Teach Less, Learn More
-
Happy Mama:
Dd's in Pri 3 this year. Yes, Roald Dahl's BFF. :D[/quote]My DD had juz started reading one of Roald Dahl's book but not BFF leh. Hope her sch will oso use Roald Dahl's book when she reaches P3. At least I noe e book will b read instead of collecting dust. :lol:
Do u mean one of Roald Dahl's story books??? Which level is yur DD at?cantbearit2:
[quote=\"Happy Mama\"]
Ya that's true. DD was asked to buy Roald Dahl's book for English this year. Hopefully it will be put to use during Semester 2. -
smurf:
Tink we shld not gif up hope as yet. If we r willing to provide constructive feedback, who noes, thgs might change.I think even with petition, they the garmen will not accept it. They think their policy/method or whatever you call it, is RIGHT, as usual. It's the right way to go. They will overthrow the petition for sure.
Eventually, many kids will suffer because of this kind of rat race. No childhood, no nothing. Sigh... -
You are very optimistic hor. Even if they are willing to listen, it will takes another couple of years before they change it. They must realize that itβs is a wrong concept before they even want to listen.
-
Chenonceau:
Not just 6 hrs of sch .. if u add in those hrs spent on supplementary classes, which are really NOT to supplement their learning, but more often than not, are used to catch up on the topics when the teachers are behind schedule! So kids end up returning home 5-6pm at least twice a week, plus time spend to complete the hw, where to find time to do the 'tutorial' role with them for skill practices?Actually, to teach such mental SKILLS. Small group coaching is essential. Given the syllabus, you need a lecture tutorial system where big groups are exposed to a short theory talk through and then tutors take over for skills practice.
That is what is happening now when parents coach kids after school or engage tutors to do so. School does the lecture. Parents and tutors do the skills practice after school. If that is so, they should shorten school hours so we have more time for practice. To go to school to listen to 6 hours of lecture makes no sense.
It is really tough. I think the relationship btw me and my son is also getting strained .. when mommy keeps pushing him to do more, do faster, do better etc ... and he is also tired of studying everyday .. sign .. no wonder more parents want to migrate now .. -
Chenonceau:
Yeah lor... Shocking right? First time I experience this too but my son came back with marked English compo with a few ticks and some minor corrections but no marks. He said \"This teacher never give marks.\"
Hahaha Chenonceau, maybe your son's compo is too good to grade - exceed full marks of 20! He can write so well, I am sure u are not concerned on his EL compo. Read his blog of creative writings - it is like those model essays that creative writing classes dish out in the beginning of the class! I printed all for my P5 son to read ...
How nice if they master enough CL vocab to do justice to their imagination while doing their CL compo ... -
Chenonceau boy got blog meh?? Where where?? Can PM me?? I wanna read his creative compo too!!
-
Brenda10:
True, that's how I was being forced to learn about \"unit transfers\" for maths. :lol:
Me too! Spent 2 nights learning it! Then realized that hey, so this is the way to solve all those questions that seem easy when u read, but very difficult to solve type of questions! But this is ridiculous! Sch spent so much time teaching the core/basic methods, yet exam expects students to be able to solve questions requiring unit method that is inadequately covered in sch. I sympathize with those students whose parents are those not numerically inclined ones ... -
smurf:
Chenonceau boy got blog meh?? Where where?? Can PM me?? I wanna read his creative compo too!!
u can find it in the same blog as Chenonceau .. under \"Little boy\"
Haha, I am helping her to advertise! But really, good things must share hor! -
Happy Mama:
Hmmm... I think you have misunderstood me... So I just wanna clarify somewhat... I did not say kids born to roadsweepers are not intelligent. My daughter is dating the son of a bean curd hawker, with a PSLE score of 270 and originally from GEP. A whole lot smarter than she is. We don't believe in tuition. Neither my husband nor I had it. My daughter neither. Neither did her boyfriend. Me, my husband, my daughter and her boyfriend made it through in a system BEFORE the introduction of the new syllabus with skills emphasis.
Kids of cleaners and roadsweepers are not necessarily less intelligent. In some cases, the parents are intelligent but because they were born into less privileged families and circumstances didn't permit them to complete their Primary or Secondary education, hence they end up as cleaners and roadsweepers.
Let me explain.
My son is tested on math questions requiring skills that teacher has not given any skills practice on. Horribly difficult questions requiring skills mastery appear in the exam that do not appear at all in homework sheets. The homework sheets are so simple compared to the exam that they're a waste of time to do. Clearly, the teacher assumes that her students have tuition to round off her teaching... that \"math thinking skills\" are being taught by someone else after school. Poor teacher has no choice but to assume so. With 35 kids per class and multiple classes, she has no time for adequate skills practice. My son's case is not isolated. Other parents feel it too. See Brenda and JRLam's experience below.JRLam:
The schools do not cover the unit transfer method (a skill) but the kids need it for exams. No matter how bright the child, how to know and master what has not been taught? Clearly, the teacher assumes that the child is being followed up on by someone else after school.
Me too! Spent 2 nights learning it! Then realized that hey, so this is the way to solve all those questions that seem easy when u read, but very difficult to solve type of questions! But this is ridiculous! Sch spent so much time teaching the core/basic methods, yet exam expects students to be able to solve questions requiring unit method that is inadequately covered in sch. I sympathize with those students whose parents are those not numerically inclined ones ...Brenda10:
True, that's how I was being forced to learn about \"unit transfers\" for maths. :lol:
Actually, to teach the mental SKILLS so important in the new syllabus, small group coaching is essential. You can't teach skills (like cooking skills) by talking alone. Students must DO and receive feedback on what they DO. Teachers who have to teach 35 kids and multiple classes, cannot afford to mark as many skills practices as are required to help kids attain mastery. Given the current skills emphasis syllabus, you pretty much need a lecture-tutorial system where big groups are exposed to a short theory talk through and then tutors take over for skills practice.
In effect, this is what is happening now when parents coach kids after school or engage tutors to do so. School does the lecture. Parents and tutors do the skills practice after school. Kids from poor homes cannot afford that required skills practice after school. You can't just be smart anymore to make it. You have to be able to afford tuition too.
Whilst it is inaccurate to assume that kids from poor homes are not smart, we cannot also assume that the geniuses among them will succeed despite everything. The majority of folks, whether from rich or poor homes, are not geniuses. Teaching in schools need to be complete and sufficient so that people can have a ticket out of poverty... and parents like me can get a life without having to spend money on tuition. The system cannot be calibrated to the assumption that kids have access to after school tuition.
It is possible that only P5 and P6 parents can understand me... The gap between exam requirements and school teaching (or lack thereof) becomes really obvious in P5 and P6.
Gee... I hope I am clear now. I seem to be tying myself into knots. :oops: :oops: :oops: -
cantbearit2:
Quick Quick This Is Election Year!
Tink we shld not gif up hope as yet. If we r willing to provide constructive feedback, who noes, thgs might change.smurf:
I think even with petition, they the garmen will not accept it. They think their policy/method or whatever you call it, is RIGHT, as usual. It's the right way to go. They will overthrow the petition for sure.
Eventually, many kids will suffer because of this kind of rat race. No childhood, no nothing. Sigh...
Anything U Want to Feedback, Petition, etc ....
Talk to your MP Now! Sure to Have SomeOne Willing to Listen and Take up the Cause ....
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better π
Register Login3
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects