Children Suicide Cases
-
ZacK:
Would you have your kids rewrite and conform to the system and possibly impede their creativity just so that they can be scored academically or appeal to the teacher that there is nothing wrong with the composition, in fact, it was both creative and well written.

If a kid is super good in mental arithmetic and get all the answers to his math correct, he won't get full score if he doesn't show the workings. Even if he showed workings, he won't get full score if he doesn't draw the model the school needs him to even if he knows the concept.
I watch Project Runway. Even the most talented contestant have to stick to the challenge's requirements in order to pass the judges' hurdle - no point producing fantastic designs/personal niche designs if they do not stick to what is required by the challenge.
I think if the kid would have incorporate some human elements alongside the cockroach analogy, she need not have to redo the whole essay.
JMHO. -
I’ve been reading silently for a while now. Thank you , Insider, for posting the article and for bringing up the subject. I really appreciate your thoughtful comments and bringing up a different angle for us parents to consider.
-
jedamum:
I guess when implementing a rule across the board and in order to maintain consistency, the teachers would need to reduce as much subjectivity as possible and thus the need for teacher to follow strictly to the marking guide... There are pros and cons to doing everything so depending on the objective, I would not say that MOE or the teachers are wrong. Only thing for me is, this system breeds mediocrity as everyone every child if kind of force to think in the same way and not out of the boxZacK:
Would you have your kids rewrite and conform to the system and possibly impede their creativity just so that they can be scored academically or appeal to the teacher that there is nothing wrong with the composition, in fact, it was both creative and well written.

If a kid is super good in mental arithmetic and get all the answers to his math correct, he won't get full score if he doesn't show the workings. Even if he showed workings, he won't get full score if he doesn't draw the model the school needs him to even if he knows the concept.
I watch Project Runway. Even the most talented contestant have to stick to the challenge's requirements in order to pass the judges' hurdle - no point producing fantastic designs/personal niche designs if they do not stick to what is required by the challenge.
I think if the kid would have incorporate some human elements alongside the cockroach analogy, she need not have to redo the whole essay.
JMHO.
-
insider:
I do not have statistics to back this, but this are my sentiments as well. My impression of the local education system is it is too left brain oriented, too rigid and does not require kids to think out of the box and explore other avenues of approaching a problem.
I am frustrated with the local educational system. I can’t wait to pack my kids off to overseas for their higher education once they are ready (I can’t stand ‘square’ people and the chance of them turning square permanently is high if continue to be educated here). -
tony:
I've been reading silently for a while now. Thank you , Insider, for posting the article and for bringing up the subject. I really appreciate your thoughtful comments and bringing up a different angle for us parents to consider.
Hi Tony,
Welcome to KSP :welcome:
Btw every noobie is entitled to his/her own thread http://www.kiasuparents.com/kiasu/forum/viewforum.php?f=28.
Enjoy your \"stay\" here :celebrate: -
[quote]
My impression of the local education system is it is too left brain oriented, too rigid and does not require kids to think out of the box and explore other avenues of approaching a problem.[/quote] :idea: Think about it...
Rigid local education system --> breeds inside the box Scholars ---> applied for Govt Scholarships --> worked for Govt with career path all pathed out --> Govt main political ruling party = where is the out of the box 'incentive'? :roll:
People who are \"out of the box\" like entreprenuers are at times those who actually fell out of this educational system.
I dunno if i am going to get stoned for saying this, but the local education system is catered towards educating the masses, with many middle and lower income families making up bulk of students and for this aspect, the system serves pretty well what they do - providing children with education. We also need a substantial amount of 'rule-abiding' workforce as a supporting role in many aspects of the industries. Creativity is subjective (just like art) and there is no 'criteria' to mark. The culture and work attitude in SG has yet reached the standard of 'open' societies in the West. In SG, you can truly focus on creativity if you have the greens or the flair. Else, like anyone else, they'll need to eventually 'fit in' (which inturn will of course run the risk of being turned \"square permanently\") if they need that score to get that headstart in the next phase of the education path.
