Do you cane your daughters when they misbehave?
-
I have never caned my girl and boy before. Both of them are reasonably well behaved.
They never throw tantrums when I do not agree to buy things for them. In fact, they never expect me to buy anything for them when we go out shopping. They never say things like "Mommy, buy this for me now". The reason is because I buy things for them only during their birthdays, or when they have worked hard. From a very young age, they know that they can eventually get what they want, if they work hard. So there is no need to throw tantrums.
When my girl entered P1, I started to give her allowance everyday. She saves part of her allowance everyday, so that she can buy what she likes. She is saving up so that she can get a computer of her own. I remember that when I was 14 years old, I saved a dollar everyday, for 100 days, and I bought a cassette recorder. I never thought about asking my parents to buy for me.
We must understand the fact that it is natural for kids to want certain things. It is not natural to suppress this desire by caning them. We should teach them the correct way of getting what they want. Once they understand it, then they will have no reason to throw tantrums.
For other cases like when they hit each other, instead of caning them, I make them kiss and hug each other. This is actually more dreadful than caning, especially when they were angry with each other. However when they were made to hug each other, they became a lot less resentful of each other. Now both my kids play very well together.
There are many methods that are more effective than caning. Parents just have to use their brains to think, instead of using their hands to hit. -
tamarind:
For other cases like when they hit each other, instead of caning them, I make them kiss and hug each other. This is actually more dreadful than caning, especially when they were angry with each other. However when they were made to hug each other, they became a lot less resentful of each other. Now both my kids play very well together.
I like this part and I make them do this as well. But sometimes both of them just hug and kiss for \"wayang\" only. -
Another method that I have used, which I think is more effective than caning, is to make my kids write the same sentence many times.
For example, I made my boy write \"I will not hit my sister again\" 50 times before. Our aim is to teach kids a lesson, and making them write the same thing many times will reinforce the lesson. The \"side effect\" is that my kids get to practice their handwriting. Both my kids write very neatly now
-
LKVM:
:celebrate:tamarind:
The \"side effect\" is that my kids get to practice their handwriting. Both my kids write very neatly now

Guess this is not the side effect but the best effect
-
while #1 and #3 dont expect me to buy to toys when we go out, unfortunately #2 (boy) always cry n whine n grumble if he sees toys when we shopping n dont buy for him.
so we always must pre-empt him, tell him that can see but cannot buy. if he agrees, then can go.
he is usu ok but stimes still cry n whine. in whc case i must say caning is no choice bcos my boy is that type that wait for THE LAST STRAW before he stops any of his manipulatiive wayang. so tamarind, u r blessed wif well behaved kids
my boy is pretty unreasonable esp when he was younger. only now that he is 5, he is much better n able to accept reasoning but still not completely mature n outgrow his nonsense yet.
he belongs to the type who cannot accept ending of show, events, outings etc. -
Yeah, I hit her open palm with the cane.
But I have found an even better punishment. I throw her out of the house and close the gate.
Sheโs 4+. -
I spank her when she talks back, tell lies and doesnโt behave. Spank her on her bottom. Sheโs 6.
-
noobparent:
my ex-neighbour used to do that to their toddler.Yeah, I hit her open palm with the cane.
But I have found an even better punishment. I throw her out of the house and close the gate.
She's 4+.
doesn't it implied that the parents love the kid lesser because of misbehaviour? i thought parents should create a secure environment for their children. -
noobparent:
My colleague does this when his son is young. Now secondary, wherever she scolded him, he will just leave the house for a few days.
But I have found an even better punishment. I throw her out of the house and close the gate.
-
MrsSeah:
Children remember how they are punished...it will backfire if the child runs away if he/she is put outside. I will use the cane when repeated reminders do not work.
My colleague does this when his son is young. Now secondary, wherever she scolded him, he will just leave the house for a few days.noobparent:
But I have found an even better punishment. I throw her out of the house and close the gate.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better ๐
Register Login7
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects