CMA Math - Discussion
-
Busymom:
U know she has mastered it when u see her starring at the string of numbers on her worksheet, u thought she is day dreaming and ask her \"are u doing yr work?\", she answer \"of course.\" and writes the answer down. Haha!!Actually, I also have questions to ask. My daughter has been on CMA for about a year now. We let her do it at her own pace with the once-a-week class as she has many other activities as well. How do you define \"master it\"? At what stage would one consider as having mastered it?
Before we sign her up for abacus, a lot of people told us that their kids had gone through it (may not be CMA but some other abacus lessons in the market), but found it to be a waste of time as the kids eventually gave up half way. What's your take on this and any advice for parents here to make sure that their children would not 半途而废?
As for how to make sure the child don't give up half way, I think it's the same for any new thing or new skill the child is learning. Lots of encouragement and taking interesting in what they are doing. -
Busymom:
We're the same as you... Letting DS1 do abacus once a week at his own pace. So far I think he does fully understand the concepts ie to do mental calculations... Will let him carry on to establish the foundation first... Sometimes we just need to persevere a bit longer let them go thru the process even tho we may not see much results now... But once they 开窍 I think the results will be exponential
Actually, I also have questions to ask. My daughter has been on CMA for about a year now. We let her do it at her own pace with the once-a-week class as she has many other activities as well. How do you define \"master it\"? At what stage would one consider as having mastered it?abacus_trainer:
If the kid only learn the basic for a short period of time and did not master it, he probably will forget it due to lack of practise. For a kid who has mastered it, after quitting the class, he will not forget but his calculation speed will slow down.
Before we sign her up for abacus, a lot of people told us that their kids had gone through it (may not be CMA but some other abacus lessons in the market), but found it to be a waste of time as the kids eventually gave up half way. What's your take on this and any advice for parents here to make sure that their children would not 半途而废?
-
abacus_trainer:
I know you are going to say it varies from child to child, but based on what you have seen or experienced, how long does it take to come this stage that you have described, on the assumption that the child goes to CMA once a week? Just an average will do, for me to be mentally prepared... If you tell me that it would take 6 years, think I will :faint:[U know she has mastered it when u see her starring at the string of numbers on her worksheet, u thought she is day dreaming and ask her \"are u doing yr work?\", she answer \"of course.\" and writes the answer down. Haha!!
By the way, since you are teaching at Woodlands branch, is that the HQ? If not mistaken, the owner is an old acquaintance (parents of DD's classmate in a particular right-brain enrichment program). Please send them my regards! -
HI! wat abt pri school kids eg P2 & P4! wat will they benefit from cma? Thx :? :?
-
Busymom:
No..no.. I am not from woodlands branch. Wrong guess. :politebleah:I know you are going to say it varies from child to child, but based on what you have seen or experienced, how long does it take to come this stage that you have described, on the assumption that the child goes to CMA once a week? Just an average will do, for me to be mentally prepared... If you tell me that it would take 6 years, think I will :faint:
By the way, since you are teaching at Woodlands branch, is that the HQ? If not mistaken, the owner is an old acquaintance (parents of DD's classmate in a particular right-brain enrichment program). Please send them my regards!
It's hard for me to put a time frame to it. I have naughty students who started later, very playful in class, giving me a headache everyweek, doing better than students who started earlier, hardworking and doing their work diligently. It also depends on the child's talent - \"tian fen\". Don't be dishearten if yr child is not doing as fast as his/her fren, better late or slow than never.
No, it won't take 6yrs. For an average student, rough estimation is around 2yrs. Hope u understand it's hard for me to answer yr question bcos there are many contributing factors to consider. A better person to answer yr question would be yr dd's teacher. -
abacus_trainer:
Hi
No..no.. I am not from woodlands branch. Wrong guess. :politebleah:Busymom:
I know you are going to say it varies from child to child, but based on what you have seen or experienced, how long does it take to come this stage that you have described, on the assumption that the child goes to CMA once a week? Just an average will do, for me to be mentally prepared... If you tell me that it would take 6 years, think I will :faint:
By the way, since you are teaching at Woodlands branch, is that the HQ? If not mistaken, the owner is an old acquaintance (parents of DD's classmate in a particular right-brain enrichment program). Please send them my regards!
It's hard for me to put a time frame to it. I have naughty students who started later, very playful in class, giving me a headache everyweek, doing better than students who started earlier, hardworking and doing their work diligently. It also depends on the child's talent - \"tian fen\". Don't be dishearten if yr child is not doing as fast as his/her fren, better late or slow than never.
No, it won't take 6yrs. For an average student, rough estimation is around 2yrs. Hope u understand it's hard for me to answer yr question bcos there are many contributing factors to consider. A better person to answer yr question would be yr dd's teacher.
1) How to motivate P2 kid to continue CMA course if they start to lack of interest or find boring?
2) Is it too late for P2 to take this course?
3) How it help to relate to their school Maths and how to explain CMA is useful to school Maths as to them it doesn't help as they don't see the relation? -
rcxmum:
HI! wat abt pri school kids eg P2 & P4! wat will they benefit from cma? Thx :? :?
I used to think older children are slower in picking up mental arithmetic bcos their brain is more developed than the younger ones. But some of my students have proven me wrong.
For older child, it helps them to learn visualisation and excercise their right brain. :nunchuk: -
abacus_trainer:
No, it won't take 6yrs. For an average student, rough estimation is around 2yrs.
2 years is really fast. What will it cover in 2 years? Thnx -
abacus_trainer:
Depends on what is your objectives for letting your girl learn abacus. Only to do calculation or for brain development. Some parents ask why learn abacus when my child can use calculator in school? The same reason why we would still go jogging when we have so many other mordern mode of transport (quoting Mr Tay - CMA CEO). Japanese invented the soroban (abacus) and are still teaching their children how to use it. They believe if we rely on using the calculator too much, our brain become \"hazy\".rcxmum:
HI! wat abt pri school kids eg P2 & P4! wat will they benefit from cma?
Ca3kids:
1) How to motivate P2 kid to continue CMA course if they start to lack of interest or find boring?
2) Is it too late for P2 to take this course?
3) How it help to relate to their school Maths and how to explain CMA is useful to school Maths as to them it doesn't help as they don't see the relation?
I feel that abacus is most useful if the child hasn't mastered addition/subtraction yet. In my opinion, seem more suitable for preschoolers, to build a strong foundation in addition & subtraction. Hence abacus meets my objective in that aspect.
Once reach primary school level, I feel that abacus is not quite in sync with MOE's model drawing & heuristic type of questions. You have to coach personally to sync to MOE syllabus.
Nevertheless, abacus does give the child a strong foundation & confidence in Maths -
Dear parents,
I started posting to this thread after reading some encouraging comments from some parents from our centre, about how their kids enjoy their CMA classes. I thought I could help answer some simple abacus related questions like why add hundreds, tens then ones, etc.
I have no experience in child psychology and may not be the right person to answer yr questions. My views do not represent the views of the entire CMA community. I am worried some of my replies may be misinterpreted and backfire.
Think I will have to stop replying. So sorry. :imsorry:
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login4
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects