Chinese Orchestra DSA

[Xnowy]

phankao:

mommyNg:

[quote=\"Xnowy\"]Hi, my DD is currently at NYGH Chinese orchestra. she told me that many of her CCA members actually went in to NanYang Girls through DSA. what they need is p5 and P6 school results must above 80% then follow by an audition. (not depend on your grade). But I am not sure if everybody got a chance for audition or not.

Oh really? My dd's school CO (external) teacher said for NYGH need at least Grade 6-7 for DSA! So you mean school results still more important than performance in the instrument (for CO)? So some students who applied DSA did not even get a chance to go for audition and they did or did not make it at the end? As for the school results your DD mentioned, is it referring to mainstream or GEP or doesn't matter? Which instrument does your DD play in CO?

Can PM you for more details? :lol:

The girls that I know that got into NYGH under DSA for CO all play erhu. They all have at least grade 8 or 9. Some of them are finalists in National Competition, some are prizewinners. Not necessarily they have good academic grades - all have to do the GAT test anyway.[/quote]my DD told me this year they have DSA of PIPA, DIZI, ERHU. so she couldn't have any chance to take ERHU, she is learning ZHONG RUAN now. and she is enjoying it. DD is taking private lesson with the external CCA instrument teacher now, so i got chance to ask her about the DSA, what she told me is base on audition. I am not sure have to sit for GAT test or not. will ask my DD to find out more. or any parents got experience to share?
my friend's DS is taking PIPA at his primary school and the father went down to DHS and HC, they told him he can try DSA as long as the school result above 80% (overall). and what he told me is no need to sit for any academic test which i am very surprised . will know more next month because the DSA selection will start very soon.

[phankao]

mommyNg:

Does your ds take chinese instrumental exam? Maybe I should get my dd to pick up her violin again! She dropped it after she picked up pipa. Not that she wanted to drop, but she wasn't too keen on practising violin and I din want to waste money and time on both instruments. Maybe at least get her back playing leisurely...?

Yes, my ds has taken NAFA/CCM exams. Now almost done working with grade 8, so maybe will take grade 8 or 9 this year.

[phankao]

Xnowy:

my friend's DS is taking PIPA at his primary school and the father went down to DHS and HC, they told him he can try DSA as long as the school result above 80% (overall). and what he told me is no need to sit for any academic test which i am very surprised . will know more next month because the DSA selection will start very soon.

I think it says on last year's DHS' DSA webpage that if below 80% average, then need to take GAT. Above, no need to take GAT. And if I didn't read wrongly, it says if above Grade 5 in the instrument, no need audition?

[Xnowy]

phankao:

Xnowy:

my friend's DS is taking PIPA at his primary school and the father went down to DHS and HC, they told him he can try DSA as long as the school result above 80% (overall). and what he told me is no need to sit for any academic test which i am very surprised . will know more next month because the DSA selection will start very soon.

I think it says on last year's DHS' DSA webpage that if below 80% average, then need to take GAT. Above, no need to take GAT. And if I didn't read wrongly, it says if above Grade 5 in the instrument, no need audition?

I was told audition is MUST regardless what grade you are.

[phankao]

Xnowy:

phankao:

[quote=\"Xnowy\"]
my friend's DS is taking PIPA at his primary school and the father went down to DHS and HC, they told him he can try DSA as long as the school result above 80% (overall). and what he told me is no need to sit for any academic test which i am very surprised . will know more next month because the DSA selection will start very soon.

I think it says on last year's DHS' DSA webpage that if below 80% average, then need to take GAT. Above, no need to take GAT. And if I didn't read wrongly, it says if above Grade 5 in the instrument, no need audition?

I was told audition is MUST regardless what grade you are.[/quote]Perhaps. But I read and re-read the DSA webpage many times last year to ascertain, and if I'm not mistaken, it was different from the year before too. We'll just have to see what criteria they have for this year then.

HCI usually need to do gAT plus several subject tests. You sure no need to do? But the DSA website never says anything about CO DSA.

[phankao]

mommyNg:

Does your ds take chinese instrumental exam? Maybe I should get my dd to pick up her violin again! She dropped it after she picked up pipa. Not that she wanted to drop, but she wasn't too keen on practising violin and I din want to waste money and time on both instruments. Maybe at least get her back playing leisurely...?

Your dd now p5? If she was younger, can ask her to take competitions.

[Xnowy]

yes, Nothing about CO at DSA website, my friend went to the HCI and DHS personally to ask. I was very surprised when he told me no test have to be done. hope he interpreted the msg correctly. :shock:

[sleepy]

Hi, need experienced parents advice


My dd joined CO for a year. However, the external teacher her school enaged for them was not teaching well in my opinion. So I've withdrawn her from CO and engaged a music teacher for my dd to learn privately instead.

Can my dd still apply for DSA using that CO instrument at P6 even though she wasn't in CO? ie. prepared to join Sec Sch CO if admitted via DSA

If she can play means can play right? Is ABRSM cert sufficient proof?
Or she must be physically in primary school CO in order to apply for DSA?

Alternatively, should she re-join CO at P5 just to clock partcipation in SYF? Is it necessary?

[mommyNg]

phankao:

Your dd now p5? If she was younger, can ask her to take competitions.

She is P3 this year. Thanks for your advice! It starts me thinking that I shd perhaps encourage her to go for competition next year (it's biennial right?). But my dd, hor, a bit scaredy cat, so dunno whether she'll be ok?

Wah, ur ds grade 8 or 9 this year, must be playing very well! :celebrate:

I'm sure he'll be successful in his DSA! Is Grade 9 the max grade for NAFA/CCM? My dd tchr said it's possible for her to finish grade 9 (max b4 diploma for NUS/CFA) by P6, so we'll see how lah. Do share with us your ds experience in DSA and other stories u may hear!!

[phankao]

mommyNg:

phankao:

Your dd now p5? If she was younger, can ask her to take competitions.

She is P3 this year. Thanks for your advice! It starts me thinking that I shd perhaps encourage her to go for competition next year (it's biennial right?). But my dd, hor, a bit scaredy cat, so dunno whether she'll be ok?

Wah, ur ds grade 8 or 9 this year, must be playing very well! :celebrate:

I'm sure he'll be successful in his DSA! Is Grade 9 the max grade for NAFA/CCM? My dd tchr said it's possible for her to finish grade 9 (max b4 diploma for NUS/CFA) by P6, so we'll see how lah. Do share with us your ds experience in DSA and other stories u may hear!!

Oh, p3, can, can join competition next year and in p6, but in p6, it would be after psle, so joining the competition would not be for DSA already, but for personal satisfaction. haha. Yes, ds is not too bad, and yes, grade 9 is the highest grade, and then there's diploma(grade 10).