How to work with insolent children
-
smurf:
I remember I saw news that in some countries, even beat lightly is disallowed. and is consider a criminal act! :shock:
Yeah smurf, that's the same countries who do not believe in capital punishment plus think it's alright to sue your parents for scarring your live permanently with your given name, or haven't given you the best and/or equal opportunity!
For me and DH, discipline is an act of love. We don't wield the cane unless absolutely necessary - and like David59 saidDavid59:
TRUST is important regardless of age....you'd be amazed how much TRUST can make a child FLY WITH CONFIDENCE! :love:A spirit of trust between parents and their teens must be built.
but first they need to learn that it has to be earned...each day, every day! -
IT:
Go ask the school, children nowaday train to be innovative,creative,salesmanship, etc..............Hi
My boy is now 9yo and I notice that he back-talk a lot these days. He wasn't like that last time. Sometimes, he was even louder than us. Some ppl say that's part of growing up, especiall for boys. Is that true? How to overcome that? Pls... I need advice :idea:
Ah!!! Salesmanship------learn to observe n ask question, group discussion...
When the teacher cannot tar han, they complaint to u. Now your kids talk back, u also cannot tar han. Patient n reasoning to him. Listen to his point of view. U may talk louder than him n at the same time explain to him that his behaviour is not acceptable to u. Tell him if he doesn't like people to yell at him, he should not yell at other people especially u r his parent, Hope this will help u. -
Emelyn:
DD used to whine, whimper, mumble, cry, etc. So we told her in a calm manner that we do not understand her when she does that, and therefore cannot respond to her. After a few reminders, we will just ignore her when she does that and give her a few \"knowing\" looks to indicate that she has to speak clearly and politely. When she stops her nonsense, we pay attention to her. It is then up to her to decide whether she wants to \"rephrase\" all that whining, etc into coherent sentences.My 10yo DS1's way of talking back is to cry...... which will then irritate and frustrate DH and I ..... and then a scolding session to ask him to stop crying will start.
We try to tell him...if he has a point to to bring across to us.... TALK, dun just CRY.... because crying will lead to frustration which will then led to scolding...
Sigh.
But, still like that.....sigh sigh sigh
In the beginning, it was trying our patience but we don't show our frustration to her. We just walk away and leave her alone. If we are outdoors, we stay within sight but still keep a distance to indicate our displeasure. After many times, DD got it and will stop the whining, etc. We use the same tactics to deal with her tantrums. Now that she is 7, we let her sulk if she wants to. When she is done (usually after only a few minutes), she will come to us to apologise and be sweet and polite (and willing to negotiate if needed). -
Hi Schellen,
Actually DS1 is not crying because he wants to have his way or get what he wants. We have passed that stage and he knows that whining or crying doesn’t work on us.
He cries when he is upset.
For eg, he ran to the kitchen and along the way, he knocks down DS2. DS2 complained…and we told DS1 not to run and ask him to apologise to DS2. Well… he will then start to cry…and say that he is not at fault… DS2 was in his way…why we always say it is his fault… etc. etc. -
Emelyn:
he ran to the kitchen and along the way, he knocks down DS2. DS2 complained...and we told DS1 not to run and ask him to apologise to DS2. Well.... he will then start to cry...and say that he is not at fault.... DS2 was in his way....why we always say it is his fault.... etc. etc.
:roll: :roll: Emelyn, seems like my DD1 and your DS1 are \"kindled souls\" here. She bursts into tears when accidents like that happen. Seems like lots of angst within themselves; and I've put mine to the fact that there's sibling rivalry. Now we punish them all when there is some form of pre-meditated violence. But if it's an accident like the eg you've given, we do not punish.
Sometimes, its a case of them having to \"grow thick-enough skin\". And crying is a way of getting attention.
Just my 2 cts worth.
-
Emelyn:
OIC. DD does that when she is upset but she doesn't do it non-stop. If she suddenly cries for no apparent reason, we calm her down and console her before finding out the reason why. She will then stop crying and tell us. Most of the times, we'll just ask her what's wrong in a calm and gentle tone and she will stop crying/sniffing so that she can tell us properly.Hi Schellen,
Actually DS1 is not crying because he wants to have his way or get what he wants. We have passed that stage and he knows that whining or crying doesn't work on us.
He cries when he is upset.
For eg, he ran to the kitchen and along the way, he knocks down DS2. DS2 complained...and we told DS1 not to run and ask him to apologise to DS2. Well.... he will then start to cry...and say that he is not at fault.... DS2 was in his way....why we always say it is his fault.... etc. etc. -
[quote]Actually DS1 is not crying because he wants to have his way or get what he wants. We have passed that stage and he knows that whining or crying doesn't work on us.
He cries when he is upset. [/quote]My ds age 8 is also still crying. Not just seeking attention crying. He past that too. When he's too angry to utter a word, he cries. When he tries to stand up for his right but no one takes him seriously he cries. When I told him his action/words hurt my feeling (I gave him a thorough explanation) he cries.
The only different for my ds is that he will tries to explain while wailing or he explain first or vent his anger first, then he cries. Luckily it's only within the family he does this and crying when his emotion is running all time high.
But for the rest of the things that I have asked him, he don't talk back if my request is reasonable. The only issue is when me or my husband dont walk the talk. He will sure quote examples and talk back. -
Hi Andaiz, Schellen & EN,
Glad to read about your posts..... Made me feel better that my DS1 is not the only one who behaves like tt.
EN : from what you described, DS1 is exactly same as yours !!
Frankly, DS1's frequent crying really gets on our nerves...... We always try to control... but but but .... very difficult !!
We are at our wit's end.... -
Emelyn:
I am not sure of your child's cirumstance. So I am just sharing some pointers.Hi Schellen,
Actually DS1 is not crying because he wants to have his way or get what he wants. We have passed that stage and he knows that whining or crying doesn't work on us.
He cries when he is upset.
For eg, he ran to the kitchen and along the way, he knocks down DS2. DS2 complained...and we told DS1 not to run and ask him to apologise to DS2. Well.... he will then start to cry...and say that he is not at fault.... DS2 was in his way....why we always say it is his fault.... etc. etc.
In my centre, we have this rule : 'You do not need to run in the centre because it is small enough and so do not need much time to walk from one end of a room to the farthest end of the last room. Whoever runs will have to practise walking properly five or more times'. So perhaps you may want to make it a rule that one cannnot run inside the house. Otherwise, you will have to practise walking . . .
Another point is that I have observed why some children cry immediately when they have done something wrong. Either they cry to let their parents know that they are already sorry ( the repentant one
) or they purposely cry loudly to soften their parents' heart, hoping that they would have pity on their wailing and so forgive or lessen the punishment meted (the cunning one
).
-
david59:
david59, there's also those who cry because they do not know how else to handle this (the limited-repertoir one :roll: ).[
Another point is that I have observed why some children cry immediately when they have done something wrong. Either they cry to let their parents know that they are already sorry ( the repentant one
) or they purposely cry loudly to soften their parents' heart, hoping that they would have pity on their wailing and so forgive or lessen the punishment meted (the cunning one
).
My DD1 is like that, so we have to continually ignore her cries and get her to do something constructive; i.e., move away from the scenario, or word her request differently... but that's for another thread.
Generally, the talking-back kind have great tenacity and are generally testing limits...
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login6
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects