Q&A - P2 English
-
both are right!
-
catgoh03:
both are right!
I would agree too, unless there is some context which we do not know about.
How about this - which of the following is correct?
\"Ryan and I went to the mall.\" vs
\"Ryan and me went to the mall.\"
and
\"Mummy brought Ryan and I to the mall.\" vs
\"Mummy brought Ryan and me to the mall.\"
Have fun
-
ChiefKiasu:
:?:
How about this - which of the following is correct?
\"Ryan and I went to the mall.\" vs
\"Ryan and me went to the mall.\"
Is Ryan and me went to the mall correct?
Cos when separated into 2 sentences, it seems to be Ryan went to the mall and me went to the mall. -
The right version should be:
\"Ryan and I went to the mall\", because when we split it into 2 sentences,
=> Ryan went to the mall
and I went to the mall
Also, \"Mummy brought Ryan and me to the mall\" is correct, because
=> Mummy brought Ryan to the mall
and Mummy brought me to the mall
There are exception cases, where the sentence can take on very different meanings, such as:
\"Mummy loves Ryan more than me.\"
=> Ryan is Mummy's favorite child
\"Mummy loves Ryan more than I.\"
=> I like Ryan, but not as much as Mummy.
Ain't English wonderful?? -
My girl wrote Answer 1 but her teacher marked her wrong. The given answer was Answer 2.
Any comments? -
Sarah:
Answer 2 is the more \"sensible\" answer, but there is nothing wrong with answer 1 in either grammar or semantics. Can go argue with teacherMy girl wrote Answer 1 but her teacher marked her wrong. The given answer was Answer 2.
Any comments? .
-
Sarah:
Er...maybe because local public buses are seldom on time in reaching their intended bus-stops, so there is no way to cite being late at the bus-stop as a reason to miss the bus?My girl wrote Answer 1 but her teacher marked her wrong. The given answer was Answer 2.
Any comments?
Nay..pardon my nonsense.
-
jedamum:
I sort of agree with your argument.
Er...maybe because local public buses are seldom on time in reaching their intended bus-stops, so there is no way to cite being late at the bus-stop as a reason to miss the bus?Sarah:
My girl wrote Answer 1 but her teacher marked her wrong. The given answer was Answer 2.
Any comments?
Nay..pardon my nonsense. -
If there is a ‘school’ prefix for the bus, then ( a ) would be more correct since school bus comes at a designated time.
However, in the generic sense, ( b ) seems more apt as one usually needs to give a reason for being late. -
Answer2 should be correct as he missed the bus ( reason) 1st, that is why he was late.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login