MUST stay in the hdb flat - else he should sell it. HDB flat should only be for occupiers. I see some new neighbours - the faces in the unit change constantly but I have no clue who the owner is (mine is old estate - everyone recognises each other by face), and I wonder why it is correct to own a hdb flat to generate rental returns. Isn’t it govt policy to provide affordable housing for citizens (and PRs) to LIVE in?
Dunno if my comments above will kena hantam. btw, I’m a happy HDB dweller and plan on staying there for a long long time. -
verykiasu2010:
if one inherited the run down walk up apt, then one never even forked out money to buy? then whatever one sells for is 100% pure profit? inheritance mah. not even negative equity.
eh, not true hor
some private property owner are really poor, inherited the very run-down walk-up apartment that worth even less than a HDB 5 room in Mei Ling St or Bishan...these people where got rich ? can't even make ends meet, and the private property on hand is worthless -- they are also trying to upgrade - to a newer HDB - subsidised by tax payers' money in upgrading, while the private got no upgrading, no conservancy charges rebate, no GST rebate, pay higher property tax, that is why must \"upgrade\" also -- to a HDB flat, how to afford to push up the HDB prices.....think ok !! not everyone in private ppty is as rich as you think !! PRAY hard you will not be one such private ppty owner hor ...... think, don't be of a one track mind, think only one way ..... every one living in private ppty must be rich meh ? -
hquek:
yes, I also think that a HDB flat is to provide affordable housing for citizens and PRs, and it should stay that way.Seem to me that if a person has both hdb and private property; and wishes to change hdb flat (for whatever reason), it means that the person will have to sell off EVERYTHING he owns just to change hdb....a bit the odd right?
I should think that if a hdb owner wants to buy private property, he MUST stay in the hdb flat - else he should sell it. HDB flat should only be for occupiers. I see some new neighbours - the faces in the unit change constantly but I have no clue who the owner is (mine is old estate - everyone recognises each other by face), and I wonder why it is correct to own a hdb flat to generate rental returns. Isn't it govt policy to provide affordable housing for citizens (and PRs) to LIVE in?
Dunno if my comments above will kena hantam. btw, I'm a happy HDB dweller and plan on staying there for a long long time.
If that citizen or PR becomes wealthy, he can invest elsewhere to make or lose money, and/but continue to use the HDB flat as his home.
he is also free to sell the HDB flat and live in a private house if he wants to. in doing so he knowingly give up some \"HDB\" benefits. in which case, the amount of wealth he has accumulated should be sufficient to ignore such benefits. -
Dun forget, even before the policy changes, CPF does not allow you to touch the ordinary account for a 2nd property if you do not have the minimum sum in there. So, yes, most younger pple will have cashflow problems if they buy a pte property and don’t sell their HDBs (if they had used CPF to buy).
Alamak, very shang1 nao3 jin1 to think about all these inequity and restrictions. I think I will just stay clear of HDB flats. If want 2nd property, just buy private, albeit a smaller unit now with the loan reductions. -
cherrygal:
Alamak, very shang1 nao3 jin1 to think about all these inequity and restrictions. I think I will just stay clear of HDB flats. If want 2nd property, just buy private, albeit a smaller unit now with the loan reductions.
Yes, alamak, shang nao jing indeed!
For me I think next time when I retire I will just stear clear of private properties and just buy HDB! Keep the cash and enjoy all the benefits that a HDB address can bring me!
On second thoughts, perhaps buy a BIG HDB and rent out one-or-two rooms for rental income if cannot buy another private....
-
cherrygal:
hahaha... pte property?... yes, most younger pple will have cashflow problems if they buy a pte property and don't sell their HDBs...
I see younger people having problems buying a HDB flat now.
hopefully, these \"cooling off measures\" will help them somewhat, eventually... -
verykiasu2010:
Of course there is no difference if you look at the end state of what each of them hold on their hands.your reasoning is irrational.
there is no difference between :
(1) someone bought HDB, sold it, moved to private, now want to buy HDB to downgrade and live in it and rent out the private for rental income for sustenance
and
(2) and existing HDB owner, accumulate enough cash, buy a private for investment income
In EFFECT : both are living in HDB and getting rental income from private property
There is no difference.
HDB owners are also rich - rich enough to own investment properties
So why penalise the private property owner who wish to downgrade to live in HDB flat ?
But if you look at the state of each of them when the HDB was purchased, they are totally different and that's what the govt is trying to separate now. Pte owner who downgrade can afford the hdb or another private property. The guy who bought the hdb and kept it while accumulating his/her funds had no other options when he applied for the hdb and that's what the hdb flats are for, isn't it? For pple who cannot afford non-public housing. If the govt dun block the pte prop owners from coming in, the present non-owners can never compete with these downgraders for a hdb flat. Then public housing policy has failed.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login0
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects