Logo
    • Education
      • Pre-School
      • Primary Schools Directory
      • Primary Schools Articles
      • P1 Registration
      • DSA
      • PSLE
      • Secondary
      • Tertiary
      • Special Needs
    • Lifestyle
      • Well-being
    • Activities
      • Events
    • Enrichment & Services
      • Find A Service Provider
      • Enrichment Articles
      • Enrichment Services
      • Tuition Centre/Private Tutor
      • Infant Care/ Childcare / Student Care Centre
      • Kindergarten/Preschool
      • Private Institutions and International Schools
      • Special Needs
      • Indoor & Outdoor Playgrounds
      • Paediatrics
      • Neonatal Care
    • Forum
    • ASKQ
    • Register
    • Login

    Why do you have to be like the others?

    Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Recess Time
    33 Posts 18 Posters 10.7k Views 1 Watching
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • T
      tamarind
      last edited by

      skunk:

      Sooner or later they will compare anyway. Competition spurs progress.

      Some children genuinely love to learn, but most love to just play, fool around or just do nothing. That's human nature. Stress in appropriate amounts drive progress.
      I agree that competition spurs progress. I think it is fine to have ranking in secondary schools and above. If we want our kids to enjoy their childhood, and to really love learning, then there should not be any ranking of students in primary schools.

      The students will still know their grades in each subject, so they know how well they are doing and whether they have made improvements. I think this is enough stress. There is no need to rank from number 1 to 40. If the teachers really need to know, they can still rank the students but keep the information to themselves only. There is no need to release the information to the parents.

      I have heard of a student who was ranked number 3 in one of the top primary school. She went around telling her friends that her parents would be very mad with her because she did not get the number 1 position.

      The problem is that the stress is no longer in appropriate amounts in primary schools.

      The fact is that, in universities, polytechnics, and junior colleges, there are no ranking of students. I do not see any advantage in ranking students in primary schools.

      1 Reply Last reply
      Reply Quote 0
      • S
        skunk
        last edited by

        tamarind:

        I have heard of a student who was ranked number 3 in one of the top primary school. She went around telling her friends that her parents would be very mad with her because she did not get the number 1 position.

        The problem is that the stress is no longer in appropriate amounts in primary schools.
        The problem doesn't lie with the system, it lies with human nature.

        Even without open ranking, people who like to stress themselves in inappropriate amounts, will go around comparing no matter what, while those who like to run away from stress instead of facing up to it will have yet another excuse to run away from it all.

        Don't say primary school, even toddlers compare toys and ability, the kid who can climb the highest on the monkey ropes, certainly earn some sort of admiration from some other kids, while the one who doesn't care, will \"escape\" the stress of such comparison but might never learn to climb the monkey ropes.

        From the way i see it, it's a problem that cannot be simply overcome by mere changes in policy. Everyone must learn to handle it in their own way, but one thing is for sure, running away from it ain't gonna solve anything.

        1 Reply Last reply
        Reply Quote 0
        • M
          mummy of 2
          last edited by

          Sometimes I wonder who is driving all these comparison? Is it the schools or the parents? From what some of you describe, it’s the parents who want to know how good the school is (in terms of academic results) and put pressure on kids. Of cos some stress is good, as it will motivate the kids to try harder, but beyond a certain point, I think it’s counter-productive. Maybe it’s easy for me to say all these as my kids are still pre-schoolers but I do hope I can retain my perspective and strive for a balanced approach even when my kids start school. JMHO.

          1 Reply Last reply
          Reply Quote 0
          • T
            tamarind
            last edited by

            We must all remember that primary school is the place where we can cultivate a genuine love for learning in children. Competition is not going to make a child love to learn.


            Changes in policy can help a big deal. If the parent don’t know exactly who is number 1, 2, 3, or 4, then
            there is no need to push their kids to get that few more marks just to be better than the rest. A child getting very depressed because he scores 3 marks less than than the number 1 kid, is really not healthy. This is much worst than comparing toys and ability. The truth is that a child who scores 3 marks less than another child in maths, does not necessarily mean that he is less clever ! In polytechnics and universities, students only know their grades, not their exact marks.

            There is no harm having competition only after 12 years old. In fact, there are many children who are late developers, and they will reach their maximum potential only when they are teenagers.

            I remember reading that in China and Canada, there is no ranking of students in primary school.

            I wonder why is it that so many parents complain about the stress in our education. But no parents want to do anything about it.

            It is not that I am scared of competition. I used to be the number 1 student every year in my primary school (an average school). I still do not see how ranking can develop a love of learning in kids. In fact, too much competition is going to have adverse effects on the child, and may cause him to develop emotional problems.

            1 Reply Last reply
            Reply Quote 0
            • F
              Fluffy
              last edited by

              I am surprised that there are primary schools still adopting the ranking of all the students. I thought that school only practise rewarding top few students in class or cohort. I think this is healthy to encourage other students to work harder and to recognise students’ efforts. It is quite unhealthy to rank everybody especially for the students who are in the last few ranks of the class, they will feel very demoralise and embarass.


              When my son was diagnosed with special needs, my sister in law tried to persuade us to bring him to Canada where she migrated. She feels that the education system in Canada is more supportive of special needs students and there are no excessive pressure to excel among the students and parents. Students who are talented in certain academic subjects, arts, music or sports are given opportunity to focus on the discipline they are keen and wish to develop and progress at advance level.

              In Singapore, the education system is such that if you are in GEP, you are deemed to be gifted in all subjects and have to persue all subjects at a much advance and indepth level. In main stream, students have to be all rounded as this is reflected in the PSLE scoring system. Unfortunately, I have spoken to numerous parents who feel that their children have to spend more time working hard on the weaker subject at the expense of the subject they are more interested to develop further. I believe this education system may be one of the factor that driven many parents to engage tutors and enrol their children in enrichment classes. Basically, parents may not believe that the school is doing enough to help their children and perhaps this is another form of outsourcing help for their children especially both parents work long hours these days.

              1 Reply Last reply
              Reply Quote 0
              • T
                tamarind
                last edited by

                The top few students should spend more time developing in other areas which they are interested in, like arts, music, sports, etc. They should also gain a wide range of knowledge, instead of spending all their time doing countless assessment books of the same subject, just so that they can get perfect marks.


                What is the use of having tops students with perfect scores, when they don't know anything else that is not examinable ?

                I remember a couple of years back, a mainland Chinese student studying in Singapore, commented that Singaporean students are stupid. I believe he meant that our children are not \"street smart\", and I have to agree that this is true.


                [quote]Basically, parents may not believe that the school is doing enough to help their children and perhaps this is another form of outsourcing help for their children especially both parents work long hours these days.[/quote]I heard in this forum, that students who score between 80 - 90 marks are told by the school that they need tuition teachers. How can 80+ marks be considered weak ? But if the whole class gets 90+ marks and above, then the child is weak compared to the rest. Is this kind of comparison really healthy ?

                I heard somewhere that a child was sent to the Learning Lab to improve on her English. Her score was 96 out of 100 marks !!!

                1 Reply Last reply
                Reply Quote 0
                • R
                  radiantmum
                  last edited by

                  Fluffy:
                  In Singapore, the education system is such that if you are in GEP, you are deemed to be gifted in all subjects and have to persue all subjects at a much advance and indepth level. In main stream, students have to be all rounded as this is reflected in the PSLE scoring system. Unfortunately, I have spoken to numerous parents who feel that their children have to spend more time working hard on the weaker subject at the expense of the subject they are more interested to develop further. I believe this education system may be one of the factor that driven many parents to engage tutors and enrol their children in enrichment classes. Basically, parents may not believe that the school is doing enough to help their children and perhaps this is another form of outsourcing help for their children especially both parents work long hours these days.

                  In US education system, kids are encouraged to focus and develop on their strengths. In S'pore's, kids are asked to work on the \"weaker\" subjects. Which comes more naturally and which will go further?
                  😐

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  Reply Quote 0
                  • P
                    pea
                    last edited by

                    radiantmum:
                    Fluffy:

                    In Singapore, the education system is such that if you are in GEP, you are deemed to be gifted in all subjects and have to persue all subjects at a much advance and indepth level. In main stream, students have to be all rounded as this is reflected in the PSLE scoring system. Unfortunately, I have spoken to numerous parents who feel that their children have to spend more time working hard on the weaker subject at the expense of the subject they are more interested to develop further. I believe this education system may be one of the factor that driven many parents to engage tutors and enrol their children in enrichment classes. Basically, parents may not believe that the school is doing enough to help their children and perhaps this is another form of outsourcing help for their children especially both parents work long hours these days.


                    In US education system, kids are encouraged to focus and develop on their strengths. In S'pore's, kids are asked to work on the \"weaker\" subjects. Which comes more naturally and which will go further?
                    😐

                    Not just in US. I read somewhere that some Scandinavian countries also have something very different from here - very little emphasis on exams in the early years. And they produce great scientists and researchers.

                    Well, at least MOE is doing away with exams for P1 and P2 soon.

                    1 Reply Last reply
                    Reply Quote 0
                    • F
                      Fluffy
                      last edited by

                      tamarind:
                      The top few students should spend more time developing in other areas which they are interested in, like arts, music, sports, etc. They should also gain a wide range of knowledge, instead of spending all their time doing countless assessment books of the same subject, just so that they can get perfect marks.

                      My mum was not educated and she wanted to give me and siblings good education. However, she never pressure us to be top in class but she expected us to read widely and gain more knowledge. She saved to buy us a set of encyclopedia and encouraged us to read the newspaper for current affairs. I started earning my own pocket money every holiday since 13 years old and on reflection, I gain alot of experience and was more \"street smart\" than the average teenagers. By the time I graduated and started working in a MNC, I was able to handle human relationship in the office better than most colleagues. I enjoyed healthy relationship with both people of my age and higher level management.

                      Children nowadays are told to focus on their study and nothing else by parents, teachers and society! Is that healthy? Many lack \"Life Skills\". I fear for the next generation!

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      Reply Quote 0
                      • M
                        mckenzy
                        last edited by

                        This could also be one reason why so many singaporeans with average-ability kids want to migrate.


                        it is definitely policy. you hardly find this kind of crazy Primary level grading in developed countries…

                        i was talking to my wife about it last night… (she’s so stressed for my P5 son)…
                        she’s a teacher and she can’t figure out quite a number of the solutions to the P5 math this year… i was telling her… someone up there amongst the govt is not paying enough attention to this…

                        sure, our primary resource is people in this country… but if you develop so many academically proficient citizens with this type of educational system, what will you eventually churn out? you think they’re gonna want to work in Resorts World?

                        1 Reply Last reply
                        Reply Quote 0

                        Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

                        Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

                        With your input, this post could be even better 💗

                        Register Login
                        • 1
                        • 2
                        • 3
                        • 4
                        • 2 / 4
                        • First post
                          Last post



                        Online Users
                        celineyapC
                        celineyap

                        Statistics

                        1

                        Online

                        211.4k

                        Users

                        34.6k

                        Topics

                        1.8m

                        Posts
                        Apps Shared on Our Forum

                        Maths

                        Ruiya.ai
                        math support
                        →
                        Tallytide
                        P1-P6 maths app
                        →
                        MugCorner
                        Sec 1-4 maths practice
                        →

                        English

                        tutor.agenticolab.com
                        P1-6 English portal
                        →
                        wordwizards.sg
                        English practice
                        →
                        Ashton English
                        P4-Sec 4 English practice
                        →

                        Chinese

                        chinese.getbuzzi.com
                        P1-P6 Chinese
                        →
                        Wonder Chinese
                        P1-P6 Chinese writing
                        →
                        Xiaozhu Free trial
                        Mandarin chat buddy
                        →

                        Multiple subjects

                        Pickytic.ai
                        AI study buddy for pri and sec
                        →

                          About Us Contact Us global:forum Terms of Service Privacy Policy