But personally, i feel that eventually it is the parent's choice of actions that matters more than whatever inflexibility that the education system seems to be. Like insider mentioned, she can have the option to pack her kids off overseas to further their studies. We as parents have the option to just let the kids follow their creativeness and forgo that pursuit of marks - but i guess only those who truly have faith in their child's abilities (or have the reserves to send their kids overseas should they fall out of the education system in the bid to stay creative) will opt for the route of choosing creativity over marks in totality.
JMHO.
Just want to add this too... sometimes it is just not only the system's fault. it is the way the school and the teachers flexibility in allowing non-standard answers. passionate teachers and schools that are not stress up to meet KPIs have the option to disregard the marking guidelines (inner exams ie). but then again the same cannot be said when the kids need to be assessed by external examination markers (cos they do need a standard to follow for core subjects). while we expressed our frustrations on the rigid system, how many of us will truly dare to go against the 'norm'? while every parent wants the best for their kid, there is no one-size-fits-all solution - we need to know that sometimes we can't have the cake and eat it too. -
insider:
I sure get what you meant.
She excels in Literature but her interest was very negatively affected by her Literature teacher during an exam in her Sec 1.
(I argued with the teacher but gave up eventually as no point trying to convince someone who is so driven by KPI). I feel for her. The teacher destroyed whatever good Chinese exposure that I have been giving to her by year in and year out drying up her creativity for the sake of MARKS.
Recently, my boy was negatively affected cos one of his teachers implied that the story books that he was reading were not exactly age-appropriate (my boy said \"he doesn't believe that I can read those books\"
). The teacher even told my boy to read him a page to prove himself.
I am actually surprised that my usual-rule-abiding son chose to ignore the teacher's instructions (he said he just walked away); I think he was either too scared or too pissed.
I am hoping that my boy had misinterpreted the situation.
I wondered...is the teacher concerned that kids should be better off reading age appropriate materials (that it is not-productive to attempt books meant for higher-ability readers), or that he thinks that my boy is just bluffing him.
-
insider:
Hmm…just wondering… Our education system was essentially an “Asian” kind, sort of “derived” from the ancient China system. China, Japan, Taiwan, Korea I think have quite similar kind of education system which is also exam oriented where massive texts need to be memorised and drilling is required. (I think MOE is gradually trying to steer away from this type of learning). I think the children there experience much more pressure than kids here.
I am frustrated with the local educational system. I can’t wait to pack my kids off to overseas for their higher education once they are ready (I can’t stand ‘square’ people and the chance of them turning square permanently is high if continue to be educated here).
Most people in those countries (countries with deep rooted cultures and traditions) that I’ve mentioned don’t seemed to be “square”. In fact, a lot of creative stuff come from them. I wonder whether the evolvement of “squareness” has anything to do with our environment that we’re living in on the whole, what we are exposed to, the way we are governed, which creates the kind of mentality to always “play safe” so as not to step out of boundaries?insider:
She relented and conformed to those 'guidelines' under ultra reluctance that I know she feels sore until today (she got an A2 for her Higher Chinese in her O levels).
ZacK:
I agree that language/art can be very subjective. A piece of original/creative work can be viewed as ‘brilliant” or “bad” if viewed by different people. Hence, probably adhering to a “proven” format seems to be the safest bet for the teacher, as we can’t guarantee how the marker will perceive the piece of work, esp. if it’s for something as important as the “O” levels. Think abt it, your daughter might have gotten an A1 if she did it her way and the marker appreciated her work. If not, wld the marker mark her down and gave her a B or worst, a C grade if he/she could not see eye to eye with your daughter’s creative efforts?I guess when implementing a rule across the board and in order to maintain consistency, the teachers would need to reduce as much subjectivity as possible and thus the need for teacher to follow strictly to the marking guide... There are pros and cons to doing everything so depending on the objective, I would not say that MOE or the teachers are wrong. Only thing for me is, this system breeds mediocrity as everyone every child if kind of force to think in the same way and not out of the box

-
jedamum:
Aiyoh, now still have this kind of teachers? Don't they know how KS parents are nowadays? So children reading higher-level material is quite acceptable or even encouraged. If it were my DD, I'm sure she would've recited the selected page flawlessly.I sure get what you meant.
Recently, my boy was negatively affected cos one of his teachers implied that the story books that he was reading were not exactly age-appropriate (my boy said \"he doesn't believe that I can read those books\"
). The teacher even told my boy to read him a page to prove himself.
I am actually surprised that my usual-rule-abiding son chose to ignore the teacher's instructions (he said he just walked away); I think he was either too scared or too pissed.
I am hoping that my boy had misinterpreted the situation.
I wondered...is the teacher concerned that kids should be better off reading age appropriate materials (that it is not-productive to attempt books meant for higher-ability readers), or that he thinks that my boy is just bluffing him.
I thought these kind of teachers only existed back in our generation cos back then, it is common for kids to enter P1 without being able to read or read well. I remember one of the books my mom bought for me in P1 was by Charles Dickens (of course, abridged one lah) and when I got 2nd in standard at the end of the year, guess what my prize was? Cinderella and Rumpelstiltskin. I was like, \"Huh??\". I was rather meek back then so I didn't kick up a fuss at school. I just chucked the books to one side when I got home.
Come to think of it, I have only encountered teachers telling the students that they should read more challenging and varied stuff to help them with their essays, especially if they only read teen romance novels and readers' digests. (This is in sec sch.) -
sunflower:
I agree that language/art can be very subjective. A piece of original/creative work can be viewed as ‘brilliant” or “bad” if viewed by different people.
The above happened to me! My secondary school days was one of the unhappiest days in my life. Was so happy when I graduated.
Literature and English was one of my 'worst' subjects during secondary school basically because I had a Secondary Teacher whom (I think and believe) discriminated against me. She taught the class both subjects. And compo/essay writing is one of my weakest (in my teacher's opinions) bec I couldn't meet her 'standards'. Oh, I'm also not those curry-favour/cheeky type of students who talk alot in class. I belong to the diligent/self-conscious category.
Once, I remembered that I tried to improve on my sentence structuring and using thesaurus rigorously to form varied sentences so that she could give me marks for that. I even tried to remember descriptive sentences coming from story books (i.e. knitting her brows - to describe a worrisome mother) so that I could impress her. But she marked it wrong instead. I was very upset then that I approached her to say why can't I 'knit their brows'. I even showed her how I 'knitted my brows' by frowning. Her reply was: 'How can one (literally) knit brows without some knitting needles. It's wrong what!' I thought it was lame excuse she was trying to brush me off. If it had been her pet student, her answer would be very diff.
It was an obvious favouritism. There was another time I had copied the exact descriptive sentence (describing the skyline) from my ex-best friend's essay. She had gotten a 'GOOD DESCRIPTION!' from her essay (she had copied from her story books too). But when it came to me, the teacher put a cross on it. It upsetted me but I kept all quiet bec I knew confronting wouldn't help. She'll just use some crap reason to weave her way out.
And for my literature, don't even talk about it. One of her pet pupils was commented for thinking out of the box by describing these two key characters from 'Merchants from the Venice' - Shakespearan text that their behaviour was gayish and supported with good evidences. She openly praised her pet student and announced those who failed (in her opinion) to the class. And I'm one of those very weak students.
I was so happy when I had the option to drop Literature during my final year as I was doing 8 subjects. A teacher can really kill the child's interest.
My ex-best friend's English was considered one of the best in that teacher's opinion, but in the end she scored a B4 or C5 in her Os, plus all her other left-brain subjects that she usually scores very poorly, the aggregate wasn't fantastic. And me, B3! During my prelims, I was obviously marked by another teacher and had already scored A2 then.
I exceled in Maths and Chinese basically bec I had very good Math and Chinese teachers. Had wanted to thank my geography teacher too and I was aiming for an A (but got a B3 instead) so as to show how much I enjoyed her class. Was so lucky to get an excellent geo teacher just in time for my 'O' level years. If it had been my old teacher, think I would have been happy that I could pass.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login12
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects