Logo
    • Education
      • Pre-School
      • Primary Schools Directory
      • Primary Schools Articles
      • P1 Registration
      • DSA
      • PSLE
      • Secondary
      • Tertiary
      • Special Needs
    • Lifestyle
      • Well-being
    • Activities
      • Events
    • Enrichment & Services
      • Find A Service Provider
      • Enrichment Articles
      • Enrichment Services
      • Tuition Centre/Private Tutor
      • Infant Care/ Childcare / Student Care Centre
      • Kindergarten/Preschool
      • Private Institutions and International Schools
      • Special Needs
      • Indoor & Outdoor Playgrounds
      • Paediatrics
      • Neonatal Care
    • Forum
    • ASKQ
    • Register
    • Login

    Q&A - PSLE Science

    Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Primary 6 & PSLE
    2.9k Posts 529 Posters 1.5m Views 1 Watching
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • T
      tianzhu
      last edited by

      James Ang:


      Earthworm lives in soil and feeds on dead leaves, there is no food on the rotting log for the earthworm to feed on, but there are dead leaves in the leaf litter community. That is the intention of the setter. Elimination method is a good way to narrow down the choices to the final correct answer since it is a clear cut question where there is only 1 answer.
      Hi James

      Thanks for helping.I am quite confused.

      Earthworm lives in soil and feeds on dead leaves,

      Do earthworms feed on dead leaves alone?

      1 Reply Last reply
      Reply Quote 0
      • T
        tianzhu
        last edited by

        James Ang:

        Let's use the selection and elimination method to analyse this MCQ question scientifically and objectively.
        The correct answer is bracket fungus for the following reasons (selection)
        1) It is a decomposer.
        2) It is found in both rotting log and leaf litter communities for organic materials to break down into simpler substances to be returned to the environment.
        3) It lives in damp and dark conditions because fungi do not make food.

        The wrong answers are not selected for the following reasons.(elimination)
        1) They are not decomposers.
        2) Earthworm feeds on dead leaves and not rotting log.
        3) Grass and ants are more commonly found in field community.

        Hope the analysis can strengthen the choice of answer in favour of bracket fungus. If there is a better analysis, please step forward for discussion. 😄
        Hi James

        Please clarify why you narrow down Organism A down to decomposer only.Again, I am confused, from MPH PSLE Science Guide, pg 203, earthworm is classified as an organism in rotting log community.

        1 Reply Last reply
        Reply Quote 0
        • J
          James Ang
          last edited by

          generally remember earthworm lives in soil and eat dead leaves;


          below extracts from wikipedia


          Biological. In many soils, earthworms play a major role in converting large pieces of organic matter (e.g. dead leaves) into rich humus, and thus improving soil fertility. This is achieved by the worm's actions of pulling down below any organic matter deposited on the dried dirt, such as leaf fall or manure, either for food or when it needs to plug its burrow. Once in the burrow, the worm will shred the leaf and partially digest it, then mingle it with the earth by saturating

          Special habitats
          While, as the name earthworm suggests, the main habitat of earthworms is in soil, the situation is more complicated than that. The brandling worm Eisenia fetida lives in decaying plant matter and manure. Arctiostrotus vancouverensis from Vancouver Island and the Olympic Peninsula is generally found in decaying conifer logs or in extremely acidic humus. Aporrectodea limicola and Sparganophilus and several others are found in mud in streams. Some species are arboreal. Even in the soil species, there are special habitats, such as soils derived from serpentine which have an earthworm fauna of their own.

          1 Reply Last reply
          Reply Quote 0
          • T
            turquoise
            last edited by

            James Ang:
            Earthworm lives in soil and feeds on dead leaves, there is no food on the rotting log for the earthworm to feed on, but there are dead leaves in the leaf litter community. That is the intention of the setter. Elimination method is a good way to narrow down the choices to the final correct answer since it is a clear cut question where there is only 1 answer.
            James Ang:
            generally remember earthworm lives in soil and eat dead leaves;

            below extracts from wikipedia


            Biological. In many soils, earthworms play a major role in converting large pieces of organic matter (e.g. dead leaves) into rich humus, and thus improving soil fertility. This is achieved by the worm's actions of pulling down below any organic matter deposited on the dried dirt, such as leaf fall or manure, either for food or when it needs to plug its burrow. Once in the burrow, the worm will shred the leaf and partially digest it, then mingle it with the earth by saturating

            Special habitats
            While, as the name earthworm suggests, the main habitat of earthworms is in soil, the situation is more complicated than that. The brandling worm Eisenia fetida lives in decaying plant matter and manure. Arctiostrotus vancouverensis from Vancouver Island and the Olympic Peninsula is generally found in decaying conifer logs or in extremely acidic humus. Aporrectodea limicola and Sparganophilus and several others are found in mud in streams. Some species are arboreal. Even in the soil species, there are special habitats, such as soils derived from serpentine which have an earthworm fauna of their own.
            JamesAng,

            From your wikipedia extracts, earthworms can be found in leaf litter AND rotting log community. So the answer to the question can be earthworms as well.

            1 Reply Last reply
            Reply Quote 0
            • T
              tianzhu
              last edited by

              James Ang:
              generally remember earthworm lives in soil and eat dead leaves;


              below extracts from wikipedia


              Biological. In many soils, earthworms play a major role in converting large pieces of organic matter (e.g. dead leaves) into rich humus, and thus improving soil fertility. This is achieved by the worm's actions of pulling down below any organic matter deposited on the dried dirt, such as leaf fall or manure, either for food or when it needs to plug its burrow. Once in the burrow, the worm will shred the leaf and partially digest it, then mingle it with the earth by saturating

              Special habitats
              While, as the name earthworm suggests, the main habitat of earthworms is in soil, the situation is more complicated than that. The brandling worm Eisenia fetida lives in decaying plant matter and manure. Arctiostrotus vancouverensis from Vancouver Island and the Olympic Peninsula is generally found in decaying conifer logs or in extremely acidic humus. Aporrectodea limicola and Sparganophilus and several others are found in mud in streams. Some species are arboreal. Even in the soil species, there are special habitats, such as soils derived from serpentine which have an earthworm fauna of their own.

              Hi
              Thank you for your reply.

              In many soils, earthworms play a major role in converting large pieces of organic matter (e.g. dead leaves) into rich humus,

              How does one interpret this sentence? Does it mean that generally earthworms eat dead leaves?
              Organic matters refer to the residues of dead plants and animals in various stages of decomposition as defined in the following links
              http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Organic_matter
              http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/organic_matter

              While, as the name earthworm suggests, the main habitat of earthworms is in soil,
              Yes if you stop here, your answer is justifiable, but about those words after the comma,

              , the situation is more complicated than that. The brandling worm Eisenia fetida lives in decaying plant matter and manure.
              Does this suggest something else?

              For PSLE Science, I think it is very safe to say that earthworms live in rotting log and leaf litter communities. You may refer to i-Science Textbook 6, Pg 95 and 96 and MPH PSLE Science Guide, pg 203

              What I’ve suggested here is some alternative view and will leave it to other parents to exercise their judgement.

              1 Reply Last reply
              Reply Quote 0
              • T
                turquoise
                last edited by

                tianzhu, looks like you and I posted at the same time about the same topic. 🙂


                I am more inclined to believe that the correct answer is earthworms rather than bracket fungus.

                1 Reply Last reply
                Reply Quote 0
                • JoyJ
                  Joy
                  last edited by

                  Hi


                  Thanks for the reply.Yes,indeed tough to guide a 10-12 years old kids on science.Just wonder what is the best way to guide or anyone out there can teach or impart...

                  I yet to come across anyone that is good in teaching this subject esp the application part.

                  Thanks for sharing the web.

                  rgds
                  Joy

                  tianzhu:
                  Joy:

                  I read with great interest in this psle sci topic...

                  Just wonder, many a time, when we guide our child to do application questions on sci, its the concept or application skill that our child really need to have?

                  Hi

                  I think scientific concepts and application skills are closely intertwined, just like husband and wife. The home’s peace and harmony is inextricably intertwined with the integration of the family members living closely together.

                  With the demands of the newer trend of Higher Order thinking questions, it is no longer enough to know or memorise facts.To do well in Science, you need to be able applying concepts to a new situation and give relevant answers that connect to the situation in the question. It is not an easy skill to be taught to a 12 years old kid.

                  I find the briefing session for parents in St Anthony’s Primary School ( http://anthonian.edu.sg/)
                  useful. Hope you’ll also find it meaningful.

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  Reply Quote 0
                  • J
                    James Ang
                    last edited by

                    tianzhu:
                    James Ang:

                    generally remember earthworm lives in soil and eat dead leaves;


                    below extracts from wikipedia


                    Biological. In many soils, earthworms play a major role in converting large pieces of organic matter (e.g. dead leaves) into rich humus, and thus improving soil fertility. This is achieved by the worm's actions of pulling down below any organic matter deposited on the dried dirt, such as leaf fall or manure, either for food or when it needs to plug its burrow. Once in the burrow, the worm will shred the leaf and partially digest it, then mingle it with the earth by saturating

                    Special habitats
                    While, as the name earthworm suggests, the main habitat of earthworms is in soil, the situation is more complicated than that. The brandling worm Eisenia fetida lives in decaying plant matter and manure. Arctiostrotus vancouverensis from Vancouver Island and the Olympic Peninsula is generally found in decaying conifer logs or in extremely acidic humus. Aporrectodea limicola and Sparganophilus and several others are found in mud in streams. Some species are arboreal. Even in the soil species, there are special habitats, such as soils derived from serpentine which have an earthworm fauna of their own.


                    Hi
                    Thank you for your reply.

                    In many soils, earthworms play a major role in converting large pieces of organic matter (e.g. dead leaves) into rich humus,

                    How does one interpret this sentence? Does it mean that generally earthworms eat dead leaves?
                    Organic matters refer to the residues of dead plants and animals in various stages of decomposition as defined in the following links
                    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Organic_matter
                    http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/organic_matter

                    While, as the name earthworm suggests, the main habitat of earthworms is in soil,
                    Yes if you stop here, your answer is justifiable, but about those words after the comma,

                    , the situation is more complicated than that. The brandling worm Eisenia fetida lives in decaying plant matter and manure.
                    Does this suggest something else?

                    For PSLE Science, I think it is very safe to say that earthworms live in rotting log and leaf litter communities. You may refer to i-Science Textbook 6, Pg 95 and 96 and MPH PSLE Science Guide, pg 203

                    What I’ve suggested here is some alternative view and will leave it to other parents to exercise their judgement.

                    I agree with your open minded approach to science as this is the true spirit of science inquiry.

                    In this situation, the question has to be referred to setter. The setter's intention could be wrong and he should not put two answers into one question. 😄 Anyway, there is no perfect question all the time, but generally PSLE questions aree tested with a sample of students and maybe a focus group is carried out, prior to the release for exam. Assessment book writers do not carry out a testing as rigorous as national exam questions.

                    1 Reply Last reply
                    Reply Quote 0
                    • T
                      tianzhu
                      last edited by

                      turquoise:
                      tianzhu, looks like you and I posted at the same time about the same topic. 🙂


                      I am more inclined to believe that the correct answer is earthworms rather than bracket fungus.
                      Hi
                      Thank you for your response.

                      After further reading, I think I am now in a better position to explain why option(4) is the most suitable answer.

                      Organism A is most commonly found in leaf litter and rotting log community.

                      The question asked for Organism A which is commonly found in leaf litter and rotting log community.The key point is commonly found in leaf litter and rotting log community. Earthworms can be found in field and garden community, drains and houses besides leaf litter and rotting log community. As this question narrow down to leaf litter and rotting log community, I think option (4) is more suitable.

                      For the second question, from Google searches, one knows that earthworms can reproduce sexually and asexually. But you’ve brought an interesting point from your child’s teacher. I’ll ask my boy to check, but I know it’ll take ages. Either his teacher is busy or he is busy, I have a problem here, he doesn’t like me to approach his teacher directly. So, even though I have tons of question, I have to exercise restraints in asking his teacher directly for the sake of father son bonding. Luckily, the KSP forum allows me an alternative outlet to seek clarification.

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      Reply Quote 0
                      • T
                        turquoise
                        last edited by

                        tianzhu:
                        Hi

                        Thank you for your response.

                        After further reading, I think I am now in a better position to explain why option(4) is the most suitable answer.

                        Organism A is most commonly found in leaf litter and rotting log community.

                        The question asked for Organism A which is commonly found in leaf litter and rotting log community.The key point is commonly found in leaf litter and rotting log community. Earthworms can be found in field and garden community, drains and houses besides leaf litter and rotting log community. As this question narrow down to leaf litter and rotting log community, I think option (4) is more suitable.
                        Hi tianzhu,

                        I see your point as to why bracket fungus is a suitable answer.

                        I also believe the person who set the question made it too ambiguous by including both possible answers. Imagine us debating this question over a couple of days. If this had been a PSLE question, the children would not have had the luxury of time and google to check their answers.

                        1 Reply Last reply
                        Reply Quote 0

                        Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

                        Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

                        With your input, this post could be even better 💗

                        Register Login
                        • 1
                        • 2
                        • 21
                        • 22
                        • 23
                        • 24
                        • 25
                        • 288
                        • 289
                        • 23 / 289
                        • First post
                          Last post



                        Online Users

                        Statistics

                        11

                        Online

                        211.4k

                        Users

                        34.6k

                        Topics

                        1.8m

                        Posts
                        Apps Shared on Our Forum

                        Maths

                        Ruiya.ai
                        math support
                        →
                        Tallytide
                        P1-P6 maths app
                        →
                        MugCorner
                        Sec 1-4 maths practice
                        →

                        English

                        tutor.agenticolab.com
                        P1-6 English portal
                        →
                        wordwizards.sg
                        English practice
                        →
                        Ashton English
                        P4-Sec 4 English practice
                        →

                        Chinese

                        chinese.getbuzzi.com
                        P1-P6 Chinese
                        →
                        Wonder Chinese
                        P1-P6 Chinese writing
                        →
                        Xiaozhu Free trial
                        Mandarin chat buddy
                        →

                        Multiple subjects

                        Pickytic.ai
                        AI study buddy for pri and sec
                        →

                          About Us Contact Us global:forum Terms of Service Privacy Policy