Why do you have to be like the others?
-
acforfamily:
acforfamily, I am sure you can. Its just the mentality inside each of us. I want my child to be different from others not purely in terms of academic performance but on how to handle problems, setbacks, how to present herself.
How I wish there are more parents like you.
......
It is a long, long route for them in life, why stress them so much?
That day, she had an interview by a teacher on selection to go for a compeition. She was asked by the teacher \"Tell me, why I must choose you and not XXX to go ?\" I am quite pleased with her answer. After that, we had a family discussion again, on her answer. Both me and hubby suggested our \"better\" version of answers. But mine was being \"bomb\" and rejected because it sounded too agressive and overpraise of oneself. My hubby's one was acceptable by all of us.
-
I watched that video. So touching & very inspiring
-
I'm also trying hard not to stress my kids too much in terms of academic enrichment. But I do try to balance that with helping them achive their potential, cos I do not want them to be under-achievers too. So far DS1 and DD2 are not attending any academic enrichment. DS1 just started arts lessons. I try to read with them, and do some worksheets with DS1 on nightly basis, to instil discipline in him.
Weekends are mainly reserved for family outings, or rest and relax. No crammed schedule, as they need a rest, and so do we :lol: -
i’ve mentioned in the forum before… that why not we try to discover what our children really would like to do and provide the means or opportunity to achieve those dreams?
alas… we are in a forum whose title speaks for itself…
i for one would like to know if my p5 son who is undergoing rigorous, never ending work to prepare for his exams this year, wants to do anything that he really likes…
the sad thing is that he simply has no time to even give it a think… -
mckenzy:
mckenzy, I disagree...we're KSP's coz we are KS in being good parents in bringing up our kids. The topics described here extend beyond the academics thankfully.
alas... we are in a forum whose title speaks for itself...
My gals have only swimming and dance as part of their out-side-of school curriculum, perhaps some music and drama at school (beyond school hours)...not the \"usual\" hothousing enrichments but we go to places with the children and aspire to expose them to different ways of dealing with others.
From the other forummers on this post, who are thankfully like-minded
, we all agree goes to the development of the child as a wholistic person
:love:
-
The ads reminded me of Beethoven who continued with his music long after he lost his hearing. :love:
Why do we follows the other? Maybe we are afraid of our kids losing out or to see our kids struggle daily in school or simply making sure that our kids potential is fully realize?
Having said this, I'm still frozen in thoughts deciding which way to go. To follow or to just let it be. Well, I guess, I still needed time to think it through
-
Right now my kids only attend one chinese enrichment class, which I plan to stop when they finish K2. They will not have any tuition in future.
I believe in teaching them to read very well, then they will naturally know how to write. By teaching them the most important skills of reading and writing, they will be well prepared for a life of learning ahead of them.
Instead of doing assessments and attending enrichment classes, they are reading all the wonderful children’s classics, as well as children’s encyclopedia. They are learning a wide variety of knowledge, as well as the beautiful style of writing of famous authors, and building up their vocabulary along the way. They are free to write anything that comes to their mind. Most importantly, they enjoy reading the books.
Kids can still have a happy and intellectually enriching childhood. -
for discussion, let me give a different perspective and some of my personal views:
acforfamily:
let me guess....is the student in a 'popular' school? would things be different if the parents have opt for a neighbourhood school?I thought that I could be a parent who would let the kid progress without tuition or extra classes, only to be told by the school that he has to perform better. I was naive enough to think that the school would only expect the students to know only things that have been taught.
acforfamily:
don't have to wait for teacher to give out sample compos. take a trip down to Popular Bookstore. Flip through 'Model Compositions for P1' will bring sweat trickling down your forehead; do most students really write that well?Imagine my horror when the teacher gave out sample compositions done by fellow classmates that indicated the use of vocab and phrases way beyond their years.
acforfamily:
the schools did so cos MOE does that too; see the recent PSLE. the phenomenal of average students going for enrichment classes to push up the standard seems to be confined to popular schools - correct me if i am wrong. that boils down to the same question; the quest of parents yearly to seek limited vacancies in 'premium' schools, they should go in with their eyes open and not blame the system if they want to partake in it.We seem to be living in a vicious circle. The schools set more and more difficult questions to differentiate the really good students. The average students find the questions difficult and go for enrichment classes, thus pushing up the standard. So the school has to set even more difficult questions.....
acforfamily:
how can we compare current generation with ours? we have to look at relativity. the system will always value meritocracy. those who do not want to jump on the enrichment bandwagons have to look at motivating their own children to take ownership of their own studies and also adjust their own expectations; accept effort rather than results, and accept that those with enrichment background is likely to have a better advantage than those who doesn't.We send our children to enrichment classes, tuition etc in the hope that they do not fall behind their cohort. But how many of us in our age group survived without tuition / extra classes? Aren't we all still doing well?
What would happen if one day, everyone stops going for all these extra lessons? Would we be worse off?
on another note, looking at ourselves, if 90% of your colleagues don't knock off at 6pm sharp, wouldn't you choose to be like them? -
One thing we can do, is to stop comparing results.
In fact, I hope that MOE disallows primary schools to rank their students in terms of academic results. Every educator is talking about instilling a love of learning in our children. Then why bother ranking the students ? Is there really a big difference between a student that scores 90 marks, and another student who scores 99 marks ?
What is the advantage of identifying the top student ? So that he/she can get a prize ?
Children should learn because they love to learn. Not because they want to be the top student in class. -
tamarind:
Sooner or later they will compare anyway. Competition spurs progress.One thing we can do, is to stop comparing results.
In fact, I hope that MOE disallows primary schools to rank their students in terms of academic results. Every educator is talking about instilling a love of learning in our children. Then why bother ranking the students ? Is there really a big difference between a student that scores 90 marks, and another student who scores 99 marks ?
What is the advantage of identifying the top student ? So that he/she can get a prize ?
Children should learn because they love to learn. Not because they want to be the top student in class.
Some children genuinely love to learn, but most love to just play, fool around or just do nothing. That's human nature. Stress in appropriate amounts drive progress.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login2
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects