MP echoes calls for PSLE to be scrapped
-
Kiasucy:
they have to work for it and prove with their result so why would it be a goody bag. Goody bag is like you attend a party and you are just given one. It will be less than 1% for not all GEP kids do well in the programme every year.[/quote]Nebbermind:
[quote=\"Kiasucy\"] Given the GEP papers are tougher and if the kids want to be exempted from PSLE they have to work hard to achieve above 80% and if they don't then they have to do PSLE lor... nothing comes free for them as usual, why would it breed elitism. From my observation after my ds attended GEP he still friend his mainstream classmates since P1 and still play regularly with his mainstream and GE classmates after school. I must say the ministry is very thougtful and successful in implementing the Tag class where GE and non-GE pupils sttend HCL and non-GE subjects togather.
I think we should stop giving out any more goodie bags to this 1%.
How were these elite selected as 1% ??? why are geppers 高人一等?Dont all P6 sit for the same national exam? -
KSP:
now P1/2 honeymoon coz no exam :imcool:
I feel that grade 6 (age 12) is too early for all children to be ready, to be mature enough, to sit for an important, national-level exam. Yet, to prevent the P1 registration process from becoming more high-stakes, we need some kind of testing at higher levels.nansk:
[quote=\"MMM\"]
We can have more \"through-train\" schools, where students gain entry to affiliated secondary schools without a common exam.
While solving one problem, we are creating another... Just imagine the pressure is now shifted to the already highly pressured P1 registration process. Parents now need to make sure their kids go to a school with a good affiliated secondary school...
My suggestion is to have primary schools go on till grade 8. Then conduct a PSLE-type exam at the end of 8th. Those two extra years will give most children time to mature and to appreciate the importance of being well-prepared for the PSLE.
:boogie:
P3/4 wakeup call for most
:nailbite:
P5/6 nightmare for most :yikes:
:imdrowning: :frustrated: :mad: :rant:
P7/8 ?? really can't imagine what will it like with another 2yrs of torture... :lightrod: :torchme:[/quote]夜长梦多??
-
Kiasucy:
they have to work for it and prove with their result so why would it be a goody bag. Goody bag is like you attend a party and you are just given one. It will be less than 1% for not all GEP kids do well in the programme every year.[/quote]The point is why should even 1 seat be given without proper justification.Nebbermind:
[quote=\"Kiasucy\"] Given the GEP papers are tougher and if the kids want to be exempted from PSLE they have to work hard to achieve above 80% and if they don't then they have to do PSLE lor... nothing comes free for them as usual, why would it breed elitism. From my observation after my ds attended GEP he still friend his mainstream classmates since P1 and still play regularly with his mainstream and GE classmates after school. I must say the ministry is very thougtful and successful in implementing the Tag class where GE and non-GE pupils sttend HCL and non-GE subjects togather.
Then what about the main streamers who work hard and consistently?
The DSA is already skewed to GEPper especially those who have above 80%. That is already the safety net they get for not getting time to focus on mainstream syllabus.
I think we should stop giving out any more goodie bags to this 1%.
-
jedamum:
i am calling for common papers staggering over three years..... :siam: :spank: so schs cannot overset or underset papers too difficult or too easy.[/quote]I get what you mean... so may be the P6 SA1 should a common papers thru out Singapore since it is to be used for DSA for mainstreamers as well. So if they can do very well, why not exempt them. But then the syllabus has got to finished before SA1 lor like they GEP syllabus ... won't it be too rush.
PSLE is suppose to be the common papers for all mainstreamers and giving them more time to prepare mah in Oct.Zann:
[quote=\"jedamum\"]
if GEP students who have achieved above 80% in GE exam can skip PSLE, why not get MOE to standardise and issue standard papers for mainstream too? then mainstreamers who have achieved above 80% in MS exam can skip PSLE and go for dsa like their GEP counterparts. then can save their time and energy and can particpate in CIP, leadership camp, character and team building programme, etc etc...
aren't the mainstreamers a viable group to implement skipping psle since bulk of tier 1-3 secondary schools consists mainly of mainstreamers who are consistent performers in pri schools? (ok, this is an assumption i make
) -
GLORYmum:
Nebbermind:
[quote=\"Kiasucy\"] Given the GEP papers are tougher and if the kids want to be exempted from PSLE they have to work hard to achieve above 80% and if they don't then they have to do PSLE lor... nothing comes free for them as usual, why would it breed elitism. From my observation after my ds attended GEP he still friend his mainstream classmates since P1 and still play regularly with his mainstream and GE classmates after school. I must say the ministry is very thougtful and successful in implementing the Tag class where GE and non-GE pupils sttend HCL and non-GE subjects togather.
I think we should stop giving out any more goodie bags to this 1%.
ABSOLUTELY AGREE !! kee ka kee chui ( Dr KSI, pls help me with the animation ) :please:[/quote]Kee ka kee qiu means you want to lie on your back and spin a breakdance? :evil:
-
GLORYmum:
Nebbermind:
[quote=\"Kiasucy\"] Given the GEP papers are tougher and if the kids want to be exempted from PSLE they have to work hard to achieve above 80% and if they don't then they have to do PSLE lor... nothing comes free for them as usual, why would it breed elitism. From my observation after my ds attended GEP he still friend his mainstream classmates since P1 and still play regularly with his mainstream and GE classmates after school. I must say the ministry is very thougtful and successful in implementing the Tag class where GE and non-GE pupils sttend HCL and non-GE subjects togather.
I think we should stop giving out any more goodie bags to this 1%.
ABSOLUTELY AGREE !! kee ka kee chui ( Dr KSI, pls help me with the animation ) :please:[/quote]I was trying to imagine what you looked like with 4 limbs in the air and choked on my sashimi. One must never read KSP whilst eating or drinking. -
Zann:
But wouldnt that be PSLE in disguise thenjedamum:
i am calling for common papers staggering over three years..... :siam: :spank: so schs cannot overset or underset papers too difficult or too easy.
I get what you mean... so may be the P6 SA1 should a common papers thru out Singapore since it is to be used for DSA for mainstreamers as well. So if they can do very well, why not exempt them. But then the syllabus has got to finished before SA1 lor like they GEP syllabus ... won't it be too rush.
-
Sun_2010:
But wouldnt that be PSLE in disguise thenZann:
[quote=\"jedamum\"] i am calling for common papers staggering over three years..... :siam: :spank: so schs cannot overset or underset papers too difficult or too easy.
I get what you mean... so may be the P6 SA1 should a common papers thru out Singapore since it is to be used for DSA for mainstreamers as well. So if they can do very well, why not exempt them. But then the syllabus has got to finished before SA1 lor like they GEP syllabus ... won't it be too rush.
[/quote]Yes and 3 years of it!! P4 finals, P5 finals and P6 finals?
May not be a bad idea...but I think parents die of stress first....
-
pirate:
Healthcare, community services for the elderly, science and technology development, to name a few.3Boys:
Schooling is but one part of societal needs. I guess since we are on KSP, the forum members might be sympathisers to such a position, but I am of the view that we already commit too much resources into education at the cost of other things.
Like what other things? Ministerial pay?
Hahaha, you must have foreseen this ping pong ball flying over from who else but your friendly neighbourhood pirate. :imanangel:
If you plot SG on a graph versus other developed countries, you will see we already spend more proportionately on education and less on healthcare. -
Chenonceau:
I was trying to imagine what you looked like with 4 limbs in the air and choked on my sashimi. One must never read KSP whilst eating or drinking.
can imagine wasabi coming thru your nostrils!! :rotflmao:
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login10
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects