2011 PSLE Discussions and Strategy
-
BusyB:
Mmmmm....but I heard school is taking in appeal and charging admin fee for appeal??? :scratchhead: If they are not allowed to transfer, shouldn't the school not be accepting appeal??? :scratchhead:[/quote]This is for those who got a CO and accepted the CO during the DSA exercise. They're not allowed to appeal to another school. That's the MOE directive. So if the school is accepting appeals it's going against the MOE directive.
That is correct.jtoh:
[quote=\"jalanbaby\"]Hi all,
i heard that there is a new MOE ruling this year and indicates that students who are successful in DSA WILL NOT be allowed to be transferred to another school.
Any KSP aware of this, and does this imply that students who take up CO cannot appeal to another school?
Advice will be much appreciated..... Thanks!!!! -
jalanbaby:
I have heard of that MOE ruling too, and have also heard of many DSA COs rushing to their preferred school to submit appeal forms. So how much enforcement of that ruling remains to be seen..... :evil:Hi all,
i heard that there is a new MOE ruling this year and indicates that students who are successful in DSA WILL NOT be allowed to be transferred to another school.
Any KSP aware of this, and does this imply that students who take up CO cannot appeal to another school?
Advice will be much appreciated..... Thanks!!!! -
jtoh:
:thankyou: jtoh
Hi tehsusu,tehsusu:
Hi Jtoh, hv read a lot in this thread and u hv helped to answer most queries.
I need your help. May i ask if someone has been accepted by NUSH
phase 2 (results of application will be made known 16/12).
Thereafter (21/12)received S1 posting, and decided not to take up NUSH. Does that means the vacancy will be left for those who appeal?
By applying to NUSH,does one lessen the chance of getting the 1st choice of our sch? thank u very much!
NUSH conducts its admission separately from the S1 Posting so applying to one will not affect your chances in the other. After you receive both results, you can choose which one to accept. But I think there's a time period within which you have to accept NUSH' offer. I can't recall if this is before the S1 Central Posting releases its results. If that's the case you'll have to accept/decline NUSH' offer before knowing the results of your S1 posting. Maybe some NUSH parent can clarify.
NUSH has full discretion over the intake of its students. So whether it releases the new vacancy to those appealing or not is entirely up to the school. In the past NUSH has chosen not to take its full intake of students, choosing only the top students into its fold. -
jtoh:
Jtoh, I'm confused. So who are the ones appealing to schools now? Aren't they the ones who have accepted COs and now changed mind to appeal to their preferred schools? S1 posting results not out yet, so no reason for this batch to start appealing :scratchhead:
This is for those who got a CO and accepted the CO during the DSA exercise. They're not allowed to appeal to another school. That's the MOE directive. So if the school is accepting appeals it's going against the MOE directive.
This appeal exercise is getting very confusing as everyone seems to be doing \"short-cut\"
-
MummySTay:
MummySTay, voluptuous??? :oops: :oops: :oops:
Hi Sunj1252, curious to know why you call vlim and Pen \"Master\". Don't you know one is a sexy hippo while the other is a voluptuous panda and both are Mummies? :evil:
Unlike Vlim, I can't dive underwater to hide, I better go deep into the bamboo forest to hide :rotflmao: :rotflmao: :rotflmao: -
Pen88n:
:rotflmao: :rotflmao:
MummySTay, voluptuous??? :oops: :oops: :oops:MummySTay:
Hi Sunj1252, curious to know why you call vlim and Pen \"Master\". Don't you know one is a sexy hippo while the other is a voluptuous panda and both are Mummies? :evil:
Unlike Vlim, I can't dive underwater to hide, I better go deep into the bamboo forest to hide :rotflmao: :rotflmao: :rotflmao:
Cannot repeat \"sexy\" mah, so used \"voluptuous\" lor! Apparently, vlim is happy with the tag and is not complaining.
:evil:
-
Pen88n:
MOE sent out a directive to all DSA schools that once a student has accepted a CO, he/she will not be allowed to appeal to another school after PSLE results are out. This was hinted at in our forum a couple of months ago when parents posted about it after attending a briefing at HCI and another school.
Jtoh, I'm confused. So who are the ones appealing to schools now? Aren't they the ones who have accepted COs and now changed mind to appeal to their preferred schools? S1 posting results not out yet, so no reason for this batch to start appealing :scratchhead:jtoh:
This is for those who got a CO and accepted the CO during the DSA exercise. They're not allowed to appeal to another school. That's the MOE directive. So if the school is accepting appeals it's going against the MOE directive.
This appeal exercise is getting very confusing as everyone seems to be doing \"short-cut\"
This is actually not new. It's always been the case that once you accept a DSA CO you're not allowed to change your mind. But through the years schools have accepted appeals and MOE has turned a blind eye to it. Until this year I guess when they sent out a directive again. It appears that some schools are accepting appeals from students with COs from other schools. We'll have to see how MOE deals with the recalcitrant schools.
So this appeal thing is for the DSA CO students only. Not for students who were unsuccessful at DSA or who are taking part in the S1 Posting. -
Hi Parents,
For those who got 200-210 range, can I know how are the grades like ?
My ds will be taking PLSE next year and his results are just mediocre. So I like to roughly gauge his results.
Many thanks. -
Pen88n:
Yes, the appeal process is very confusing. For e.g.
Jtoh, I'm confused. So who are the ones appealing to schools now? Aren't they the ones who have accepted COs and now changed mind to appeal to their preferred schools? S1 posting results not out yet, so no reason for this batch to start appealing :scratchhead:jtoh:
This is for those who got a CO and accepted the CO during the DSA exercise. They're not allowed to appeal to another school. That's the MOE directive. So if the school is accepting appeals it's going against the MOE directive.
This appeal exercise is getting very confusing as everyone seems to be doing \"short-cut\"
Example One
1) A student who has CO from ACS(I) and exercised the CO. So no S1 posting form. However, he scored 259 for his PSLE. Now he feels like he has a chance to go to RI as the COP for RI (year 2010 PSLE) was 259. So he appeals to RI and HCI also as he preferred RI and HCI then ACS(I). Can RI and HCI accept that? Based on past yearsβ experience, most of the successful appeal case for those students who have already gotten CO from other schools need a few points above the COP to be accepted.
Example Two
1) A student who was a GEPper and has WL for RI. Exercised the WL but not accepted. He scored 252 for his PSLE. He has S1 posting form on hand. The best part is that, he wants to appeal to RI and RI allows this student to appeal without putting RI as the 1st choice or any choice in the S1 posting form. That's mean anyone can appeal to RI without putting RI as any choice in the S1 option form. This is a win-win situation. RI charge $20 for each appeal case, charge another $50 for GAT if not taken during DSA exercise
That means anyone who are interested to appeal to RI would go to the following web site to apply.
http://admissions.ri.edu.sg/
The whole S1 form application, DSA and appeal case are so confusing...... -
2ppaamm:
Just dive under water, sure no problem.[/quote]Or hide behind hippo, like papa ostrich.. :rotflmao:
Better still, look for hippo's DS.TwaTau:
[quote=\"Pen88n\"]
RI Principal will be personally looking for the notti hippo......blacklisted!!! :rotflmao: :rotflmao: :rotflmao:
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better π
Register Login72
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects