Teaching Chinese at Home
-
But my Chinese is so bad that without hanyupinyin I cannot read all the words in the books meant for my 3 year old!!! Probably in my case it is better to use hypy then to get the pronunciations all wrong…
-
Praline:
But my Chinese is so bad that without hanyupinyin I cannot read all the words in the books meant for my 3 year old!!! Probably in my case it is better to use hypy then to get the pronunciations all wrong...
I memorise as much as possible. There may be some words that I don't really know still. What i may do in those cases, is to write the hypy for those at another unrelated corner of the page so it's not associated with the chinese characters. -
Erm, is chInese so difficult to learn?? There is so much emphasis given to Chinese. :?
I find that English is more difficult to learn than Chinese, especially grammar. I can never write proper poetic English.
-
smurf:
It's difficult to me! That's why I always wanted to give my kids a headstart. Didn't want them to grow up hating chinese, so enrolled them in SAP schools. Unfortunately, it's only been a 1/3 success story for the older 3. Only 1 out of the 3 older ones really like chinese, altho' at least they don't totally hate it like is quite the case in a more \"ang moh\" school environment.Erm, is chInese so difficult to learn?? There is so much emphasis given to Chinese. :?
I find that English is more difficult to learn than Chinese, especially grammar. I can never write proper poetic English.
-
smurf:
Not really, Chinese is easy to learn if the child has the passion in it. Most important is to built their passion while they are young by exposing them to lots of chinese reading books, fun words and chengyu stories, to build a strong foundation.Erm, is chInese so difficult to learn?? There is so much emphasis given to Chinese. :?
-
phankao:
DangDang.com have these types of books or not?
dangdang.com has tons and tons of pictures books, without hanyu pinyin. The books listed in my blog for ages 2 to 6 are picture books without hanyu pinyin (all except 2 books) from my home library:
http://tamarindvillage.blogspot.com/2010/09/how-to-raise-bilingual-child.html
Each book costs $3+ on average including shipping to Singapore. There are thousands more titles in dangdang. Those that I listed are excellent books that kids will love. Although the books are for young kids, the words are challenging for adults in Singapore.
The books are not always very big, but not very small either. I would say the size is medium. Chinese parents do not think that very young kids should read books with huge words, and probably that is why their kids can read long novels with small words by 7 or 8 years old. I think they are right. -
Vinarc:
I absolutely agree with Vinarc.
Not really, Chinese is easy to learn if the child has the passion in it. Most important is to built their passion while they are young by exposing them to lots of chinese reading books, fun words and chengyu stories, to build a strong foundation.smurf:
Erm, is chInese so difficult to learn?? There is so much emphasis given to Chinese. :?
In fact, my parents could not teach me Chinese when I was young, and they never read any Chinese books to me. But they allowed me to take a bus to the national library every week, and I loved to read Chinese story books.
I scored high marks in Chinese all the way to A levels, and I never had any Chinese tuition, and never did any assessment books. I spent the least time studying Chinese textbooks. But I spend all my free time reading fantastic Chinese books purely for enjoyment.
I found English very difficult to learn when I was in school. Mostly because I did not know phonics, and I could not read well. So that is why I put in effort to teach my kids English first. Then I realized that if we use the correct methods, learning English could be very easy too.
The problem with Chinese is that most parents do not know what is the correct way of teaching Chinese. They thought that they should make kids practice writing as many Chinese characters as possible since a very young age. This is a big mistake. Most kids will end up hating Chinese (except for a few very rare ones who like to write Chinese). The correct method should be to focus on character recognition before 6 years old.
The other mistake is to teach hanyu pinyin before the child even starts to learn Chinese. English educated parents do not believe that their kids can learn Chinese without hanyu pinyin, which is very wrong. Most kids before 6 years old have a very good ability to remember Chinese characters as pictures, there is no need to use hanyu pinyin at all. In fact, if parents teach the child hanyu pinyin first, he may reject reading Chinese. -
While mummies here are discussing how to teach children 认字w/o hypy, MOE change policy again. Will affect my son who go P1 next year
http://www.asiaone.com/News/Latest%2BNews/Edvantage/Story/A1Story20110118-258975.html
the part on getting more teachers & making Chinese learning more interesting is most welcomed. But that part on using computer to answer exam questions mean there is no need to learn 笔画anymore! As long as u know how to type hypy or scribble the word pictorially, whether the little 撇or捺comes b4 the 横is no longer impt. Mummy here is getting a cultural shock. I always feel these are the little things that make Chinese character beautiful. Sigh... -
tamarind:
The issue for a 1year old reader, is not only the size of the words. It is also because they emphasize the picture more than the words. You yourself already described the books as \"Picture Books\". That is distracting to a very young reader. Words should be larger than the pictures, and preferably on separate pages without the distraction of the pictures. That's why I like the books that I posted up there. Some of the books, I make myself based on day-to-day experiences. Lots of words too, by the time it comes to the more difficult levels. But expensive lah.phankao:
DangDang.com have these types of books or not?
dangdang.com has tons and tons of pictures books, without hanyu pinyin. The books listed in my blog for ages 2 to 6 are picture books without hanyu pinyin (all except 2 books) from my home library:
http://tamarindvillage.blogspot.com/2010/09/how-to-raise-bilingual-child.html
Each book costs $3+ on average including shipping to Singapore. There are thousands more titles in dangdang. Those that I listed are excellent books that kids will love. Although the books are for young kids, the words are challenging for adults in Singapore.
The books are not always very big, but not very small either. I would say the size is medium. Chinese parents do not think that very young kids should read books with huge words, and probably that is why their kids can read long novels with small words by 7 or 8 years old. I think they are right. -
phankao:
I don't agree with you that words must be bigger than pictures. It is very important for young kids to look at pictures for as long as they want, while they read. Pictures help kids to understand what they are reading. Otherwise kids may know many words but don't understand the meaning, or how to use them.
The issue for a 1year old reader, is not only the size of the words. It is also because they emphasize the picture more than the words. You yourself already described the books as \"Picture Books\". That is distracting to a very young reader. Words should be larger than the pictures, and preferably on separate pages without the distraction of the pictures. That's why I like the books that I posted up there. Some of the books, I make myself based on day-to-day experiences. Lots of words too, by the time it comes to the more difficult levels. But expensive lah.
The books in my blog are all best selling books and well loved by many young kids in China, I believe that mainland China parents know better than us when it comes to teaching Chinese to their kids.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login2
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects