P2 Math - General Discussion

[Tang]

vlim:

joconde:

[quote=\"mowmow\"]
Hi,

I think the question did not sound logical. Did Jenny exchange or give stamps with/to Jonathan? The story said \"exchanged\" while the question said \"gave\". So conflicting. If it was exchange, then Chiefkiasu's solution is correct.

It seems to me that the person who came out with this question lacks basic written communication skills and is incapable of presenting a problem clearly -- without causing confusion. I also find such problem with my child's school, both Math and Science. Maybe it's time MOE brush up subject teacher's communication skills !

'
aiyo yo isn't 'exchange' means i give u two and u give back two to me..... then so end up the both answer is still 355
.... the teacher who set this qn is either trying to be tricky (which I don't think so) or got language problem. :siao:[/quote]
I can exchange 1 (rare) stamp with 3 (more common) stamps with my friend. Hence exchange is not necessarily 1 for 1.

I can also exchange 1 duck for 2 chicken (if a duck is more expensive than a chicken).


Based on my understanding, I believe

\"She exchanged 56 stamps with Jonathan. Jonathan exhanged 44 stamps with her.\" is meant to be \"She exchanged 56 of her stamps with Jonathan for 44 of Jonathan's stamps.\"

\"a) How many stamps did Jenny have after giving some stamps to Jonathan?\" is meant to be \"How many stamps did Jenny have after handling over the stamps to Jonathan and before she got the exchanged stamps from Jonathan?\"

[Full.010894Cream]

Tang:

I can exchange 1 (rare) stamp with 3 (more common) stamps with my friend. Hence exchange is not necessarily 1 for 1.

I can also exchange 1 duck for 2 chicken (if a duck is more expensive than a chicken).

While I agree with u on this, ie, 'exchange' need not be one-for-one, the use of 'exchange' in that qn is definitely NOT appropriate.

[vlim]

Full.Cream:

Tang:

I can exchange 1 (rare) stamp with 3 (more common) stamps with my friend. Hence exchange is not necessarily 1 for 1.

I can also exchange 1 duck for 2 chicken (if a duck is more expensive than a chicken).

While I agree with u on this, ie, 'exchange' need not be one-for-one, the use of 'exchange' in that qn is definitely NOT appropriate.

ok.. then I think it would be more sound or more apppropriate to say' jenny exhange 56 with jonathon for 44 stamps...instead of putting it in two separate sentences.. very confusing and misleading :?

[Just4Fun]

//Moderator's note: Topics merged.


This is what my DS got for his Maths paper :
There were 6 cookies in each packet.
I bought 3 packets of cookies on Monday.
a, How many cookies did I buy on Monday ?
b, I bought 30 more cookies on Tuesday.
How many cookies did I buy altogether on both days ?

Answer to (b) ??? Can some one pls help on this ????
48 or 66 cookies shd be the correct answer ???? :?

[MMM]

I think 66 should be the correct answer.

[girlmum]

Just4Fun:

This is what my DS got for his Maths paper :

There were 6 cookies in each packet.
I bought 3 packets of cookies on Monday.
a, How many cookies did I buy on Monday ?
b, I bought 30 more cookies on Tuesday.
How many cookies did I buy altogether on both days ?

Answer to (b) ??? Can some one pls help on this ????
48 or 66 cookies shd be the correct answer ???? :?

I would think that the answer should be 66. (Mon 18 cookies, Tues 30 more ie 18+30 = 48, both days 18 + 48 = 66)
Hope I'm right

[Just4Fun]

That is what I hv thought, and this is what my DS had answered.

Unfortunately, this is not the correct answer ! ???

This question is quite ambiguous, isn’t it ?

[MMM]

So what is the answer??? Is it a issue with english sentence structuring rather than math???

[Just4Fun]

The answer fr the teacher is 48.


Yes, this shd be English words structuring issue ,right ?

[MMM]

Maybe you should feedback to the maths teacher. When they say 30 "MORE" than it’s usually on top of day 1. They should simply said, they bought 30 cookies (no need to add more).


Not forgetting, the maths teacher need to go for a english revision class.